'In Pride and Prejudice, good manners are no guide to good character.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must consider language, form and structure and refer to the context of the novel in your answer.
Model answer
In a novel of manners it is fitting that Austen asks whether manners can be trusted. Pride and Prejudice repeatedly shows characters whose pleasing manners hide bad character and others whose unpleasant manners hide real goodness. I largely agree with the view, but Austen also suggests that good manners matter when they come from good principles, and that bad manners can reveal real faults.
Wickham is the clearest example of manners as a mask. When Elizabeth first meets him, Austen notes that "he had all the best parts of beauty, a fine countenance, a good figure, and very pleasing address". His charm is immediate, and Elizabeth believes his story of Darcy's cruelty without question. Only after reading Darcy's letter does she realise that "His countenance, voice, and manner, had established him at once in the possession of every virtue", while she can remember "no more substantial good". The free indirect style shows her discovering how she was deceived. Wickham's later conduct - his debts and his elopement with Lydia - confirms that his manners were a performance.
Darcy is the reverse. At the Meryton assembly his manners give "a disgust which turned the tide of his popularity": he refuses to dance and insults Elizabeth within her hearing. Yet the novel gradually reveals his honesty and generosity. Mrs Reynolds calls him "the best landlord, and the best master", and his rescue of Lydia, done secretly and without seeking thanks, proves his character. Darcy's bad manners are real faults - Elizabeth's complaint that he did not behave "in a more gentlemanlike manner" is just - but they are faults of pride, not of principle. In Austen's society 'gentlemanlike' meant more than birth; it implied right conduct, and Darcy learns to make his manners match his principles.
Other characters show the gap between polish and kindness. Miss Bingley and Mrs Hurst are "very fine ladies", educated "in one of the first private seminaries in town", yet they are polite to Elizabeth's face while mocking her petticoat and her "low connections" behind her back. Mr Collins is all elaborate courtesy, but he is "a mixture of pride and obsequiousness, self-importance and humility", and at the Netherfield ball he addresses Darcy "without introduction", breaking the very rules of etiquette he claims to respect. Lady Catherine has the highest rank in the novel, yet her conversation is rude and domineering: Elizabeth notes her "dignified impertinence". Rank and refinement do not guarantee goodness.
However, Austen does not suggest that manners never matter. The Gardiners prove that good manners can reflect good character. Mr Gardiner, though he "lived by trade, and within view of his own warehouses", is "well-bred and agreeable", and at Pemberley Elizabeth glories in "every sentence of her uncle, which marked his intelligence, his taste, or his good manners". Bingley's "easy, unaffected manners" also match his kind nature, although his easy temper makes him too ready to be persuaded. Conversely, bad manners in the Bennet family do reveal real faults. Mrs Bennet's loud boasting at the Netherfield ball and Lydia's wildness show a lack of judgement with serious consequences, and Darcy's letter rightly criticises their "total want of propriety". Elizabeth feels as if her family had agreed "to expose themselves as much as they could".
Structurally, the novel moves from first impressions based on manners to judgements based on actions. Darcy's improved civility at Pemberley shows that manners can change when character develops, and Elizabeth's discovery that she misread both men teaches her to look beyond surfaces. In a society governed by elaborate codes of introduction, visiting and conversation, this lesson was important: manners were the language of social life, and Austen shows how easily that language could be used to deceive.
The view is therefore largely true. Manners in Pride and Prejudice are often a poor guide to character, as Wickham, the Bingley sisters and Lady Catherine show. But Austen's ideal is not to ignore manners; it is to unite them with principle, as Darcy finally does and as the Gardiners always have.