'England should have its own parliament, like Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
- how England is governed now
- the debate about 'English votes for English laws'.
Model answer
England is the only nation of the UK without its own devolved parliament. Laws on English matters such as health and education are made by the UK Parliament at Westminster, where MPs from all four nations can vote.
Some people agree that England should have its own parliament. Since devolution, MPs representing Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish constituencies can vote on laws that affect only England, such as school policy, while English MPs cannot vote on the same issues in Scotland, because these are decided by the Scottish Parliament. This is known as the West Lothian question, and many see it as unfair to voters in England. 'English votes for English laws' tried to solve this from 2015, but it was abolished in 2021, so the problem remains. An English parliament would treat all four nations equally and let voters in England hold a government responsible for English services. It would also make clear when UK ministers, such as the Health Secretary, are acting for England only. Supporters also point to a growing sense of English identity, which they say deserves its own institution.
However, others disagree. England has more than four-fifths of the UK's population, so an English parliament would be almost as large and powerful as the UK Parliament, and the two could clash, which might unbalance or even threaten the Union. MPs for English constituencies already make up more than 80% of the House of Commons, so laws for England rarely pass against the wishes of most English MPs. England is also very diverse, and many argue that decisions are better brought closer to people through regional devolution, such as the Greater London Authority and the elected mayors of areas like Greater Manchester and the West Midlands. A new parliament would add another layer of politicians and cost, and there is little evidence of public demand: in 2004 voters in the North East rejected an elected regional assembly by about 78% to 22%.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. The West Lothian question is a real unfairness, but because England is so much larger than the other nations, a separate English parliament could create more problems than it solves. Strengthening devolution to regions and cities within England, together with Commons procedures that give English MPs a clear say on English-only laws, is a more balanced way to address the issue.
Explanation
Strong answers explain the West Lothian question and EVEL accurately, then weigh fairness between the nations against England's size, cost and the alternative of regional devolution. Using evidence such as England's share of the population and the 2004 North East referendum supports the argument. Answers that describe only one side are capped at 4, and answers with no judgement at 6.