Question 1
12 marksRead the text below. Then answer the question that follows.
Text 2
Composure
From a novel by Ivo Brannigan (fictional), 2020
In this extract from a novel, the narrator remembers playing the cello in a music competition for the first time, at the age of fifteen.
[1] There is a sheet of pale green paper in my desk drawer that I have never thrown away. It is folded into quarters, and at the top, in an adjudicator's quick blue handwriting, it says: Class 14, Strings Under 16. Competitor 7. I was competitor 7. I was fifteen, and I had never played to anyone except my teacher, my gran and the cat.
[2] The festival was held in a school hall that smelled of floor polish and wet coats. There were rows of plastic chairs, parents fanning themselves with programmes, and at the front, at a small table with a reading lamp, the adjudicator: a woman with silver hair cut like a helmet and a pen she kept clicking. Competitors one to six played. I heard none of them. I sat with my cello between my knees like something I was trying to hide behind, and counted my own heartbeats until I lost count.
[3] "Number seven," said the steward, and the whole hall seemed to tilt towards me.
[4] I had chosen The Swan because it was slow. That was my reasoning at fifteen: slow meant safe. Nobody had told me that slow is where nerves live. Fast music hurries you past your fear; slow music makes you sit inside it. I had learned it by heart, because my teacher said that was braver, and the first note is long, a single stroke of the bow that is meant to float. Mrs Adair played the rippling introduction on the piano. I drew the bow across the string, and I felt it begin to shake.
[5] It was not much of a shake. I know that now. At the time it felt like an earthquake. The bow juddered on the string like a car crossing a cattle grid, and I was certain that every person in that hall could hear it: the parents, the steward, the adjudicator with her clicking pen, the man at the back who had come in to fix a radiator. My face burned. Somewhere far below me, my left hand went on finding the notes by itself, as if it belonged to a calmer person.
[6] Then, halfway through, the music simply left. One moment I knew the next phrase as well as my own name; the next there was a white space where it should have been, clean and total, like a page torn out of a book. My bow stopped. The hall stopped. I could hear the radiator ticking.
[7] Mrs Adair did not stop. I have thought about that for sixteen years. She played the same bar again, softly, and then again, as if nothing in the world were wrong, as if this were simply how the piece went, and on the third time round my fingers remembered before I did. I came back in. I played to the end. The last note was long, too, and this time, for no reason I could name, the bow was still.
[8] There was applause, the warm, polite clapping of people who have heard the same piece three times since breakfast. I bowed to the floor and walked off without looking up, sure that I had just failed in public in the most complete way a person could.
[9] "That bit where you slowed right down," Gran said in the corridor, gripping both my hands. "I nearly cried. Did you do that on purpose?"
[10] I came third out of nine. When the adjudicator gave her results, she said something about my tone that I did not hear, because I was waiting for her to mention the silence. She never did. On the green sheet she had written six lines, and the last, which I have read so often that the fold has worn through it, says: A memory lapse, recovered with real composure. Lovely singing sound.
[11] Composure. I had felt like a building coming down. From the third row, it had looked like a choice.
[12] I teach now. Every year one of my students walks onto a stage with shaking knees and comes off certain that everything is ruined, and every year I tell them what nobody told me. The audience is not inside your body. They cannot hear your heart. They hear the music, and they hear you come back.
Glossary: adjudicator - the judge of a music competition, who writes comments on each performance; steward - a helper who calls the competitors; The Swan - a slow piece for cello and piano by the French composer Camille Saint-Saens
Question 3 is about Text 2, Composure by Ivo Brannigan (fictional).
Look again at paragraphs 5 to 7.
Explore how Ivo Brannigan uses language and structure to describe what happens during the narrator's performance.
Support your ideas by using relevant subject terminology. [12]
Model answer
Brannigan presents the performance through two perspectives at once: the fifteen-year-old who lives through it and the adult who has 'thought about that for sixteen years'. The three paragraphs form three stages, the shaking bow, the blank and the recovery, and the pace slows almost to nothing before starting again.
Paragraph 5 opens with the older narrator's understatement, 'It was not much of a shake. I know that now.', which is immediately set against the hyperbole 'At the time it felt like an earthquake.' This contrast between then and now introduces the idea that the memory is bigger than the event. The onomatopoeic verb in 'juddered on the string like a car crossing a cattle grid' makes the sound jolting and ugly, and the list after the colon, from 'the parents' to 'the man at the back who had come in to fix a radiator', shows the narrator imagining that every single person is listening to the mistake. The short sentence 'My face burned.' captures shame physically. Then the image of the left hand that 'went on finding the notes by itself, as if it belonged to a calmer person' personifies the hand and splits the narrator in two, the body working while the mind panics.
In paragraph 6 the personification 'the music simply left' makes memory desert the narrator as if it were a person walking out. The antithesis of 'One moment ... the next' marks how sudden this is, and the simile 'like a page torn out of a book' suits someone playing from memory, since the 'white space' is total. Brannigan then stops the paragraph with parallel short sentences, 'My bow stopped. The hall stopped.', so that time seems to freeze, and the sound of 'the radiator ticking', which links back to the workman of paragraph 5, magnifies the silence.
Paragraph 7 turns on repetition: 'Mrs Adair did not stop.' answers the two stops before it. The narrator's comment 'I have thought about that for sixteen years' interrupts the action to show how much this small kindness mattered. The repeated 'again' and the anaphora of 'as if nothing in the world were wrong, as if this were simply how the piece went' show the accompanist calmly covering the gap, and the personification 'my fingers remembered before I did' lets the body lead the recovery. The short sentences 'I came back in. I played to the end.' make the ending of the crisis quick and plain. Finally, the long last note on which 'the bow was still' echoes and reverses the shaking first note, giving the performance a circular shape, while 'for no reason I could name' keeps a sense of mystery about why the shaking has stopped.
Explanation
The strongest answers notice the two voices in these paragraphs, the panicking fifteen-year-old and the older narrator who knows 'that now', and analyse how Brannigan uses them, with the slowing and restarting pace, to show a moment that felt far bigger than it was. Language comments should be precise about effects: the simile of the cattle grid, the personified hand and fingers, the parallel 'My bow stopped. The hall stopped.' Answers should call the performer "the narrator", since the text never gives a gender, and should not stray to Gran's or the adjudicator's comments in later paragraphs.
Mark scheme
-
12 marks
Levels of response (12 marks). AO2: Explain, comment on and analyse how writers use language and structure to achieve effects and influence readers, using relevant subject terminology to support their views.
Level 6 (11-12 marks): A skilled analysis which demonstrates a sophisticated appreciation of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Candidates' analysis of both language and structure is detailed and integrated. Precisely-selected and integrated subject terminology deployed to enhance the response.
Level 5 (9-10 marks): An analysis which demonstrates a perceptive understanding of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Candidates' analysis of both language and structure is reasonably detailed and balanced. Well-chosen subject terminology integrated into explanations.
Level 4 (7-8 marks): A developed explanation which shows a secure understanding of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Candidates comment on the effects of both language and structure, but the explanation may not be entirely balanced. Relevant terminology should be used to develop ideas.
Level 3 (5-6 marks): A clear explanation which shows a general understanding of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Candidates refer to both language and structure but may not give a full explanation of the effects. Some use of relevant subject terminology to support ideas.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): A straightforward commentary which shows some understanding of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Candidates are likely to refer more fully to either language or structure and note some features without explaining the effects. Some use of subject terminology, though it may not always be relevant.OCR's level descriptors, continued: Level 1 (1-2 marks): A descriptive response which shows limited awareness of how the writer has used language and structure to achieve effects and influence the reader. Little or no use of subject terminology. 0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.
Max 8 if the response does not achieve a reasonable balance between references to language and to structure: OCR's guidance says such a response 'cannot achieve the higher levels' (OCR J351/02 mark scheme, June 2023), and Levels 5 and 6 need analysis of both that is balanced. Credit only comments on paragraphs 5-7, which the question names.
Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points supported from paragraphs 5-7):
Language: 'It was not much of a shake. I know that now. At the time it felt like an earthquake.' (understatement against hyperbole; then and now): the gap between the fact and the feeling. 'juddered on the string like a car crossing a cattle grid' (onomatopoeic verb, simile): a jolting, ugly sound. The list after the colon ('the parents, the steward, the adjudicator with her clicking pen, the man at the back') and 'every person in that hall could hear it' (exaggerated certainty): everyone seems to be listening to the mistake. 'My face burned.' (short sentence, metaphor of heat): shame. 'my left hand went on finding the notes by itself, as if it belonged to a calmer person' (personification, simile): the body split from the mind. 'the music simply left' (personification): memory deserts the narrator. 'One moment ... the next there was a white space' (antithesis); 'clean and total, like a page torn out of a book' (simile): the blank is complete. 'My bow stopped. The hall stopped.' (parallel short sentences, repetition): time freezes. 'I could hear the radiator ticking.' (auditory detail): the silence magnified. 'Mrs Adair did not stop.' (repetition of 'stop', contrast). 'again, softly, and then again' (repetition) and 'as if nothing in the world were wrong, as if this were simply how the piece went' (anaphora): the accompanist's calm covers the gap. 'my fingers remembered before I did' (personification): the body leads the recovery. 'I came back in. I played to the end.' (short sentences): a quick, plain resolution.
Structure: the dual perspective of the older narrator ('I know that now', 'I have thought about that for sixteen years') interrupts the moment and shows how much it mattered. Each paragraph is a stage (the shaking bow, the blank, the recovery), and the pace slows to a stop in paragraph 6 before restarting in paragraph 7. The radiator, mentioned in paragraph 5, returns as the only sound in paragraph 6. The still bow on the long last note echoes and reverses the shaking first note.
Higher-level analysis shows how the then-and-now voice and the stop-start pace make a small slip feel enormous; mid-level work explains separate images and sentence forms; lower-level work retells what went wrong.