'Macbeth is destroyed by his own choices, not by fate.'
How far do you agree with this statement?
You must consider language, form and structure and refer to the context of the play in your answer.
Model answer
The prophecies in Macbeth all come true, so it is tempting to see Macbeth as a victim of fate. However, Shakespeare is careful to show that the witches only tell Macbeth what will happen; they never tell him how, and they never tell him to kill. I largely agree with the statement: fate provides the temptation, but Macbeth's choices turn prophecy into murder.
There is certainly a sense of fate in the play. The witches open it planning "There to meet with Macbeth", as if he has been chosen before he appears. Their equivocal language, such as "Fair is foul, and foul is fair" and the riddle that Banquo is "Lesser than Macbeth, and greater", suggests that they see further than humans can. Every prophecy is fulfilled: Macbeth becomes Thane of Cawdor within minutes, then king; Birnam wood comes to Dunsinane; and Macduff was "from his mother's womb / Untimely ripp'd". By the end Macbeth feels trapped: "They have tied me to a stake. I cannot fly". The bear-baiting image presents him as an animal tied up for others' sport.
Yet Shakespeare structures the opening so that we watch Macbeth choosing. The witches promise only that he "shalt be king hereafter"; within moments his aside shows that he himself has thought of murder, an idea so horrible that it "doth unfix my hair". He even considers letting fate work alone - "If chance will have me king, why, chance may crown me / Without my stir" - so Shakespeare shows him with the option of waiting, and rejecting it. Banquo provides the clearest proof. He is promised royal descendants and is tempted, yet he prays against "the cursed thoughts that nature / Gives way to in repose" and keeps his "allegiance clear". Two men hear prophecies; only one becomes a murderer.
Macbeth's later decisions confirm this. In Act 1 Scene 7 he decides "We will proceed no further in this business"; Lady Macbeth persuades him back, but persuasion is not fate. In Act 3 he openly challenges destiny - "Rather than so, come, fate, into the list, / And champion me to th' utterance!" - and hires murderers to stop Banquo's line. In Act 4 he seeks out the witches himself, and even after hearing that "none of woman born / Shall harm Macbeth" he decides to kill Macduff to "make assurance double sure". The slaughter of Macduff's family is never prophesied: it is entirely his own choice.
A Jacobean audience would have understood this balance. Christian teaching held that the Devil could tempt and deceive, but that people had free will and would be judged for their choices. James I's Daemonologie presented witches as servants of the Devil, so their prophecies are partial truths designed to lead Macbeth to damnation, as Banquo warns: "The instruments of darkness tell us truths; / Win us with honest trifles, to betray's / In deepest consequence". The idea of truths that mislead also echoes the debate about equivocation after the Gunpowder Plot, when the Jesuit Henry Garnet was tried in 1606. When Macbeth finally sees that the witches "palter with us in a double sense", he blames their "juggling", but the audience knows that they never forced his hand. The scenes with Hecate, who boasts that her spirits will "draw him on to his confusion", might suggest a stronger supernatural control, but many scholars believe these passages were added later by another writer, possibly Thomas Middleton, so they are weaker evidence of Shakespeare's design.
In conclusion, fate in Macbeth sets the stage, and the prophecies create both the temptation and the dramatic irony. But Shakespeare uses soliloquies and asides to show the moments of decision, and uses Banquo to prove that resistance was possible. A modern audience, less likely to believe in witches, may see them as an outward form of Macbeth's own desires, which makes his responsibility even clearer. Macbeth is destroyed by what he chooses to do with the future he is shown.