Read the following extract from Chapter 5 of The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde and then answer the question that follows.
In this extract, Sir Danvers Carew has been murdered and Hyde has disappeared. Utterson has gone to Jekyll's house and, for the first time, has been taken through the laboratory to Jekyll's private cabinet, where he finds his friend "looking deathly sick". Utterson has just asked whether Jekyll has heard the news.
The doctor shuddered. "They were crying it in the square," he said. "I heard them in my dining-room."
"One word," said the lawyer. "Carew was my client, but so are you, and I want to know what I am doing. You have not been mad enough to hide this fellow?"
"Utterson, I swear to God," cried the doctor, "I swear to God I will never set eyes on him again. I bind my honour to you that I am done with him in this world. It is all at an end. And indeed he does not want my help; you do not know him as I do; he is safe, he is quite safe; mark my words, he will never more be heard of."
The lawyer listened gloomily; he did not like his friend's feverish manner. "You seem pretty sure of him," said he; "and for your sake, I hope you may be right. If it came to a trial, your name might appear."
"I am quite sure of him," replied Jekyll; "I have grounds for certainty that I cannot share with any one. But there is one thing on which you may advise me. I have - I have received a letter; and I am at a loss whether I should show it to the police. I should like to leave it in your hands, Utterson; you would judge wisely, I am sure; I have so great a trust in you."
"You fear, I suppose, that it might lead to his detection?" asked the lawyer.
"No," said the other. "I cannot say that I care what becomes of Hyde; I am quite done with him. I was thinking of my own character, which this hateful business has rather exposed."
Utterson ruminated awhile; he was surprised at his friend's selfishness, and yet relieved by it. "Well," said he, at last, "let me see the letter."
The letter was written in an odd, upright hand and signed "Edward Hyde": and it signified, briefly enough, that the writer's benefactor, Dr. Jekyll, whom he had long so unworthily repaid for a thousand generosities, need labour under no alarm for his safety, as he had means of escape on which he placed a sure dependence. The lawyer liked this letter well enough; it put a better colour on the intimacy than he had looked for; and he blamed himself for some of his past suspicions.
Starting with this extract, explore how Stevenson presents the friendship between Utterson and Jekyll in The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde.
Write about:
- how Stevenson presents the friendship between Utterson and Jekyll in this extract
- how Stevenson presents the friendship between Utterson and Jekyll in the novel as a whole.
Model answer
Stevenson presents the friendship between Utterson and Jekyll as old, deep and loyal, but strangely silent. Jekyll says he trusts Utterson more than anyone, yet he never tells him the truth; Utterson cares enough to risk his own reputation for his friend, yet he repeatedly chooses not to know. Through the two men Stevenson explores the strengths and the limits of Victorian male friendship, in which loyalty and discretion count for more than honesty.
The extract shows the friendship under pressure. Utterson begins bluntly: "Carew was my client, but so are you, and I want to know what I am doing." He is torn between professional duty and personal loyalty, and his question, "You have not been mad enough to hide this fellow?", is direct in a way the novel's gentlemen rarely are. Jekyll replies with a burst of oaths: "I swear to God I will never set eyes on him again. I bind my honour to you". The repetition of "I swear to God" and the language of honour make this a gentleman's pledge to a friend, yet the reader suspects that such vows are exactly what Jekyll cannot keep.
Utterson's response shows his care. He listens "gloomily" and dislikes "his friend's feverish manner", but his warning is protective: "for your sake, I hope you may be right. If it came to a trial, your name might appear." Friendship here means guarding a reputation. Jekyll, meanwhile, keeps his secret even while praising his friend: he has "grounds for certainty that I cannot share with any one", and in the same speech says, "I have so great a trust in you." Trust becomes a way of handing Utterson a difficult decision (Jekyll soon adds, "I wish you to judge for me entirely") while the real truth is withheld.
The most revealing moment is Jekyll's admission that he is not worried about Hyde's capture: "I was thinking of my own character, which this hateful business has rather exposed." Utterson is "surprised at his friend's selfishness, and yet relieved by it". The paradox is telling. Selfishness should disappoint a friend, but Utterson is relieved because it suggests that Jekyll is no longer shielding Hyde. His loyalty makes him read every sign in Jekyll's favour: when he sees the letter in its "odd, upright hand", he "blamed himself for some of his past suspicions". The dramatic irony is painful, because the reader already sees more than the loyal friend allows himself to see.
Across the novel the friendship follows this pattern of devotion and exclusion. In Chapter 2 Utterson is driven by love for "poor Harry", resolving to "put my shoulder to the wheel - if Jekyll will but let me"; the repeated condition, "if Jekyll will only let me", shows that a friend can help only as far as he is allowed in. In Chapter 3 Jekyll says he would trust Utterson "before any man alive, ay, before myself", but asks him to drop the subject and to promise to protect Hyde. Utterson's loyalty becomes something close to complicity when he locks Guest's evidence in his safe. During Jekyll's good months in Chapter 6 the friends meet "almost daily", but then the door is shut, and Jekyll's letter asks Utterson not to "doubt my friendship, if my door is often shut even to you" and to "respect my silence". At the window in Chapter 7, Utterson still believes that "the presence of a friend might do him good".
The friendship reaches its crisis in Chapter 8. The man who has always respected his friend's privacy calls out, "I demand to see you", and breaks down the door with Poole. Silence has failed, and only force can reach the truth. Even so, the bond is honoured: the new will names "Gabriel John Utterson" in place of Hyde, the note is signed "Your unworthy and unhappy friend", and Jekyll's full statement is written for him. The friendship ends as it was lived, with Utterson receiving in writing what Jekyll could never say to his face.
Stevenson sets this friendship in a largely male world of bachelor professionals, where friends are made young and kept for life, as Utterson reminds Lanyon: "We are three very old friends, Lanyon; we shall not live to make others." Victorian codes of honour meant that a gentleman did not pry into a friend's private life, and Stevenson shows the cost of that code. Utterson's loyalty is genuine and moving, but because he will not ask and Jekyll will not tell, the friendship can comfort Jekyll without ever being able to save him.