'Varnashrama dharma has no place in the modern world.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Hindu teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some people, including some Hindus, would agree that varnashrama dharma has no place in the modern world. Over many centuries, the idea of varna became linked to birth-based castes (jatis) and to untouchability, which caused terrible injustice. Untouchability was abolished by the constitution of India in 1950, and caste discrimination is illegal there, while reformers such as Gandhi and many Hindus today have campaigned against caste prejudice. The Bhagavad Gita (5.18) teaches that the wise see all beings with an equal eye, which seems to rule out treating anyone as inferior. In modern societies such as Britain, people choose their own careers, and the four varnas do not fit today's jobs. The ashrama system can also seem out of date: very few people become sannyasis, and its traditional rules were written for men in an ancient society.
However, many Hindus would argue that the ideals behind varnashrama dharma are still valuable. The four ashramas give a helpful pattern for life: education and discipline when young, work and family in adulthood, and a gradual shift to spiritual matters in old age, which many Hindus still follow in a flexible way. Many Hindus also understand varna as describing a person's qualities and actions, not their birth, following the Bhagavad Gita (4.13), so it encourages people to use their natural talents to serve society. For much of his life, Gandhi defended an ideal of varna as different duties of equal worth, while campaigning against untouchability. The idea that everyone has duties suited to their role and stage of life is also a useful balance to a culture that focuses mainly on individual rights.
In conclusion, I think that the birth-based caste hierarchy that grew out of varna has no place in the modern world and is rightly illegal in India. However, the ashramas and the ideal of doing one's own duty according to one's abilities can still guide Hindus today. So I partly disagree with the statement: varnashrama dharma should be reinterpreted rather than rejected completely, keeping its idea of duty while rejecting all discrimination.
Explanation
Strong answers separate the two parts of varnashrama dharma, the ashramas and varna, and distinguish the ideal of varna from birth-based caste discrimination, which is illegal in India and opposed by many Hindus. Apply teachings such as Bhagavad Gita 4.13 and 5.18 to the statement. Write about caste factually and respectfully, and reach a conclusion that follows from the arguments.