"'An eye for an eye' is the fairest way to punish criminals."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Some people would agree with this statement. The principle of 'an eye for an eye' appears in the Torah: 'Breach for breach, eye for eye, tooth for tooth: as he hath caused a blemish in a man, so shall it be done to him again' (Leviticus 24:20; also Exodus 21:24). Its central idea is proportion: the punishment should match the crime, no more and no less. This seems fair because offenders get exactly what they deserve, victims see that justice has been done, and the same rule applies to rich and poor alike. In its own time the law was a great advance, because it limited revenge and stopped blood feuds in which a minor injury could lead to killing. The Qur'an also refers to this principle, saying that in the Torah God ordained 'a life for a life, an eye for an eye' (5:45), and Shariah law permits proportionate retribution, qisas, for murder and injury (2:178). Some non-religious thinkers, such as the philosopher Immanuel Kant, also argued that punishment should be based on what the offender deserves. Supporters of the death penalty for murder often appeal to this principle.
However, many religious believers disagree. Jesus directly challenged it: 'Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth: But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil' (Matthew 5:38-39). He taught Christians to turn the other cheek and to love their enemies (Matthew 5:43-47), and most Christians believe that punishment should aim at reformation and reconciliation, not at repaying harm with harm. Even in Judaism, the rabbis of the Talmud did not apply the principle literally: they interpreted 'eye for eye' as requiring fair financial compensation for an injury. The Qur'an, while allowing qisas, also says that whoever gives up the right to retaliation as an act of charity will have it count as atonement for their own sins (5:45), and that whoever pardons will be rewarded by Allah (42:40). Buddhists would argue that answering harm with harm only increases suffering and bad karma, because hatred is overcome only by non-hatred (Dhammapada 5), and many Hindus and Sikhs influenced by ahimsa would agree. There are also practical problems: an 'eye for an eye' cannot apply literally to many crimes, such as fraud, drug dealing or cybercrime, and if taken literally it would require the state to commit acts of cruelty. It also ignores the circumstances of the crime, such as poverty or mental illness, which a relative approach to morality would take into account. Humanists would argue that punishment should reduce future harm through rehabilitation and protection, not simply repay suffering.
In conclusion, I think the idea behind 'an eye for an eye', that punishment should be proportionate to the crime, is an important part of fairness, and religions such as Judaism and Islam rightly value it. However, as a literal method of punishment it is not the fairest way, because it ignores the circumstances of the offender, cannot be applied to many crimes and leaves no room for reform, mercy or forgiveness. A fair punishment should be proportionate, but it should also aim to change the offender, as Jesus' teaching and the rabbinic interpretation of the law both suggest.
Explanation
Strong answers distinguish between the principle of proportion, which most people accept as fair, and literal retaliation, which few support. Knowing that the rabbis interpreted 'eye for eye' as compensation, and that the Qur'an praises forgiveness even where qisas is allowed, shows excellent understanding of diversity. Answers that only quote Jesus' 'turn the other cheek' without evaluating the case for proportionate justice stay at Level 2 or 3.