'Ahimsa means Hindus should never use violence.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Hindu teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Hindus would agree with the statement. The Mahabharata calls ahimsa the highest dharma, and the Laws of Manu (10.63) list it first among the duties for everyone. Because the same atman is present in every living being, any act of violence harms a soul like one's own and creates bad karma that will bring suffering in this or a future life. Mahatma Gandhi believed that ahimsa should be practised without exception and showed through his campaigns of non-violent resistance that it could challenge injustice without bloodshed. Patanjali's Yoga Sutras (2.35) teach that hostility disappears in the presence of someone firmly established in non-violence, suggesting that ahimsa is more powerful than force.
However, many other Hindus believe that violence is sometimes necessary to uphold dharma. In the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna tells Arjuna, a kshatriya (warrior), that he must fight in a righteous war, because protecting society is his duty (2.31-33), and Krishna himself says that he comes into the world to destroy the wicked and restore dharma (4.8). Rama fought Ravana to rescue Sita, and the goddess Durga is worshipped for destroying the demon Mahishasura. The Laws of Manu (8.349) even state that a person who kills in self-defence or to protect others 'in the cause of right' commits no sin. For these Hindus, ahimsa means never causing harm out of hatred, anger or selfishness, rather than refusing to protect the innocent. Many Hindus serve in the police and armed forces, believing that preventing greater violence is part of their dharma.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Ahimsa is a central Hindu virtue, and violence should always be the last resort. However, Hindu scripture clearly allows force to defend the innocent and restore dharma, so ahimsa does not mean that Hindus should never use violence. The best understanding is that ahimsa forbids harmful intentions and unnecessary violence, while recognising that, in rare cases, protecting others is the greater good.
Explanation
Top answers weigh the ideal of ahimsa (Gandhi, the Mahabharata, the atman in all beings) against teachings that allow force, such as Krishna's instruction to Arjuna and the duty of a kshatriya, and reach a reasoned judgement. Apply each teaching directly to the word 'never'. A common weakness is to describe ahimsa at length without considering situations such as self-defence or a righteous war.