Read the following extract from Act 4 Scene 3 of Macbeth and then answer the question that follows.
At this point in the play, Macduff has come to England to urge Duncan's son Malcolm to return and fight Macbeth. Malcolm, suspicious that Macduff could be Macbeth's agent, has been testing him by pretending to be full of vices.
MALCOLM.
But I have none: the king-becoming graces,
As justice, verity, temp'rance, stableness,
Bounty, perseverance, mercy, lowliness,
Devotion, patience, courage, fortitude,
I have no relish of them; but abound
In the division of each several crime,
Acting it many ways. Nay, had I power, I should
Pour the sweet milk of concord into hell,
Uproar the universal peace, confound
All unity on earth.
MACDUFF.
O Scotland, Scotland!
MALCOLM.
If such a one be fit to govern, speak:
I am as I have spoken.
MACDUFF.
Fit to govern?
No, not to live. - O nation miserable,
With an untitled tyrant bloody-scepter'd,
When shalt thou see thy wholesome days again,
Since that the truest issue of thy throne
By his own interdiction stands accus'd,
And does blaspheme his breed? Thy royal father
Was a most sainted king. The queen that bore thee,
Oft'ner upon her knees than on her feet,
Died every day she lived. Fare thee well!
These evils thou repeat'st upon thyself
Have banish'd me from Scotland. - O my breast,
Thy hope ends here!
MALCOLM.
Macduff, this noble passion,
Child of integrity, hath from my soul
Wiped the black scruples, reconcil'd my thoughts
To thy good truth and honour.
Starting with this conversation, explore how Shakespeare presents ideas about what makes a good king in Macbeth.
Write about:
- how Shakespeare presents ideas about kingship in this conversation
- how Shakespeare presents ideas about what makes a good king in the play as a whole.
[30 marks]
AO4
Model answer
Macbeth is a play about kingship, and Shakespeare defines a good king largely through contrast: Duncan's gracious but trusting rule, Macbeth's tyranny, the holy Edward of England, and the tested virtue of Malcolm. In this conversation Malcolm lists the "king-becoming graces", giving the audience the play's clearest definition of good kingship, and the scene also shows that a good king needs the wisdom to test appearances - the wisdom Duncan lacked.
Malcolm's list is a catalogue of twelve virtues without a single conjunction: "justice, verity, temp'rance, stableness, / Bounty, perseverance, mercy, lowliness, / Devotion, patience, courage, fortitude". The asyndeton makes the list feel exhaustive and weighty, like a moral code. Notably, "courage" comes near the end. Macbeth had courage in abundance - he was "brave Macbeth" - but lacked almost everything else, so Shakespeare suggests that a warrior's bravery is not enough to make a king. "Lowliness" and "mercy" stand in pointed contrast to Macbeth's pride and cruelty.
Malcolm then describes a bad king in cosmic terms: with power, he would "Pour the sweet milk of concord into hell, / Uproar the universal peace". The "milk of concord" recalls Lady Macbeth's scorn for the "milk of human kindness": a tyrant poisons the nurturing harmony that should flow from the throne. This is exactly what Macbeth has done, so Malcolm's pretended self-portrait is really a portrait of the present king.
Macduff's reaction proves his integrity. His apostrophe, "O Scotland, Scotland!", shows that his loyalty is to the nation, not to a person. Asked whether such a man is fit to govern, he answers absolutely: "Fit to govern? / No, not to live." Scotland is a "nation miserable" under "an untitled tyrant bloody-scepter'd": "untitled" means without lawful right, and the compound fuses the sceptre, symbol of rule, with blood. By contrast, he remembers Duncan as "a most sainted king" and Malcolm's mother as "Oft'ner upon her knees than on her feet". Holiness and prayer are presented as royal qualities.
The scene's twist adds a further virtue: discernment. Malcolm reveals that Macduff's "noble passion, / Child of integrity" has "Wiped the black scruples" from his soul; he was testing him because "Devilish Macbeth" has tried to trap him before. Duncan admitted that "There's no art / To find the mind's construction in the face" and paid for his trust with his life. His son has learned to look beneath the surface. Some audiences find Malcolm's deception uncomfortable, but Shakespeare presents it as necessary caution in a kingdom full of spies.
Elsewhere Duncan represents generous kingship. He rewards loyalty - "I have begun to plant thee" - and even Macbeth admits that Duncan's virtues "Will plead like angels" against his murder. Macbeth's reign is the opposite. He rules by fear, keeping "a servant fee'd" in every noble's house, and his people suffer: "Each new morn / New widows howl, new orphans cry". By Act 5 his soldiers obey "only in command, / Nothing in love", and his title hangs "like a giant's robe / Upon a dwarfish thief".
The ideal is completed by Edward the Confessor, whose healing touch is "A most miraculous work in this good king" and who has "a heavenly gift of prophecy" - holy prophecy set against the witches' riddles. Malcolm's final speech shows him putting the graces into practice: he rewards his thanes, promises to call home exiles, and vows to act "by the grace of Grace" in "measure, time, and place", the language of order and moderation.
These ideas reflect contemporary thinking. Under the divine right of kings the monarch was God's deputy, which is why Duncan is "sainted" and Edward can heal. James I's Basilikon Doron, written as advice to his son, distinguished a lawful king, who knows he is ordained for his people, from a tyrant, who thinks his people are ordained for him. Macbeth's declaration "For mine own good / All causes shall give way" is the tyrant's creed exactly. James also continued the royal touch for 'the King's evil', so the praise of Edward flattered the reigning king. Shakespeare presents good kingship as a union of virtue, piety, service and wisdom - the qualities Malcolm lists, Duncan partly embodies, Edward perfects and Macbeth destroys.