"Humans have the right to use the Earth's resources however they want."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religious and non-religious beliefs, such as those held by Humanists and atheists, in your answer.)
Model answer
Some people would agree with this statement, at least in part. Genesis 1:28 records God telling humans to 'subdue' the earth and 'have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over every living thing', and Psalm 8:6 says that God has put all things 'under his feet'. In the past some Christians interpreted dominion as permission to use nature for human benefit, and the historian Lynn White argued in 1967 that this attitude helped cause the ecological crisis. Some people argue that humans are made in the image of God and are more valuable than the rest of creation, so human needs come first; using resources such as fuel, land and minerals has lifted billions of people out of poverty. Some atheists might also argue that, without a God who owns the earth, there is no higher authority to tell humans how to use it.
However, almost all religions and most non-religious people reject the idea that humans can use resources however they want. Most Christians today interpret dominion as stewardship: the earth belongs to God ('The earth is the LORD's, and the fulness thereof', Psalm 24:1), and humans were put in Eden 'to dress it and to keep it' (Genesis 2:15). Pope Francis wrote in Laudato Si' (2015) that dominion does not justify absolute domination over other creatures, and he called for an ecological conversion. Jews follow bal tashchit, the command not to destroy needlessly, which comes from the ban on cutting down fruit trees in Deuteronomy 20:19-20, and the story of Honi and the carob tree teaches that we must plant for future generations. Muslims believe they are khalifah, Allah's stewards, who will be judged on the Day of Judgement for how they used the trust (amanah) given to them; the Prophet taught Muslims not to waste water even when washing for prayer beside a flowing river. Hindus practise ahimsa, non-violence towards all living things, because Brahman is in everything: Krishna says that he is the eternal seed of all beings (Bhagavad Gita 7.10). Sikhs believe that God is present in creation, and the Guru Granth Sahib describes air as the guru, water as the father and the earth as the great mother of all (GGS 8). Buddhists follow the second Precept, not taking what is not given, which many apply to taking more than our share of the earth's resources, and they believe in pratitya samutpada: harming nature harms everything, including ourselves.
Non-religious people also generally disagree. Humanists believe that this is the only planet and the only life we have, and that no God will save us from the consequences of our actions. They base their views on scientific evidence, which shows that over-use of fossil fuels is causing climate change, and Humanist Climate Action encourages humanists to take action on it. Humanists argue that we have a responsibility to future generations and to other sentient creatures, so we must use resources sustainably; Peter Singer argues that the interests of animals that can suffer must be taken into account. They also point out that climate change harms the poorest people most, so using resources however we want would be unjust.
In conclusion, I strongly disagree with the statement. Humans may have the right to use the earth's resources to meet their genuine needs, and religions such as Christianity and Islam teach that God provided the earth for human benefit. However, the phrase 'however they want' ignores the responsibilities that come with that right. Religious teachings about stewardship, khalifah and ahimsa, and Humanist concern for future generations, all show that resources must be used wisely and sustainably, especially now that climate change threatens the poorest people and the generations still to come.
Explanation
A top answer recognises the arguments that seem to support the statement (dominion, human development) before evaluating the strong religious and non-religious arguments against it. Using a range of specification sources (Genesis 1:28, Psalm 8:6, Honi, khalifah, the second Precept, Humanist Climate Action) and focusing on the key phrase 'however they want' reaches Level 5.