Explore how the meaning of the scarlet letter changes during the novel.
You must consider language, form and structure and refer to the context of the novel in your answer.
Model answer
The scarlet letter is the novel's central symbol, but Hawthorne never lets it keep one meaning. It begins as a mark of shame imposed by the Puritan authorities, becomes a work of art, a torture, a source of insight, a sign of ability and finally an object of reverence. By making the symbol change with time and with the person looking at it, Hawthorne suggests that meaning is created by people rather than fixed by law. Tellingly, the word for Hester's crime is never written in the novel.
The Custom-House introduces the letter as a riddle. The narrator finds a faded rag of red cloth and senses "some deep meaning in it, most worthy of interpretation", which communicates itself to his feelings but evades his mind. When he places it on his breast it seems to burn like red-hot iron. From the start, the letter is something that must be interpreted, and its power is felt rather than understood.
In Chapter 2 the Puritan authorities intend the letter as a simple sign of sin. Hester, however, has embroidered it with "fantastic flourishes of gold-thread", turning punishment into art and defiance. The narrator says it "had the effect of a spell", taking her out of ordinary human relations. In a community that used public marks and shaming to enforce morality, the letter's meaning is first to isolate. Mr Wilson's sermon gives it new terrors, so that it seems to take its scarlet colour from the flames of hell, and Hester's sense of it as a brand is deepened by the children who taunt her and the strangers who stare.
The letter also becomes a source of knowledge. In Chapter 5 it gives Hester "a sympathetic knowledge of the hidden sin in other hearts", so that it seems to throb near ministers and pious matrons. The symbol of one woman's sin reveals the sins of the whole community. In Pearl it takes living form: she is "the scarlet letter endowed with life", and in the Governor's convex armour the letter swells to "exaggerated and gigantic proportions" until Hester seems hidden behind it.
In the middle of the novel Hawthorne shows that meaning depends on the viewer. When a meteor crosses the sky in Chapter 12, the guilty Dimmesdale sees a great letter A, and the narrator attributes it to "the disease in his own eye and heart". The next day the sexton reads the same sign as Angel, for Governor Winthrop's death. Hawthorne plays on the Puritan habit of reading portents in the sky, while suggesting that every reader sees what his own mind brings.
The community's reading changes too. In Chapter 13 Hester's charity leads many people to say that the A means Able, and the letter becomes "the taper of the sick-chamber", even like the cross on a nun's bosom. Yet the narrator warns that "The scarlet letter had not done its office": Hester's outward penance hides an inner rebellion. In the forest she throws the letter away, but Pearl refuses to know her mother without it, and the symbol returns. For Pearl, the letter has become part of her mother's identity.
At the climax the letter moves to Dimmesdale's breast, and Hawthorne refuses to say what the onlookers saw, offering several explanations, from self-torture to the gnawing of remorse, and leaving the reader to choose. In the Conclusion Hester resumes the letter of her own free will, and it "ceased to be a stigma", becoming something "looked upon with awe, yet with reverence too". The final heraldic device on the shared tombstone, "ON A FIELD, SABLE, THE LETTER A, GULES", turns it into a kind of coat of arms.
As a Romantic writer of romance, Hawthorne uses the letter to show that a symbol can hold many meanings at once. The Puritans tried to fix it as a sign of shame, but Hester's life, and the reader's interpretation, transform it. The letter's changing meaning is the novel's argument: human beings, not laws, decide what a sign of sin will finally mean.