Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
AQA GCSE Citizenship Studies (Paper 1) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
Active citizenship
Unit 2
Politics and participation
Where does political power reside in the UK and how is it controlled?
Political power and the British constitution
What are the powers of local and devolved government and how can citizens participate?
Local and devolved government
Voting, elections and public spending
Where does political power reside: with the citizen, parliament or government?
Voting systems and political parties
How Parliament and government work
How do others govern themselves?
How other countries govern themselves
How can citizens try to bring about political change?
Bringing about political change
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/9

Taking citizenship action: the investigation

Practise 16 exam-style questions on Taking citizenship action: the investigation for AQA GCSE Citizenship Studies (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 16 questions
  • 1–12 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
16 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Explain one reason why it is important to set clear aims at the start of a citizenship investigation.

Model answer

Clear aims help you to decide what research you need to do (1). For example, if your aim is to persuade the council to put a crossing outside the school, you know you need evidence such as accident figures and the views of parents, so you do not waste time on research that will not help your case (1).

Explanation

The first mark is for a valid reason - focus, choosing research, planning the action, teamwork or measuring success. The second mark is for explaining what difference the clear aim makes. Answers that say aims are important 'because they are' or simply repeat the question score 0.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Identifies a reason, e.g. aims give the investigation a clear focus / they help to decide what research to carry out / they make it possible to measure success at the end / they help to plan a suitable action / they help a team agree on what it is trying to do and share out the tasks / they make it clear to decision makers what change is wanted. Credit any other valid reason.

    Award 1 mark for identifying a reason and 1 mark for developing an explanation. Example: 'Clear aims let you measure how successful your action was (1), because at the end you can compare what happened, such as the number of signatures collected, with the target you set (1).'

  2. 1 mark

    Develops the reason with a linked explanation or consequence, e.g. so time is not wasted on research that is not relevant / because you can compare the outcome with the aim / so everyone in the group works towards the same goal.

    The development must explain why the reason matters. Do not credit a second, unconnected reason as development.

Question 2

2 marks

Source A

A safer crossing for Westfield Road

(The school and the road in this source are invented.)

A group of Year 10 students thought the junction outside their school was dangerous. They put an online survey on the school's social media page for one day. The survey asked: 'Do you agree that the dangerous junction outside our school needs a crossing before someone is badly hurt?'

58 people replied: 55 answered 'Yes' and 3 answered 'No'. The group wrote to the council saying that 95% of people wanted a crossing.

The council replied that its traffic counts showed few accidents at the junction, and asked how the survey had been carried out.

Using Source A, explain one weakness of the group's primary research.

Model answer

The survey question was leading, because it described the junction as 'dangerous' and added 'before someone is badly hurt' (1). This pushes people towards answering 'Yes', so the 95% result may exaggerate the real level of support, which is why the council questioned how the survey had been carried out (1).

Explanation

The first mark is for picking out a weakness - the leading question, the small or self-selecting sample, or the single day online. The second is for explaining its effect on how far the results can be trusted. Good answers use the council's reply as evidence that the weakness mattered.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Identifies a weakness of the primary research from Source A, e.g. the question was leading / biased (it called the junction 'dangerous' and said 'before someone is badly hurt') / the sample was small (58 people) / the sample was not representative or was self-selecting (only followers of the school's social media page, not residents, drivers or the wider community) / the survey ran for only one day / it was online only / there was no check on who replied or how many times / the group did not collect evidence of accidents or traffic to support the survey.

    Max 1 if the answer makes no use of Source A. Award 1 mark for identifying a weakness and 1 mark for developing an explanation. Do not credit a strength.

  2. 1 mark

    Develops the weakness with an explanation of its effect, e.g. so the 95% result probably exaggerates real support / so the council could doubt the evidence, as its reply shows / so the views of people who would be affected by a crossing (drivers, residents) were missing.

    The development must explain how the weakness reduces the reliability or usefulness of the research. Do not credit a second, unconnected weakness as development.

Question 3

4 marks

Source A

Wheels in the park

(The town and the group in this source are invented.)

Three students in Marlowe Vale wanted the council to build a skate park on unused land in Hilltop Park. Their survey of 80 young people at the local skate shop found that 74 wanted a skate park.

When they presented their plan at a residents' meeting, several older neighbours objected. They were worried about noise late at night and about litter. A parent of young children said that the land was the only grassy space nearby for toddlers to play.

The students decided not to change their plan. They said the neighbours 'did not understand young people' and sent their survey results to the council. The council replied that it could not support the plan until the group showed that it had listened to local residents.

Referring to Source A, discuss how well the group took account of different viewpoints in their investigation.

Model answer

The group took some account of different viewpoints, but not enough. On the positive side, they gathered young people's views through a survey of 80 people, and they presented their plan at a residents' meeting, which meant they put their own viewpoint and heard what others thought.

However, their survey was carried out at a skate shop, so it was biased towards young people who already skate. The 74 out of 80 in favour does not represent the wider community, such as older residents or parents of young children. More importantly, when the neighbours raised concerns about late-night noise, litter and the loss of the only grassy space for toddlers, the group dismissed them, saying the neighbours 'did not understand young people'. They heard other viewpoints but did not represent or respond to them.

The group could have adapted the plan, for example by agreeing closing times, adding bins or keeping part of the grass for younger children, or surveyed residents as well. The council's reply that it could not support the plan until the group had listened to residents shows that failing to consider other viewpoints seriously weakened their action. Overall, they took account of other viewpoints poorly.

Explanation

Level 2 answers judge both how the group gathered views (a biased survey at a skate shop, the residents' meeting) and how it used them (dismissing the neighbours' concerns), using evidence from the source and the council's reply. Weaker answers just retell the source. Representing the views of others, and changing a plan in response, is a key citizenship skill.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks).
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Good application of knowledge and understanding of concepts and issues. Response clear and relevant to the concepts and issues surrounding the citizenship action.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Basic application of knowledge and understanding of concepts and issues. Response muddled and lacking relevance to the concepts and issues surrounding the citizenship action.
    0 marks: Nothing to credit.

    Max 2 if the answer makes no use of Source A. Indicative content (not exhaustive; credit other relevant points): some views were gathered - the survey of 80 young people (74 in favour) and attending the residents' meeting, where the students presented their own viewpoint and heard others'; but the survey was carried out at a skate shop, so it was biased towards people likely to want a skate park and did not represent the wider community; the group dismissed the neighbours' concerns (noise, litter, the toddlers' play space) instead of representing or answering them, and saying they 'did not understand young people' shows little respect for other views; they could have adapted the plan (opening hours, bins, keeping part of the grass for younger children, another site) or surveyed residents and parents; the council's response shows the consequence - not considering other viewpoints weakened their action; an overall judgement, e.g. poorly: they heard other views but did not take account of them. Level 2 answers use evidence from the source to judge how well the views were gathered and used; Level 1 answers simply describe what the group did.

Question 4

12 marks

Your Active Citizenship Investigation. Start your answer by stating what your investigation was about.

Analyse how successfully your citizenship action delivered a benefit or change for your chosen community.

Your answer should refer to:
- the aims of your action
- evidence of the impact your action had
- any factors that limited its impact.

Model answer

Example answer, for an investigation into support for young carers at our school.

My investigation was about whether young carers - students who help to look after a family member who is ill or disabled - received enough support at my school. Our aims were to raise awareness of young carers among students and staff, and to persuade the school to introduce practical support for them.

Our research shaped the action. A national charity's report said that many young carers are never identified by their school. Our anonymous survey of 120 students found 9 who said they regularly cared for someone, but only 2 of them had ever told a teacher. A worker from the local young carers' service told us that young carers often miss homework deadlines and feel isolated. So we proposed a young carers' card, which lets students phone home during the day and ask for homework extensions without having to explain, and a fortnightly lunchtime club run with the young carers' service. We also gave an assembly to every year group.

The action delivered a real benefit for young carers. The head teacher agreed to introduce the card, which was a lasting change in school policy, and by the end of the term 14 students had registered as young carers, when only 2 of the young carers in our survey had ever told a teacher. Between six and eight students came to every club meeting, and one told us it was 'the first time I didn't feel like the only one'. This was strong evidence that our first and most important aim had been met, mainly because we targeted the person with the power to change school policy and offered a low-cost solution.

The awareness aim was less successful. Before the assembly, 30% of the students we surveyed could explain what a young carer is; afterwards, 55 out of 100 could. That is a big improvement, but almost half the students still could not, so awareness across the school was only partly raised.

Several factors limited our impact. We had only one term, so we could not measure whether the support lasted. Some young carers may not want to be identified because of stigma - our survey found 9 young carers among just 120 students, which suggests that there are more in the whole school than the 14 who registered. The club depends on one teacher continuing to run it after we leave. We also could not change the wider problems families face at home, which are the responsibility of the council's social services rather than the school.

Overall, our action was successful for the community it was mainly aimed at, young carers in our school, because it achieved a lasting change in policy and gave them regular support. It was less successful at changing awareness across the whole school, and its long-term success depends on others keeping it going. If I did it again, I would train a group of Year 9 students to take over the club so that the benefit lasts.

Explanation

Top answers state the issue, the community and the aims, then analyse each aim against specific evidence (numbers, changes, feedback), explain why the action worked or did not, and weigh the factors that limited its impact before reaching a clear judgement. Describing the action without analysing its impact keeps an answer in Level 2. Answers that do not describe a real investigation are capped at 3 marks.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks).
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Clear and precise analysis, supported by well-chosen evidence from the candidate's investigation, demonstrates excellent, relevant application of knowledge and understanding of the citizenship actions. Analysis is developed, justified and evaluated within the context of citizenship action. The analysis and evaluation lead to a well-judged and coherent conclusion.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Appropriate evidence is selected from the candidate's investigation, demonstrating good, mostly relevant application of knowledge and understanding of citizenship actions. The evidence is used to support arguments and analyses but these analyses are not always completely developed, justified or evaluated. Analysis and evaluation may not all be relevant to the context. Conclusions drawn from the analysis and evaluation may not be completely coherent.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some evidence is selected from the candidate's investigation, demonstrating some occasionally relevant application of knowledge and understanding of citizenship actions. Weak arguments are made which are not necessarily related to the evidence selected. Analysis and evaluation is not relevant to the context. Some attempt is made to integrate the analysis and evaluation into concluding remarks.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic application of knowledge and understanding of the citizenship actions arising from the candidate's investigation. Little or no attempt is made to analyse or evaluate the evidence presented. Little or no attempt is made to integrate the points made.
    0 marks: Nothing to credit.

    Max 3 if the answer does not describe a specific investigation the student carried out (an issue, research or action of their own). The answer must show a named issue, the community the action was meant to benefit, the aims, the action taken and evidence of its impact; it may also say how the research shaped the action, but an answer is not capped for leaving this out. Indicative content (not exhaustive; credit other relevant points). AO2: the aims of the action and the community it was intended to benefit; a description of the action taken and who it reached or involved; how the research shaped the action; evidence of impact, e.g. a decision or policy changed, numbers taking part or signing, before-and-after survey results, feedback from the people affected, media coverage. AO3: analysis of how far each aim was achieved, with evidence; analysis of why the action was or was not successful (choice of decision maker, timing, method, resources, support from others); factors that limited its impact (time, money, scale, the power of the decision maker, lack of support, short-term rather than lasting change, difficulty measuring impact); evaluation of whether the benefit was lasting and who gained most; a well-judged conclusion on how successful the action was overall, perhaps with what would be done differently.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.