Question 1
40 marksWriting imaginatively and creatively
You should spend about 1 hour on this task. You will be assessed on the quality of your extended response. You should plan and check your work carefully.
Write about a time when you had to trust someone else to keep you safe.
In your writing you should describe:
• what you were doing and who you had to trust
• how it felt to put your safety in their hands
• how the experience has changed the way you think about trust.
[40]
Model answer
If you had asked me, at the start of Year 10, to name the last person in the world I would trust with my life, I would have said Reece Marwood without even stopping to think.
Reece had been making my life slightly worse since Year 7. Nothing dramatic. He did an impression of the way I said 'bath'. He moved my chair when I stood up. Once, in a science lesson, he told the whole class that I had cried at the end of a film about a horse, which was true, and which I have never forgiven. So when we arrived at the crag for our outdoor-education day and the instructor, Rhian, began pairing people up, I prayed for anyone else.
'Marwood,' she said. 'You're with --' and then my name.
Reece looked at me. I looked at the sky.
The crag was a fifteen-metre face of grey limestone above a river, streaked with orange and polished smooth in places by years of hands and boots. The instructors had fixed steel anchors at the top of each route, and from each one a rope came down to the ground. One person climbs, tied to one end. The other person, the belayer, stands at the bottom holding the other end through a little metal device clipped to their harness, taking in the slack as the climber goes up. If the climber falls, the belayer locks the rope, and the climber stops. That is the theory. In practice, it means that when you are fifteen metres up a cliff, the only thing between you and the ground is the person at the bottom.
In my case, that was Reece Marwood.
'Climb when ready,' he said, as Rhian had taught us. He sounded bored.
'Climbing,' I said.
For the first ten metres, I was almost enjoying it. Then I looked down. Reece was a small figure in a blue helmet, his face tipped up towards me, and I thought about my chair, and the horse film, and the way he laughed, and I could not believe I had agreed to this. My hands were sweating so much that the chalk turned to paste. My left leg began to shake, a fast, uncontrollable trembling that Rhian later told me climbers call 'sewing-machine leg'. The last part of the route went over a bulge in the rock, and to get past it I had to let go with one hand and reach for a hold I could not quite see.
I reached. My foot slipped. And I fell.
It was not far. Half a metre, perhaps. But in that half-metre my stomach left my body and I heard myself make a noise I hope nobody else heard. Then the harness bit hard into my legs, the rope went tight, and I was dangling against the rock, turning slowly, completely still in the air.
I looked down.
Reece was leaning back against the rope with his whole weight, both hands locked on it below the device, his feet braced, his face white. He was not bored now. He was staring up at me as if nothing else in the world existed.
'I've got you,' he shouted. His voice cracked. 'I've got you. I've got you.'
He lowered me slowly, smoothly, the way we had practised, and when my feet touched the ground my legs gave way and I sat down. Reece crouched next to me. His hands, I noticed, were shaking more than mine.
'That was horrible,' he said quietly. 'Don't do that again.'
Then it was his turn to climb, and my turn to hold the rope. And halfway up, Reece Marwood -- who had done impressions of me for three years -- froze, and clung to the rock, and asked me in a very small voice whether I was definitely still holding on. I said I was. I said it about twenty times, all the way to the top and all the way down.
Reece and I never became friends. But he has not done the impression since, and when we pass each other in the corridor, we nod -- the small nod of two people who know something about each other that nobody else does.
I used to think trust was something you gave to people you liked, as a kind of reward. That afternoon taught me that liking has very little to do with it. Trust is about what somebody does when your whole weight is on the other end of the rope. Reece did not like me, and I did not like him, and neither of us let go. The rope never asked how we felt about each other. It only worked because we both held on.
Explanation
Establishing Reece as the last person the writer would trust means that the moment the rope holds changes how the two of them see each other, not only whether the writer falls, and the climbing set-up is explained so clearly that the reader knows exactly what is at stake. The fall is told through the body -- the sweating hands, the 'sewing-machine leg', the half-metre drop -- and the swapped roles reveal that Reece was frightened too. The reflection that trust has little to do with liking someone grows from the experience; weaker answers describe a whole activity day and then add a sentence saying that trust is important.
Mark scheme
-
24 marks
Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). AO5: Communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively, selecting and adapting tone, style and register for different forms, purposes and audiences. AO5: Organise information and ideas, using structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion of texts.
Level 6 (21-24 marks): The form is deliberately adapted to position the reader, showing a sophisticated control of purpose and effect. Tone, style and register are ambitiously selected and deployed to enhance the purpose of the task. There is a skilfully controlled overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used to support coherence and cohesion and achieve a range of effects.
Level 5 (17-20 marks): The form is confidently adapted and shows a secure understanding of purpose and audience. There is a sustained use of tone, style and register to fulfil the purpose of the task. There is a controlled overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used to support coherence and cohesion and achieve particular effects.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The form is adapted to show a clear understanding of purpose and audience. Tone, style and register are chosen to match the task. There is a well-managed overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used to support coherence and cohesion, and sometimes for effect.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): The form is sustained and shows clear awareness of purpose and audience. Tone, style and register are appropriate for the task, with some inconsistencies. There is a clear overall structure, with paragraphs and grammatical features used, mostly securely, to support coherence and cohesion.OCR's level descriptors, continued: Level 2 (5-8 marks): The form, which is mostly appropriate for purpose and audience, is generally maintained. There is an attempt to use a tone, style and register appropriate to the task. There is some evidence of overall structure, with some use of paragraphs and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion. Level 1 (1-4 marks): There is some attempt to use a form appropriate for purpose and audience. There is a limited attempt to use a tone, style and register appropriate for the task. There is some attempt to structure the response, with limited evidence of paragraphs or grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion. 0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.
Indicative content for this task (not a checklist; reward other effective approaches):
Form and approach: personal writing about a time when the writer's safety depended on someone else -- a climbing partner holding the rope, an instructor on a zip wire or in a kayak, a driver on a dangerous road, a parent in a storm, a stranger giving directions in the dark. Responses may be true or imagined, as long as they read as personal writing in the first person. The best answers focus on one experience and make the relationship with the trusted person central: who they were, why trusting them was difficult or easy, and what changed.
Bullet 1 (what you were doing and who you had to trust): the activity should be explained clearly enough for any reader to understand where the danger lay, with precise, plausible detail; the other person should be characterised, ideally with some tension between them and the writer (a stranger, a rival, someone the writer doubts).
Bullet 2 (how it felt to put your safety in their hands): this is the heart of the task -- the body's fear, the moment of letting go or committing, and the instant when trust is tested (a slip, a fall, a sudden decision). The feeling should be shown through sensation and action rather than named.
Bullet 3 (how it has changed the way you think about trust): mature reflection that grows from the experience, for example that trust has less to do with liking someone than with what they do when it matters, or that the trusted person was also afraid. A changed relationship or habit, shown in a final image, works well.
Level 6 here: the form is deliberately adapted to position the reader -- for example, the writer's distrust of the other person is established first, so that the moment the rope holds changes the relationship as well as ending the danger. Tone is ambitiously selected, combining wry honesty with physical fear. The structure is skilfully controlled: set-up, the climb or ordeal, the test, a reversal (perhaps the roles swap), and a reflective ending.
Levels 3-4: an account of a whole activity day with the moment of trust brief; the other person barely characterised; the danger unclear; feelings asserted ('I was terrified but I trusted him'); a moral about trust tacked on at the end. -
16 marks
Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy). AO6: Use a range of vocabulary and sentence structures for clarity, purpose and effect, with accurate spelling and punctuation.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): An ambitious range of sentence structures is used to shape meaning and create impact. Accurate punctuation is used to enhance clarity and achieve particular effects. Vocabulary is precise and subtle, expressing complex ideas with clarity. Spelling of irregular and ambitious words is accurate, with very occasional lapses.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): A wide range of sentence structures is used for deliberate purpose and effect. Punctuation is consistently accurate and is used to achieve clarity. Vocabulary is sometimes ambitious and used convincingly for purpose and effect. Spelling, including complex regular words, is accurate; there may be occasional errors with irregular and ambitious words.
Level 2 (5-8 marks): A range of sentence structures is used, mostly securely, and sometimes for purpose and effect. Punctuation is generally accurate with occasional errors. Vocabulary is appropriate and shows some evidence of being selected for deliberate effects. Spelling is generally accurate with occasional errors with common and more complex words.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Simple sentences are used with some attempt to use more complex structures. Some punctuation is used but there is a lack of control and consistency. Vocabulary is straightforward and relevant with mostly accurate spelling of simple words.
0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.AO6 guidance for this task:
Sentence structures: clear explanatory sentences for how the activity works; long, straining sentences for the climb or ordeal; short sentences and fragments for the test ('My foot slipped.'); calls or instructions as single lines of speech; a measured, reflective close.
Punctuation for effect: dialogue and set calls punctuated accurately, each on a new line; dashes for sudden movement and interruption; colons to introduce an explanation; semicolons to balance two people's experiences; italics are unavailable, so stress must come from word order and punctuation.
Vocabulary: precise vocabulary for the activity (harness, karabiner, belay device, top rope, anchor, holds, ledge, chalk, slack) and for trust and fear (wary, resentful, reluctant, vulnerable, reassured, grudging); exact physical verbs (grip, smear, lunge, brace, dangle).
Spelling of words this task is likely to need: karabiner, harness, separate, definitely, conscious, embarrassed, desperately, vulnerable, immediately, muscles, rhythm, limestone, believe, necessary, relief.
Level 4 rather than Level 3: Level 4 uses sentence structure to carry the reader through the physical experience (tension building, the jolt of the fall, release) and punctuates speech, calls and description with complete accuracy; vocabulary is precise and subtle, so that the change in the relationship is implied through gesture. Level 3 is varied and accurate, but technical and emotional vocabulary is used less precisely, and the sentences describe the experience rather than enacting it.