"Human life is more valuable than animal life."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religious and non-religious beliefs, such as those held by Humanists and atheists, in your answer.)
Model answer
This statement raises the question of whether being human gives a life greater value, or whether all living beings that can suffer deserve equal consideration.
Many religious believers agree with the statement. Christians believe that only humans are made in the image of God (Genesis 1:27) and that God gave humans dominion over the animals (Genesis 1:26-28). Jesus told his followers not to be afraid because they were 'of more value than many sparrows' (Matthew 10:31). The Catholic Church teaches that animals may be used for food and clothing, and for medical experiments within reasonable limits, because human life is of greater value, although animals must not be made to suffer needlessly. Muslims believe humans are Allah's khalifah (vicegerents) on earth (Qur'an 2:30), with a responsibility and status that animals do not have. Even in the Dharmic religions, a human birth is seen as especially precious: Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists believe that only as a human can a soul or being reach moksha, mukti or enlightenment, and Guru Granth Sahib 12 calls the human body the opportunity to meet God. Many non-religious people also agree, arguing that humans' self-awareness, reason, conscience and complex relationships give human life greater value, and that animal research has helped to save millions of human lives.
On the other hand, the philosopher Peter Singer argues that this view is speciesism, a prejudice like racism or sexism. Following Jeremy Bentham's question 'Can they suffer?', Singer says that what matters morally is the capacity to suffer, and that the similar suffering of an animal deserves equal consideration. He points out that some animals, such as chimpanzees, are more self-aware than some humans, such as newborn babies. Darwin's theory of evolution supports the idea that humans are animals who share common ancestors with other species, so there is no sharp line between them. Many Humanists therefore oppose cruelty and factory farming, and some are vegetarian or vegan. Religious traditions also give animal life great value. Hindus believe the atman is present in all beings and that the wise see the same self in a Brahmin, a cow, an elephant and a dog (Bhagavad Gita 5:18), so many practise ahimsa and vegetarianism. Buddhists apply the first precept to all living beings, and Muslims learn from the Qur'an that animals form communities like human ones (Qur'an 6:38). Among Christians, Pope Francis taught in Laudato Si' that other creatures have value in themselves, not only because they are useful to humans.
In conclusion, there are strong reasons to see human life as special: humans have unique abilities and, for many believers, a unique relationship with God and the chance of spiritual liberation. However, Singer is right that the suffering of animals matters, and almost every religion agrees that animals must be treated with care. I think the best view is that human life has a special value because humans have greater responsibility, but this should lead humans to protect animals rather than to treat them as worthless. Human life may be more valuable, but animal life is still valuable.
Explanation
The best answers explain Singer's argument about speciesism accurately and set it against religious teachings such as Genesis 1:27 and Qur'an 2:30, while noticing that religions also value animal life (Bhagavad Gita 5:18, Qur'an 6:38, Laudato Si'). Level 5 needs this diversity, detailed non-religious views and a reasoned conclusion rather than a simple yes or no.