'Elesin fails because of his own weakness, not because of the colonial authorities.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must consider language, form and structure in your answer.
Model answer
Elesin's failure has two causes in the play: his own attachment to life, and the arrival of the District Officer at the crucial moment. I largely agree with the view, because Soyinka repeatedly shows that the decisive weakness lies within Elesin. However, the play also presents colonial power as a violent intrusion, so the authorities cannot be excused entirely.
From the opening scene Soyinka prepares the audience for Elesin's weakness. The stage directions present him as a man of enormous vitality who enjoys life, and his boast that the juiciest fruit on every tree was always his shows a man used to taking what he desires. The Praise-Singer's warning that "The hands of women also weaken the unwary" is quickly followed by the arrival of the young woman, and Elesin's sensual verse about her body shows how strongly he is still bound to the world. Iyaloja grants the marriage but predicts that he will "sigh a last regret for the flesh". These warnings work as foreshadowing, so when Elesin fails, the audience recognises a weakness that has been visible all along.
Elesin's own words in Scene 5 support the view most strongly. Speaking to his Bride, he admits that he first blamed the white man, then his gods, and now wants to blame her, before confessing a "longing on my earth-held limbs". The compound adjective presents a body held down by the earth. To Iyaloja he goes further, describing "the awful treachery of relief" he felt when the stranger's hand stopped him, and the blasphemy of thinking that the gods might have sent the interruption. This is a remarkable admission: the arrest gave him an excuse that part of him welcomed. Iyaloja and the Praise-Singer judge him accordingly. The Praise-Singer reminds him that the people placed the reins of the world in his hands, and Iyaloja's speech about the left-overs of the world presents his failure as a series of choices.
Soyinka's Author's Note supports this reading. He calls the colonial factor "a catalytic incident merely": something that triggers a reaction rather than causing it. The tragedy, in this view, lies in Elesin's failure of will at the threshold between the worlds of the living and the dead.
Yet the play does not let the colonial authorities off. Pilkings arrests Elesin in the middle of his trance, and Elesin's image of his will being "squelched in the spittle of an alien race" presents the intrusion as a violation. The verb is ugly and physical, suggesting that something sacred has been crushed and soiled. In the cell he tells Pilkings that he has "shattered the peace of the world for ever", and accuses him of taking his first-born to England to make him in his own image. Even Elesin's confession insists that he would have shaken off his longing if the white man had not entered. Iyaloja, too, blames Pilkings at the end, accusing him of playing with strangers' lives and of cutting down the young shoot to feed his pride. Structurally, the British interruption is the turning point of the play: without it, the ritual might have been completed.
The colonial authorities also bear responsibility for the wider damage. Pilkings's interference leads directly to Olunde's death and then to Elesin's. His insistence that he did his duty and has no regrets shows a man unable to see the consequences of his power. Soyinka presents this blindness satirically, through the Resident's concern for His Highness and the Pilkingses' use of the egungun as fancy dress, which suggests that colonial rule treats a whole culture as a game.
Overall, I agree that Elesin fails mainly because of his own weakness. The colonial authorities create the occasion for failure, and their arrogance has terrible results, but the play insists that a man of Elesin's power and preparation could have overcome both temptation and interference. That is why the final judgement falls on him, in Iyaloja's words: "The son has proved the father". Olunde, facing the same colonial world, does what his father could not.