Source A
The battle for Hollin Wood
(The town and the groups in this source are invented.)
The council in Larkhaven gave permission for a new road through Hollin Wood, an ancient woodland, to ease traffic jams in the town centre. Campaigners had collected 9,000 signatures on a petition and written to their MP, but the plan went ahead.
When tree-felling began, members of a group called Guardians of Hollin Wood built tree-houses in the wood and refused to leave. Others chained themselves to the gates of the building site. The protest was filmed and shared widely, and national newspapers covered the story. Work was delayed for three months, and the cost of policing the protest was estimated at £400,000.
A survey of local residents found that 52% supported the new road and 41% opposed it. One resident said: 'I agree with saving the wood, but breaking the law is wrong.' A protester replied: 'We tried the polite way first. Nobody listened.'
Examine why some campaigners choose to use direct action rather than other forms of citizenship action.
You should refer to Source A and examples from your own knowledge in your answer.
Model answer
Source A shows that one of the main reasons campaigners turn to direct action is that the usual methods have failed. The Larkhaven campaigners collected 9,000 signatures and wrote to their MP, but the plan still went ahead. As the protester said, 'We tried the polite way first. Nobody listened.' For people who believe that something irreplaceable, such as an ancient woodland, is about to be destroyed, direct action can feel like the only option left.
Direct action can also achieve things that letters and petitions cannot. By building tree-houses and chaining themselves to the gates, the Guardians of Hollin Wood physically delayed the work for three months. Their protest was filmed, shared widely and covered by national newspapers, turning a local planning decision into a national story. The £400,000 cost of policing also raises the cost of the project, which puts extra pressure on the council. The Suffragettes chose direct action for similar reasons: after decades of peaceful petitions had not won women the vote, they used window-smashing and chaining themselves to railings to force the issue into the headlines.
However, direct action carries serious risks. The survey in Source A found that 52% of residents supported the road and only 41% opposed it, so the protesters could be accused of overriding a decision made by an elected council that most local people backed. The resident who said 'breaking the law is wrong' shows how direct action can lose public sympathy. Protesters also risk arrest: since the Public Order Act 2023, 'locking on' - attaching yourself to an object or building, as the people chained to the gates did - can itself be a criminal offence in England and Wales if it causes serious disruption. Direct action does not always work either: the Newbury bypass protests of 1996 used tree camps very like these, but the road was still built.
Different groups also make different choices. Insider groups, which are regularly consulted by government, usually avoid direct action because it could cost them their access to ministers. Outsider groups, which have no such access, are more likely to use it.
In conclusion, campaigners choose direct action mainly when they feel the normal democratic channels have failed and the issue is too urgent to wait, because it can delay decisions and win media attention. But it is a high-risk choice: it can break the law, divide public opinion and still fail, so it is most likely to succeed when it wins public sympathy rather than losing it.
Explanation
Top answers explain several reasons for direct action using Source A (the failed petition, the delay to the work, the media coverage, the cost) and support them with their own examples, such as the Suffragettes or road protests. They also weigh the costs - the survey showing most residents backed the road, legal risks under the Public Order Act 2023 and the loss of public support - and reach a judgement. Answers that only praise or only condemn direct action, without weighing its benefits against its costs, are unlikely to reach the top levels.