'A murti is only a symbol of God.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Hindu teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Hindus would agree that a murti is only a symbol of God. The Upanishads teach that Brahman is beyond all form, and the Kena Upanishad says that Brahman is not the thing that people worship here, but the reality behind all things. Followers of Advaita therefore see the murti as an aid for the mind, which helps people who cannot yet meditate on Brahman without form; the Bhagavad Gita (12.5) admits that worshipping the unmanifest is hard for embodied beings. The Arya Samaj goes further and rejects murti worship completely. Many Hindus also point out that clay murtis made for Ganesh Chaturthi are immersed in water after the festival, showing that God is not tied to the image, and some compare a murti to a photograph of a loved one: precious, but not the person.
However, many Hindus would say that a murti is much more than a symbol. In the prana pratishtha ceremony priests invite the deity into the murti and open its eyes, and from then on the deity is believed to be present. Sri Vaishnavas teach that the temple murti is the archa avatara, a real descent of God, who chooses out of compassion to dwell in a form that devotees can see, touch and serve, and ISKCON teaches that the temple deity is not different from Krishna. This is why temple murtis are woken, bathed, dressed and fed every day, and why darshan is a two-way seeing in which the deity looks at the worshipper. In the Gita (4.11) Krishna says he responds to people in the way they approach him, so God can truly be met through the murti.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement, mainly because of the word 'only'. Hindus do not believe that the stone or metal itself is God, so the murti is never simply an 'idol'. But for most Hindus a consecrated murti is a place where God is really present, not just a reminder. The statement fits the views of the Arya Samaj and some followers of Advaita, but not the experience of most Hindu worshippers.
Explanation
Top answers contrast the view that the murti is a symbol or aid (Advaita, Arya Samaj) with belief in the deity's real presence after prana pratishtha (Sri Vaishnava archa avatara, ISKCON), and test the word 'only'. Avoid calling murtis 'idols' or saying Hindus worship statues as God. A conclusion that follows from the arguments, not just a summary, is needed for Level 4.