"Alack, what heinous sin is it in me / To be ashamed to be my father's child!" (Jessica, Act 2 Scene 3)
Explore the presentation of Jessica in the play.
You must consider language, form and structure and refer to the context of the play in your answer.
Model answer
Jessica is one of the most ambiguous characters in The Merchant of Venice. She escapes a father she describes as hellish, marries the man she loves and becomes a Christian, which an Elizabethan audience may have seen as a happy outcome. Yet Shakespeare also shows her stealing from her father, mocked by her new companions and strangely quiet in Belmont, so that she can be read both as a romantic heroine and as a lonely outsider.
Shakespeare first presents Jessica as a prisoner in her father's house. Her first words to Lancelot are "Our house is hell, and thou, a merry devil, / Didst rob it of some taste of tediousness". The imagery of hell suggests misery and spiritual danger, and links Shylock with the devil as the Christian characters do. Her short soliloquy then reveals a painful conflict: "Alack, what heinous sin is it in me / To be ashamed to be my father's child!" Children were expected to honour their parents, as the fifth commandment taught, and she knows that her shame breaks that duty. Yet she separates herself from him: "though I am a daughter to his blood, / I am not to his manners." The rhyming couplet that ends the scene, in which she will "Become a Christian and thy loving wife", sounds decisive, as if conversion and marriage are one escape.
Shylock's behaviour in Act 2 Scene 5 seems to support her. He orders her to "Lock up my doors" and to keep "the sound of shallow fopp'ry" out of his "sober house", which presents him as controlling and joyless. When he leaves, her couplet "I have a father, you a daughter, lost" shows that she has already made her choice, and the dramatic irony makes his trust painful to watch.
The elopement is presented with romance but also with unease. Jessica appears "above, in boy's clothes", throws down a casket and goes back to "gild myself / With some moe ducats". The verb "gild" links her with the gold that the play warns against, and her shame - "I am much asham'd of my exchange" - suggests that she is not wholly comfortable with what she is doing. Gratiano's praise, "Now, by my hood, a gentle, and no Jew", puns on "gentle" and gentile: she is accepted only because the Christians no longer see her as Jewish. Lorenzo, at least, praises her as "wise, fair, and true", which suggests real love.
Her actions after the elopement are harder to defend. Tubal reports that she spent "fourscore ducats" in one night in Genoa and exchanged a ring for a monkey - the turquoise that Shylock "had ... of Leah" before his marriage. For a moment Shylock's grief becomes personal rather than financial, and Jessica's careless act makes her seem thoughtless, even cruel. In Belmont she testifies against her father, saying that he would rather have Antonio's flesh than "twenty times the value" of the debt, which shows that she has fully joined the Christian side.
Yet Shakespeare suggests that she is never fully accepted. Gratiano calls her Lorenzo's "infidel" and asks Nerissa to "cheer yond stranger", and in Act 3 Scene 5 Lancelot tells her that there is no mercy for her in heaven because she is "a Jew's daughter". Her reply, "I shall be saved by my husband. He hath made me a Christian", reflects the Elizabethan belief that conversion brought salvation, but it also shows how far her identity now depends on a husband. In Marlowe's The Jew of Malta a Jewish daughter, Abigail, also turns to Christianity, so Shakespeare's audience may have expected Jessica's conversion to be presented as a reward.
The final act deepens the ambiguity. In the lyrical exchange "In such a night", Jessica and Lorenzo name lovers from classical stories, such as Thisbe and Dido, whose loves ended unhappily, and Jessica teases him for stealing her soul "with many vows of faith, / And ne'er a true one". The joke may hint at doubt. After Lorenzo's speech on music she says "I am never merry when I hear sweet music", and then she falls silent. She receives the deed of gift of her father's wealth, but she never mentions him again.
Shakespeare presents Jessica as a daughter who chooses love and freedom over loyalty, and an Elizabethan audience may have seen her conversion as a happy ending. A modern audience is more likely to notice the price: she loses her father, her faith and her place, and gains a home in which she remains a stranger.