Read the following extract from Chapter 5 of The Sign of Four and then answer the question that follows.
In this extract, Holmes, Watson and Thaddeus Sholto have climbed to the locked door of Bartholomew Sholto's room at Pondicherry Lodge. Holmes has looked through the keyhole and said, "There is something devilish in this, Watson."
I stooped to the hole, and recoiled in horror. Moonlight was streaming into the room, and it was bright with a vague and shifty radiance. Looking straight at me, and suspended, as it were, in the air, for all beneath was in shadow, there hung a face, - the very face of our companion Thaddeus. There was the same high, shining head, the same circular bristle of red hair, the same bloodless countenance. The features were set, however, in a horrible smile, a fixed and unnatural grin, which in that still and moonlit room was more jarring to the nerves than any scowl or contortion. So like was the face to that of our little friend that I looked round at him to make sure that he was indeed with us. Then I recalled to mind that he had mentioned to us that his brother and he were twins.
"This is terrible!" I said to Holmes. "What is to be done?"
"The door must come down," he answered, and, springing against it, he put all his weight upon the lock. It creaked and groaned, but did not yield. Together we flung ourselves upon it once more, and this time it gave way with a sudden snap, and we found ourselves within Bartholomew Sholto's chamber.
It appeared to have been fitted up as a chemical laboratory. A double line of glass-stoppered bottles was drawn up upon the wall opposite the door, and the table was littered over with Bunsen burners, test-tubes, and retorts. In the corners stood carboys of acid in wicker baskets. One of these appeared to leak or to have been broken, for a stream of dark-coloured liquid had trickled out from it, and the air was heavy with a peculiarly pungent, tar-like odour. A set of steps stood at one side of the room, in the midst of a litter of lath and plaster, and above them there was an opening in the ceiling large enough for a man to pass through. At the foot of the steps a long coil of rope was thrown carelessly together.
By the table, in a wooden arm-chair, the master of the house was seated all in a heap, with his head sunk upon his left shoulder, and that ghastly, inscrutable smile upon his face. He was stiff and cold, and had clearly been dead many hours. It seemed to me that not only his features but all his limbs were twisted and turned in the most fantastic fashion. By his hand upon the table there lay a peculiar instrument, - a brown, close-grained stick, with a stone head like a hammer, rudely lashed on with coarse twine.
Starting with this extract, explore how Conan Doyle uses elements of horror in The Sign of Four.
Write about:
- how Conan Doyle creates horror in this extract
- how Conan Doyle uses elements of horror in the novel as a whole.
Model answer
Conan Doyle borrows the language and settings of Gothic horror to thrill his readers, but he places them inside a detective story in which every horror must finally be explained. In this extract the shock of Bartholomew Sholto's death is built through Watson's reactions, the uncanny image of a double and a sequence of sensory details, before the scene turns into a chemical laboratory and the supernatural gives way to the scientific.
The extract opens with Watson's physical response: he "recoiled in horror". As a narrator he reacts as the reader is meant to, so his fear becomes ours. The setting is classic Gothic. Moonlight fills the room with "a vague and shifty radiance", and "all beneath was in shadow", so what Watson sees seems "suspended, as it were, in the air". The verb "hung" and the long sentence that delays its subject - "there hung a face" - make the reader wait for the horror, as in a ghost story.
The face is horrifying because it is familiar: it is "the very face of our companion Thaddeus". The repetition of "the same" ("the same high, shining head, the same circular bristle of red hair") creates an uncanny double, and Watson even looks round to make sure Thaddeus is still beside him. The Gothic motif of the double suggests that one brother is looking at his own death. The worst detail is the expression: "a horrible smile, a fixed and unnatural grin". The oxymoron of a horrible smile is more disturbing than an obvious sign of pain, and Watson says it was "more jarring to the nerves than any scowl or contortion".
The violence of breaking in - the door "creaked and groaned" as if alive - leads to a sudden change of register. The room is "a chemical laboratory" with "glass-stoppered bottles", "Bunsen burners, test-tubes, and retorts". The scientific list seems reassuring, but a carboy has leaked, and "the air was heavy with a peculiarly pungent, tar-like odour". Smell adds to the sense of corruption, and this dark liquid will later be the creosote that Toby follows, so a detail of horror is also a clue. Finally the body is revealed "all in a heap", with "that ghastly, inscrutable smile", "stiff and cold", his limbs "twisted and turned in the most fantastic fashion". The adjective "inscrutable" keeps the mystery alive, and the primitive weapon "rudely lashed on with coarse twine" introduces something alien into the English house.
Across the novel, horror arrives in a series of shocks. Thaddeus's story of his father's death climaxes with the cry "Keep him out!" and a face at the window with "wild cruel eyes". Holmes, usually so calm, calls the locked room "something devilish", and Watson reads the words "The sign of the four" "with a thrill of horror". In the garret he sees prints of a naked foot "scarce half the size" of a man's, and "my skin was cold under my clothes"; he whispers that "a child has done the horrid thing". Holmes calls the poisoned darts "hellish things". In the chase on the Thames, Watson describes Tonga as a "savage, distorted creature" with "half animal fury". Here the horror depends on racial prejudice: Conan Doyle turns a human being into a monster, and a modern reader should see this as the fear of the foreign that ran through Victorian fiction rather than as truth. Small's story then adds the real horrors of 1857, including the cold-blooded killing of Achmet.
Yet Conan Doyle always rationalises the Gothic. In the next chapter Holmes identifies the grin as the "risus sardonicus", Watson recognises the work of a strychnine-like poison, and the locked room is explained by the trap-door and the rope. The pattern echoes Poe's 'The Murders in the Rue Morgue', often called the first locked-room mystery, in which a horrifying crime is solved by reason. Victorian readers had a taste for horror: the novel appeared four years after Jekyll and Hyde and two years after the Whitechapel murders filled the London press. The Sign of Four offers that thrill and then the comfort of explanation. Horror is real in the novel, but it is a puzzle to be solved, and Holmes is the one person who never stays frightened for long.