'The Prime Minister has become more like a president than the leader of a team.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
- the powers of the Prime Minister
- the role of the cabinet and ministers.
Model answer
Some argue that the Prime Minister has become more like a president. Through the power of patronage the Prime Minister appoints, reshuffles and sacks every minister, so cabinet members owe their jobs to the PM and may be reluctant to challenge them. The PM chairs the cabinet, controls its agenda and decides which issues go to smaller cabinet committees or are settled with a few close advisers in Downing Street, so full cabinet discussion can become a formality. The PM also uses royal prerogative powers on the government's behalf, such as deploying the armed forces and negotiating treaties, and since the Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022 can again ask the monarch to dissolve Parliament and so choose the date of an early election. The media focus heavily on the party leader: general election campaigns now include televised leaders' debates (first held in 2010), and Prime Minister's Questions puts the PM at the centre of Parliament. A PM with a large Commons majority can dominate both the cabinet and Parliament.
However, there are strong arguments against. Constitutionally the PM is 'first among equals': under collective responsibility, decisions are taken by the cabinet as a whole, and senior ministers with their own support in the party can resist the PM. Unlike a US President, who is elected separately for a fixed four-year term, a PM depends on keeping the confidence of the House of Commons and of their own party. Several Prime Ministers have been replaced between elections after losing the support of their party or cabinet, for example in 1990, in 2019 and twice in 2022; in July 2022 a wave of ministerial resignations helped to force the Prime Minister out. The PM can also be defeated in the Commons, as when MPs voted against the government's motion on possible military action in Syria in 2013. In a coalition, as in 2010-2015, the PM must agree decisions with another party, and the courts can limit the PM too: in 2019 the Supreme Court ruled that the Prime Minister's advice to prorogue Parliament was unlawful.
Overall, I partly agree. A Prime Minister with a large majority and a united party can dominate government in a 'presidential' style, using patronage and media attention to lead from the front. But this power is conditional: it depends on the support of the cabinet, the party and the Commons, and it can disappear quickly, as the frequent changes of Prime Minister since 2016 show. A real president has a separate mandate and a fixed term, which a Prime Minister lacks, so the PM is better described as a powerful leader of a team who can still be removed by that team.
Explanation
Level 4 answers weigh the PM's powers (patronage, control of the cabinet, prerogative powers, media focus) against the limits (collective responsibility, dependence on party and Commons, real examples of PMs being removed or defeated) and reach a justified judgement. Good answers also notice that a US President has a separate mandate and fixed term, which a PM does not. Answers that only list the PM's powers stay at Level 2.