Question 1
40 marksWriting imaginatively and creatively
You should spend about 1 hour on this task. You will be assessed on the quality of your extended response. You should plan and check your work carefully.
Write a description of a place deep underground.
In your writing you should describe:
• the place and how you came to be there
• what you saw, heard and felt below the surface
• what the experience made you feel about the world above ground.
[40]
Model answer
The cage that takes you down into the mine is a metal box the size of a garden shed, and when the gate clangs shut behind you, it drops.
Not quickly. But steadily, with a rattle and a whine, ninety metres straight down through the rock, while the square of daylight above your head shrinks to a postage stamp and then disappears. There were eight of us squashed together in our hard hats and heavy battery belts: six of us from my class, our history teacher, and Emrys, our guide, who had worked in this pit for twenty years before it closed and still walked like a man who expected the roof to be low.
At the bottom, the air was cold, and damp, and smelled of wet stone and, under that, a sour, sooty tang that I later realised was coal. Tunnels led away in every direction, held up by iron arches and ancient wooden props, lit only by the small round beams of our helmet lamps. Water dripped. Somewhere, very faintly, something hummed -- the fans, Emrys said, that still pushed fresh air through the workings. We walked for ten minutes, ducking under beams, our lamps bobbing over walls that glittered black. Then he stopped and turned to face us.
'Right,' he said. 'Lamps off. All of you. Trust me.'
Somebody asked whether we were allowed to say no. Then, one by one, the beams went out.
I have never managed to describe it properly. The nearest I can get is this: it was as if somebody had lifted the world away and left me standing in the place where it used to be. After a few seconds my eyes, starved of anything to look at, began to invent things: faint purple clouds that drifted and broke apart, tiny sparks that were not there. Then the floor seemed to tilt, very gently, under my boots, and I put a hand out to the rock to steady myself, and could not have told you which way was up.
And the dark had no size. It might have ended at my eyelashes, or gone on for a mile. Everything else came rushing in to fill the space where seeing had been: the far-off hum of the fans, impossibly loud; somebody's coat rustling; the boy next to me breathing through his mouth; the weight of the battery dragging at my belt. The cold of the rock found the back of my neck. The smell of coal seemed to grow stronger, thick and gritty in my throat.
Nobody was asking questions now.
Emrys's voice came out of the blackness, quiet and very close.
'Nearly two hundred years ago,' he said, 'there would have been a child sitting just about where you're standing. Five, six years old. A trapper. His job was to open a wooden door when he heard the coal trucks coming, and shut it again the moment they had passed, so that the fresh air went where it was needed. Twelve hours a day. On his own. In this.'
I tried to imagine it, and I could not, and I could. A small boy sitting on the floor of the tunnel with his back against the rock, in a darkness that did not change from the start of his shift to the end of it, listening for the rumble of the trucks. Twelve hours. Six days a week. I thought about myself at six, asleep under a duvet covered in stars, with a nightlight shaped like the moon. I felt sick.
'Lamps on,' said Emrys.
The light, when it came back, was so beautiful that I could have cried. Eight little circles of yellow, wobbling over wet black walls. Faces, pale and blinking. The boy next to me was holding the sleeve of the girl on his other side, and when he saw that we could all see, he let go very fast.
When the cage brought us back up, I stepped out squinting, and the ordinary grey afternoon -- the winding wheel against the sky, the coach, the drizzle on the hills -- looked to me as rich and glowing as a painting.
I still think about that minute in the dark. Not because it frightened me, although it did, but because of the trapper. I think of him whenever I complain about the length of a school day: six hours, with a break and a lunch hour, in rooms with windows. And on grey winter mornings, when everyone at the bus stop is grumbling about the drizzle, I sometimes tip my face up to the sky anyway, to the plain, cold, ordinary light, and stand in it for a moment, because he could not.
Explanation
The description takes the reader down in the cage and along the tunnels step by step, so that when the lamps go out the reader's own sight seems to fail, and the darkness is conveyed through every other sense: eyes that invent purple clouds and sparks, a dark with 'no size', the hum of the fans made 'impossibly loud'. The guide's account of the child trapper turns sensation into reflection, and the grey afternoon at the top that looks 'as rich and glowing as a painting', with the writer now standing in plain winter daylight 'because he could not', shows how the experience has changed the way the writer sees the world above ground. Responses to this task often fall back on 'pitch black' and 'scary', or narrate the trip and give the place underground only a sentence.
Mark scheme
-
24 marks
Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). AO5: Communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively, selecting and adapting tone, style and register for different forms, purposes and audiences. AO5: Organise information and ideas, using structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion of texts.
Level 6 (21-24 marks): The form is deliberately adapted to position the reader, showing a sophisticated control of purpose and effect. Tone, style and register are ambitiously selected and deployed to enhance the purpose of the task. There is a skilfully controlled overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used to support coherence and cohesion and achieve a range of effects.
Level 5 (17-20 marks): The form is confidently adapted and shows a secure understanding of purpose and audience. There is a sustained use of tone, style and register to fulfil the purpose of the task. There is a controlled overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used to support coherence and cohesion and achieve particular effects.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The form is adapted to show a clear understanding of purpose and audience. Tone, style and register are chosen to match the task. There is a well-managed overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used to support coherence and cohesion, and sometimes for effect.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): The form is sustained and shows clear awareness of purpose and audience. Tone, style and register are appropriate for the task, with some inconsistencies. There is a clear overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used, mostly securely, to support coherence and cohesion.OCR's level descriptors, continued: Level 2 (5-8 marks): The form, which is mostly appropriate for purpose and audience, is generally maintained. There is an attempt to use a tone, style and register appropriate to the task. There is some evidence of overall structure, with some use of paragraphs and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion. Level 1 (1-4 marks): There is some attempt to use a form appropriate for purpose and audience. There is a limited attempt to use a tone, style and register appropriate for the task. There is some attempt to structure the response, with limited evidence of paragraphs or grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion. 0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.
Indicative content for this task (not a checklist; reward other effective approaches):
Form and approach: a personal description of a place deep underground -- a mine or show cave visited on a tour, a pothole, a tunnel, a crypt, a wartime shelter or bunker, a deep underground station. Responses may be true or imagined, as long as they read as personal writing in the first person. The best answers make the reader feel the surface being left behind -- daylight, weather, the sounds of the world above -- and, where sight fails, turn to sound, touch, smell, temperature and the body, and to what the place made the writer think and imagine.
Bullet 1 (the place and how you came to be there): a clear, economical sense of the place and the way down into it (a cage, a ladder, a long sloping tunnel, a spiral of steps), so that the reader feels the daylight shrinking. Details of the people present can add contrast and humour.
Bullet 2 (what you saw, heard and felt below the surface): this is the heart of the task. Strong answers record the place precisely -- the cold of stone, a drip, the smell of damp or coal, a low roof, the small beams of lamps -- and may find fresh ways to convey a moment of total darkness (the eyes straining at nothing, the dark felt as a pressure) in which the other senses are heightened.
Bullet 3 (what the experience made you feel about the world above ground): reflection that grows from the place -- for example, imagining the people who once worked or sheltered there, gratitude for daylight and air, a new sense of what lies under ordinary fields and streets. A small present-day action can show the change.
Level 6 here: the form is deliberately adapted to position the reader -- for example, the reader is taken down with the writer step by step, so that when the lamps go out the reader's own sight seems to fail. Tone is ambitiously selected, hushed and intense, with the history of the place deepening it. The structure is skilfully controlled: descent, the moment of darkness, a turn to the people of the past, the return to the surface, and a resonant present-day close.
Levels 3-4: description that relies on 'pitch black' and 'scary'; a narrative of the trip with the place itself described in a sentence; senses listed rather than explored; history pasted in as facts; an ending that simply says it was a good experience. -
16 marks
Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy). AO6: Use a range of vocabulary and sentence structures for clarity, purpose and effect, with accurate spelling and punctuation.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): An ambitious range of sentence structures is used to shape meaning and create impact. Accurate punctuation is used to enhance clarity and achieve particular effects. Vocabulary is precise and subtle, expressing complex ideas with clarity. Spelling of irregular and ambitious words is accurate, with very occasional lapses.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): A wide range of sentence structures is used for deliberate purpose and effect. Punctuation is consistently accurate and is used to achieve clarity. Vocabulary is sometimes ambitious and used convincingly for purpose and effect. Spelling, including complex regular words, is accurate; there may be occasional errors with irregular and ambitious words.
Level 2 (5-8 marks): A range of sentence structures is used, mostly securely, and sometimes for purpose and effect. Punctuation is generally accurate with occasional errors. Vocabulary is appropriate and shows some evidence of being selected for deliberate effects. Spelling is generally accurate with occasional errors with common and more complex words.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Simple sentences are used with some attempt to use more complex structures. Some punctuation is used but there is a lack of control and consistency. Vocabulary is straightforward and relevant with mostly accurate spelling of simple words.
0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.AO6 guidance for this task:
Sentence structures: measured sentences for the descent; a stark short sentence for the moment of darkness ('The lamps went out.'); fragments for single sounds and sensations; a long sentence that gropes and accumulates as the writer tries to describe the dark; quiet, reflective sentences at the end.
Punctuation for effect: dashes to interrupt and to add sudden sensations; colons to introduce what was heard or felt; semicolons to set sensations side by side; dialogue, such as a guide's words, punctuated accurately; numbers handled consistently.
Vocabulary: precise vocabulary for the place (shaft, cage, seam, tunnel, pit props, ventilation door, coal dust, lamp, helmet) and for darkness and the senses (impenetrable, absolute, disorientated, claustrophobic, acute, tingling, clammy); avoidance of cliches through fresh comparisons.
Spelling of words this task is likely to need: darkness, claustrophobic, disorientated, ventilation, separate, definitely, conscious, unconscious, immediately, extraordinary, atmosphere, gradually, believe, rhythm, ceiling.
Level 4 rather than Level 3: Level 4 uses sentence structure and punctuation to make the reader experience the descent and the darkness (a sudden short sentence; a long, searching one) and chooses vocabulary that is precise and subtle, with secure spelling of ambitious and technical words. Level 3 is varied and accurate, but the place is described with less precision and the sentence choices are less clearly tied to effect.