Read the following extract from Act 5 Scene 1 of Much Ado About Nothing and then answer the question that follows.
At this point in the play, Benedick has promised Beatrice that he will challenge Claudio, who shamed Hero at their wedding and believes that she has since died. Claudio and Don Pedro have just refused to fight Leonato and his brother Antonio, and they have been looking for Benedick to cheer them up.
BENEDICK.
Shall I speak a word in your ear?
CLAUDIO.
God bless me from a challenge!
BENEDICK.
[Aside to Claudio.] You are a villain, I jest not: I will
make it good how you dare, with what you dare, and when you dare. Do me
right, or I will protest your cowardice. You have killed a sweet lady, and
her death shall fall heavy on you. Let me hear from you.
CLAUDIO.
Well I will meet you, so I may have good cheer.
DON PEDRO.
What, a feast, a feast?
CLAUDIO.
I' faith, I thank him; he hath bid me to a calf's-head
and a capon, the which if I do not carve most curiously, say my knife's
naught. Shall I not find a woodcock too?
BENEDICK.
Sir, your wit ambles well; it goes easily.
DON PEDRO.
I'll tell thee how Beatrice praised thy wit the
other day. I said, thou hadst a fine wit. 'True,' says
she, 'a fine little one.' 'No,' said I,
'a great wit.' 'Right,' said she, 'a
great gross one.' 'Nay,' said I, 'a good wit.'
'Just,' said she, 'it hurts nobody.' 'Nay,'
said I, 'the gentleman is wise.' 'Certain,'
said she, 'a wise gentleman.' 'Nay,' said I,
'he hath the tongues.' 'That I believe' said
she, 'for he swore a thing to me on Monday night, which he
forswore on Tuesday morning: there's a double tongue; there's
two tongues.' Thus did she, an hour together, trans-shape thy
particular virtues; yet at last she concluded with a sigh, thou wast
the properest man in Italy.
CLAUDIO.
For the which she wept heartily and said she cared not.
DON PEDRO.
Yea, that she did; but yet, for all that, an if she did not
hate him deadly, she would love him dearly. The old man's daughter
told us all.
CLAUDIO.
All, all; and moreover, God saw him when he was hid in the garden.
DON PEDRO.
But when shall we set the savage bull's horns on the
sensible Benedick's head?
CLAUDIO.
Yea, and text underneath, 'Here dwells Benedick the
married man!'
BENEDICK.
Fare you well, boy: you know my mind. I will leave you now to
your gossip-like humour; you break jests as braggarts do their blades,
which, God be thanked, hurt not. My lord, for your many courtesies I thank
you: I must discontinue your company. Your brother the bastard is fled
from Messina: you have, among you, killed a sweet and innocent lady. For
my Lord Lack-beard there, he and I shall meet; and till then, peace be
with him.
Starting with this conversation, explore how Shakespeare presents friendship and loyalty between men in Much Ado About Nothing.
Write about:
- how Shakespeare presents friendship and loyalty between men in this conversation
- how Shakespeare presents friendship and loyalty between men in the play as a whole.
[30 marks]
AO4
Model answer
Male friendship holds the world of Much Ado About Nothing together. Don Pedro, Claudio and Benedick have fought side by side, and their bond is expressed through shared jokes, favours and loyalty to their prince. Yet Shakespeare shows that this friendship is more fragile than it looks: it breaks at the first suspicion, and it can blind men to justice. In this conversation the bond between Benedick and his comrades is broken, and the cause is not rivalry but conscience.
The scene is built on contrast. Claudio and Don Pedro have just humiliated Leonato and Antonio and expect the usual banter from Benedick. Instead he delivers his challenge in a private aside: "You are a villain; I jest not." The plain statement rejects the language of jest that has defined their friendship. The repeated "dare" in "how you dare, with what you dare, and when you dare" uses the formal language of a duel, and "Do me right, or I will protest your cowardice" threatens Claudio where a soldier is most vulnerable, his reputation for courage. The final charge, "You have killed a sweet lady, and her death shall fall heavy on you", puts loyalty to the truth above loyalty to a friend.
Claudio cannot take it seriously. He turns the challenge into an invitation to a feast - Benedick "hath bid me to a calf's-head and a capon" - and jokes about finding "a woodcock too". A calf's head suggests a fool, a capon is a castrated cockerel and a woodcock was proverbially easy to trap, so Claudio insults Benedick even as he laughs. Benedick's dry reply, "Sir, your wit ambles well; it goes easily", compares Claudio's wit to an ambling horse: comfortable but lightweight. Don Pedro joins in with a long story of Beatrice mocking Benedick's wit, and the two friends revive the jokes of Act 1 about "the savage bull's horns" and "Benedick the married man". The callback shows how this friendship has always worked, through shared mockery, and it also shows their insensitivity, since they are joking so soon after what they believe to be Hero's death.
Benedick's final speech ends the friendship formally. He calls Claudio "boy", a deliberate insult to a soldier, and says that his comrades "break jests as braggarts do their blades, which, God be thanked, hurt not": their wit is all show. To his prince he is coldly courteous: "My lord, for your many courtesies I thank you: I must discontinue your company." Then come the facts his friends have ignored: "Your brother the bastard is fled from Messina: you have, among you, killed a sweet and innocent lady." The phrase "among you" shares the guilt between them. When he leaves, Don Pedro can only say, "He is in earnest", as if earnestness were the strangest thing a friend could show.
The friendship began generously. In Act 1 Don Pedro tells Claudio, "My love is thine to teach", and offers to woo Hero for him, while Beatrice jokes that Benedick will "hang upon him like a disease". But at the masked ball, when Don John suggests that Don Pedro is wooing Hero for himself, Claudio believes it at once and decides that "Friendship is constant in all other things" except love. Don Pedro's reply to Benedick's teasing, "I will but teach them to sing, and restore them to the owner", shows his integrity, but Claudio's readiness to doubt his friend foreshadows his readiness to doubt Hero. When Don John slanders her, the two men's loyalty becomes a joint vow: "I will join with thee to disgrace her." Male solidarity is turned into a weapon against a woman.
Benedick's choice is prepared in the church, where he tells Leonato that although his "inwardness and love" belong to the Prince and Claudio, he will deal justly. His first answer to "Kill Claudio", "Ha! not for the wide world", shows how much the friendship means, which is why his decision matters so much. The villains offer a dark parody of loyalty: Conrade promises to help Don John "To the death, my lord", but Borachio is paid "a thousand ducats", so their loyalty is bought. At the end friendship is restored on new terms. Benedick tells Claudio to "live unbruised, and love my cousin", adding, "Come, come, we are friends", while Don Pedro, alone and "sad", is told to get a wife. The bond survives, but it now includes the women it once shut out.
In Renaissance culture friendship between men was often idealised as the highest human bond, sometimes placed above love for women, and a gentleman's loyalty to his lord was a matter of honour. Shakespeare tests that ideal. Claudio's and Don Pedro's loyalty to each other is genuine, but it makes them partners in injustice, while Benedick shows that the deeper loyalty is to the truth. The play suggests that a friendship worth having must survive honesty, and that being a true friend can sometimes mean issuing a challenge.