Read the following extract from Chapter 18 of Great Expectations and then answer the question that follows.
In this extract, Mr Jaggers, a London lawyer, has come to the forge to tell Pip that he has "great expectations": an unnamed benefactor wishes him to be brought up as a gentleman. Joe has said that he wants nothing for himself, and Jaggers has just offered Pip twenty guineas for new clothes.
He produced a long purse, with the greatest coolness, and counted them out on the table and pushed them over to me. This was the first time he had taken his leg from the chair. He sat astride of the chair when he had pushed the money over, and sat swinging his purse and eyeing Joe.
"Well, Joseph Gargery? You look dumbfoundered?"
"I am!" said Joe, in a very decided manner.
"It was understood that you wanted nothing for yourself, remember?"
"It were understood," said Joe. "And it are understood. And it ever will be similar according."
"But what," said Mr. Jaggers, swinging his purse, - "what if it was in my instructions to make you a present, as compensation?"
"As compensation what for?" Joe demanded.
"For the loss of his services."
Joe laid his hand upon my shoulder with the touch of a woman. I have often thought him since, like the steam-hammer that can crush a man or pat an egg-shell, in his combination of strength with gentleness. "Pip is that hearty welcome," said Joe, "to go free with his services, to honour and fortun', as no words can tell him. But if you think as Money can make compensation to me for the loss of the little child - what come to the forge - and ever the best of friends! - "
O dear good Joe, whom I was so ready to leave and so unthankful to, I see you again, with your muscular blacksmith's arm before your eyes, and your broad chest heaving, and your voice dying away. O dear good faithful tender Joe, I feel the loving tremble of your hand upon my arm, as solemnly this day as if it had been the rustle of an angel's wing!
But I encouraged Joe at the time. I was lost in the mazes of my future fortunes, and could not retrace the by-paths we had trodden together. I begged Joe to be comforted, for (as he said) we had ever been the best of friends, and (as I said) we ever would be so. Joe scooped his eyes with his disengaged wrist, as if he were bent on gouging himself, but said not another word.
Mr. Jaggers had looked on at this, as one who recognised in Joe the village idiot, and in me his keeper.
'In Great Expectations, money does more harm than good.'
Starting with this extract, explore how far you agree with this view.
Write about:
- how Dickens presents attitudes to money in this extract
- how far Dickens presents money as doing more harm than good in the novel as a whole.
Model answer
Money drives the storyline of Great Expectations, and much of the time it does harm: it makes Pip a snob, separates him from Joe, sinks him into debt and draws predators to Miss Havisham. I largely agree with the view. Yet Dickens draws a careful distinction. Money that is unearned and used to buy status corrupts; money that is earned honestly, or given quietly out of love, can do real good.
The extract sets two attitudes to money side by side. Jaggers produces "a long purse, with the greatest coolness", counts out the guineas and sits "swinging his purse and eyeing Joe". The swinging purse is like bait: Jaggers expects money to settle everything. His word "compensation" turns Pip into a commercial asset, payment "For the loss of his services", as if Joe had lost an apprentice rather than a child.
Joe's reply overturns that logic. He lays his hand on Pip's shoulder "with the touch of a woman", and the narrator compares him to "the steam-hammer that can crush a man or pat an egg-shell", an industrial image of huge strength controlled by tenderness. Joe's speech breaks down under emotion: "if you think as Money can make compensation to me for the loss of the little child". The capital letter turns "Money" into a rival power, and the dashes and unfinished sentence show that love cannot be translated into the language of trade. Jaggers, who regards Joe as "the village idiot" and Pip as "his keeper", cannot understand him.
The older narrator then interrupts with a burst of guilt: "O dear good Joe, whom I was so ready to leave and so unthankful to". The apostrophe and the image of "the rustle of an angel's wing" make Joe almost holy, but the young Pip "was lost in the mazes of my future fortunes" and "could not retrace the by-paths we had trodden together." The metaphor of a maze suggests that money has already begun to lead Pip away from the paths he shared with Joe. Even within the extract, the promise of wealth damages the most important relationship in Pip's life.
The rest of the novel largely confirms this. In London Pip and Herbert "spent as much money as we could", yet Pip admits "we were always more or less miserable", and his "lavish habits" lead Herbert into "expenses that he could not afford". Money changes how others behave, too: Pumblechook and Trabb fawn on Pip once he is rich. At Satis House, wealth made Miss Havisham the target of Compeyson, who "got great sums of money from her", and her relations flatter her only in the hope of inheriting. Even Magwitch, who "lived rough" so that Pip could "live smooth", believes that Estella can be his boy's "if money can buy 'em". His fortune draws him back to England and to his death, and it is "forfeited to the Crown".
But Dickens does not condemn money itself. The one generous use Pip makes of his fortune is to buy Herbert a partnership in secret, which he later calls "the only good thing I had done". Wemmick's advice to "Get hold of portable property" sits beside his loving care for his father at Walworth. Most movingly, Joe settles Pip's debt and leaves only a receipt and a short note. Money given quietly, without any wish for status or control, heals instead of harming.
The ending makes the distinction clear. Pip works abroad with Herbert and tells Estella, "I work pretty hard for a sufficient living"; the firm "had a good name, and worked for our profits". Written in 1860-61, soon after Samuel Smiles's Self-Help (1859) had praised men who rose by their own effort, the novel contrasts unearned expectations with honest work. Dickens, whose father had been imprisoned for debt, knew how money troubles could break a family.
So the view is largely right. In Great Expectations money that is unearned and spent on appearances does far more harm than good, but money earned honestly, or given in secret love, becomes one of the ways in which characters reveal their goodness.