'Citizens in the USA have more ways to influence their government than citizens in the UK.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
- how citizens choose those who govern them
- other ways in which citizens can take part in politics.
Model answer
There are strong reasons to agree. US citizens can vote for many more of the people who govern them. They elect the President, through the Electoral College, as well as both houses of Congress, while UK citizens elect only their MP: the Prime Minister is not directly elected and the House of Lords is appointed. Elections in the USA are also more frequent: the whole House of Representatives is elected every two years, so voters can quickly reward or punish their representatives. Because the USA is a federal system, citizens also elect state governors and state legislators and, in many places, local officials such as sheriffs, prosecutors, school boards and judges. In about half the states citizens can propose and vote on laws directly through ballot initiatives, and some states allow recall elections. US citizens also choose their parties' candidates in primary elections, while in the UK candidates are usually chosen by party members. Their rights to free speech, a free press, peaceful assembly and to petition the government are written into the First Amendment and protected by the Supreme Court.
However, having more elections does not always mean more influence. Voter registration is the individual's responsibility and the rules differ from state to state, including different voter ID rules and limits on voting for people with criminal convictions, and election day is usually a normal working day. Because of the Electoral College, votes in a few swing states matter far more than votes in 'safe' states, and candidates have won the presidency while losing the national popular vote, as in 2000 and 2016. In many states the boundaries of House districts are drawn by state politicians, which can lead to gerrymandering, whereas UK boundaries are drawn by independent Boundary Commissions. The cost of US campaigns, and spending by groups such as Super PACs since a 2010 Supreme Court ruling, may give wealthy donors more influence than ordinary citizens. UK citizens also have important opportunities of their own: they elect local councillors, mayors and, in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, devolved parliaments and assemblies; they can raise problems with their MP at constituency surgeries; e-petitions with 100,000 signatures are considered for debate in Parliament; and they have voted in national referendums, such as the 2016 vote on EU membership, which have never been held at national level in the USA.
Overall, I agree that US citizens have more ways to influence their government, because they elect far more of those who govern them and, in many states, can make laws directly. But more ways do not necessarily mean more influence: the Electoral College, unequal voting rules and the power of money mean that some American citizens' voices count for far more than others. So US citizens have more opportunities on paper, but how much influence they actually have depends on who they are and where they live.
Explanation
Level 4 answers compare the two systems on both sides, using accurate detail (elections for the President and both houses, state initiatives and primaries against registration rules, the Electoral College, money in politics and the UK's own opportunities), and reach a judgement that distinguishes the number of ways from how effective they are. A common error is to claim that UK voters elect the Prime Minister. One-sided answers are capped at 4 marks.