Read the following extract from Act 4 Scene 1 of The Merchant of Venice and then answer the question that follows.
At this point in the play, Portia, disguised as a young doctor of law called Balthazar, is judging the case in the court in Venice. Shylock has refused every offer of money, and Antonio has said goodbye to Bassanio and is ready to die.
PORTIA.
A pound of that same merchant's flesh is thine,
The court awards it and the law doth give it.
SHYLOCK.
Most rightful judge!
PORTIA.
And you must cut this flesh from off his breast.
The law allows it and the court awards it.
SHYLOCK.
Most learned judge! A sentence! Come, prepare.
PORTIA.
Tarry a little, there is something else.
This bond doth give thee here no jot of blood.
The words expressly are "a pound of flesh":
Take then thy bond, take thou thy pound of flesh,
But in the cutting it, if thou dost shed
One drop of Christian blood, thy lands and goods
Are, by the laws of Venice, confiscate
Unto the state of Venice.
GRATIANO.
O upright judge! Mark, Jew. O learned judge!
SHYLOCK.
Is that the law?
PORTIA.
Thyself shalt see the act.
For, as thou urgest justice, be assur'd
Thou shalt have justice more than thou desir'st.
GRATIANO.
O learned judge! Mark, Jew, a learned judge!
SHYLOCK.
I take this offer then. Pay the bond thrice
And let the Christian go.
BASSANIO.
Here is the money.
PORTIA.
Soft!
The Jew shall have all justice. Soft! no haste!
He shall have nothing but the penalty.
GRATIANO.
O Jew, an upright judge, a learned judge!
PORTIA.
Therefore prepare thee to cut off the flesh.
Shed thou no blood, nor cut thou less nor more,
But just a pound of flesh: if thou tak'st more
Or less than a just pound, be it but so much
As makes it light or heavy in the substance,
Or the division of the twentieth part
Of one poor scruple, nay, if the scale do turn
But in the estimation of a hair,
Thou diest, and all thy goods are confiscate.
'Portia is the true hero of The Merchant of Venice.'
Starting with this moment in the play, explore how far you agree with this view.
Write about:
- how Shakespeare presents Portia at this moment in the play
- how far Shakespeare presents Portia as the true hero in the play as a whole.
[30 marks]
AO4
Model answer
Portia has a strong claim to be the hero of The Merchant of Venice. At this moment she saves Antonio's life when every man in Venice has failed, using intelligence and nerve rather than force, and across the play she steers both the Venice and the Belmont stories to their happy endings. Yet 'hero' suggests moral as well as practical triumph, and Shakespeare also shows Portia's prejudice and the hardness of her victory over Shylock. She is the play's most capable and admired figure, but not an untroubled hero.
The opening of the extract shows her command of suspense. She seems to give Shylock everything: "A pound of that same merchant's flesh is thine, / The court awards it and the law doth give it." The near-repetition in reverse, "The law allows it and the court awards it", makes the judgment sound final, and Shylock's excited cries, "Most rightful judge!" and "Most learned judge!", show that he believes he has won. Whether she has planned this moment all along or is seizing it, Portia lets the danger reach its peak before she acts.
Then comes the reversal: "Tarry a little, there is something else." The quiet, almost casual phrasing contrasts with what follows: "This bond doth give thee here no jot of blood." Portia beats Shylock at his own game. He has insisted on the bond's exact words, asking of a surgeon, "Is it so nominated in the bond?", and she now reads those words with even greater precision: the bond gives flesh, not blood. If he sheds "One drop of Christian blood", his goods are "confiscate / Unto the state of Venice", so the law he relied on is turned against him. Her reply to "Is that the law?", "Thyself shalt see the act", shows complete authority.
She presses her advantage relentlessly. When Shylock tries to accept the money, she stops him: "Soft! / The Jew shall have all justice. Soft! no haste!" Her final speech piles up conditions with impossible precision: he must cut "just a pound", and if the scale turns even "in the estimation of a hair", "Thou diest". The repetition and exactness show a mind that has anticipated every escape. Gratiano's echo, "O learned judge! Mark, Jew, a learned judge!", works like a chorus celebrating her, and the dramatic irony that this "learned judge" is a woman the men cannot recognise makes her triumph sweeter for the audience.
Across the play Portia acts when others cannot. She begins trapped by her father's will, yet her wit in Act 1 Scene 2 shows a sharp mind. When Antonio's letter arrives, she offers to pay "Double six thousand, and then treble that" and secretly plans the journey to Venice. Her mercy speech gives the play its moral centre. In Act 5 she controls the ending, holding the rings, the deed of gift for Lorenzo and Jessica, and the letter announcing that Antonio's ships are safe. Antonio's thanks, "Sweet lady, you have given me life and living", sum up her role as rescuer.
There are, however, reasons to resist the view. Portia's prejudice is clear when she dismisses Morocco with "Let all of his complexion choose me so". At the trial, after preaching that mercy is "an attribute to God himself", she shows Shylock little: she denies him even his "principal", invokes the law against an "alien" and orders, "Down, therefore, and beg mercy of the Duke." Her victory saves Antonio but destroys Shylock. The ring trick also involves deception and teasing that some audiences find close to cruelty. And the play's title points to Antonio, while Bassanio is the romantic hero who wins her.
For Shakespeare's audience, Portia's defeat of Shylock would have been the triumphant climax of a comedy, and her cleverness all the more delightful because no woman could be a lawyer and because a boy actor played her. Modern audiences may admire her brilliance but feel uneasy about the justice she delivers. On balance, Portia is the true hero in the sense that she saves the day and shapes every outcome, but Shakespeare presents a hero whose mercy has limits, which makes her more complex than a simple heroine of comedy.