Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/12

Crime and punishment: morality, the aims of punishment and the death penalty

Practise 36 exam-style questions on Crime and punishment: morality, the aims of punishment and the death penalty for Eduqas GCSE Religious Studies (Philosophy and Ethics). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 36 questions
  • 2–21 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

What is meant by 'absolute morality'?

Model answer

Absolute morality is the belief that certain actions are always right or always wrong in every situation, whatever the circumstances or consequences. For example, a Christian who holds absolute morality might believe that 'Thou shalt not kill' (Exodus 20:13) means that taking an innocent life is wrong in all circumstances.

Explanation

Absolute morality is the opposite of relative morality, in which the right action depends on the situation. Many religious believers hold absolute views on some issues because they believe the rules come from God, who does not change. The second mark needs development, such as 'whatever the consequences', or an example.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A basic or partial meaning: moral rules that never change / some actions are always right or always wrong.

    Accept 'rules that apply to everyone at all times', 'fixed moral rules'.

  2. 1 mark

    An accurate, developed meaning: absolute morality is the belief that some actions are always right or always wrong, whatever the situation, culture or consequences, because there are universal moral rules (for many believers given by God) that apply to everyone at all times; or the basic meaning with a relevant example, e.g. believing that killing an innocent person is wrong in every circumstance; keeping the Ten Commandments as unbreakable rules; the Catholic teaching that some acts are wrong in themselves.

    Two marks for an accurate and appropriate account of the concept; one mark for an account limited in scope or content. Credit valid alternatives, e.g. an accurate explanation by contrast with relative morality.

Question 2

5 marks

Describe how Christians interpret Matthew 5:38-39 and 43-47 when considering the death penalty.

Model answer

In Matthew 5:38-39 Jesus quoted the law 'An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth' but told his followers 'resist not evil' and to turn the other cheek. In Matthew 5:43-47 he taught 'Love your enemies' and to pray for those who persecute them. Liberal Christians interpret these verses as meaning that Jesus replaced retribution with love and forgiveness, so Christians should oppose the death penalty, which takes a life in return for a life and removes any chance of repentance. The Catholic Church now teaches that the death penalty is 'inadmissible'. However, some conservative Christians argue that these verses are about how individuals should respond to personal wrongs, not about the duty of the state. They point to Romans 13:4, which says the ruler 'beareth not the sword in vain', and to Genesis 9:6, and so support the death penalty for the worst murders.

Explanation

The top level needs both what the verses say and how different Christians interpret them; describing only one view limits the answer. The key distinction is between applying Jesus' teaching to the state's system of justice (liberal) and limiting it to personal revenge (conservative). Supporting the conservative view with Romans 13 or Genesis 9:6 shows detailed knowledge.

Mark scheme
  1. 5 marks

    Levels of response (5 marks). AO1: knowledge and understanding.
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): An excellent, coherent description showing accurate knowledge and understanding of Jesus' teaching in Matthew 5:38-39 and 43-47 (rejecting 'an eye for an eye', turning the other cheek, loving enemies) and of the different ways liberal and conservative Christians interpret it in relation to the death penalty, and how this influences their views; a range of specialist terms and sources of wisdom and authority used accurately.
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): A good, generally accurate description of the teaching with some understanding of how Christians apply it to the death penalty; specialist terms and/or sources used generally accurately.
    Level 1 (1 mark): A limited statement of relevant information, e.g. that Jesus said to turn the other cheek so Christians are against the death penalty; limited use of specialist terms or sources.
    0 marks: no relevant information.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Matthew 5:38-39: Jesus quotes 'An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth' and says 'resist not evil' but turn the other cheek, rejecting revenge. Matthew 5:43-47: 'Love your enemies, bless them that curse you... pray for them which despitefully use you'; God sends sun and rain on the evil and the good; loving only those who love you is no better than what tax collectors do. Liberal interpretation: Jesus replaced retribution with love (agape) and forgiveness, so Christians should oppose the death penalty, which repays a life with a life; loving enemies includes murderers; every life is sacred (Genesis 1:27; Exodus 20:13 'Thou shalt not kill'); execution removes the chance of repentance; Jesus stopped the stoning of a woman: 'He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her' (John 8:7). The Catholic Church teaches that the death penalty is 'inadmissible' (Catechism, revised by Pope Francis in 2018); the Church of England, Methodists and Quakers oppose it; Sister Helen Prejean. Conservative interpretation: these verses concern personal relationships and revenge, not the duty of the state; the ruler 'beareth not the sword in vain' (Romans 13:4) and punishes wrongdoers on God's behalf; Genesis 9:6 ('Whoso sheddeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed'); Exodus 20:13 forbids murder, not lawful execution; Thomas Aquinas accepted execution to protect the common good; some conservative Christians, especially in the USA, support the death penalty for the worst murders.

Question 3

8 marks

From two different religions or two religious traditions, explain attitudes towards the aims of punishment.

Model answer

Christians believe that justice is part of God's nature and that governments have a God-given duty to punish wrongdoers: Paul wrote that the ruler is 'the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath upon him that doeth evil' (Romans 13:4). Most Christians therefore accept that punishment should be just and can deter crime and protect society. However, many Christians are uneasy about retribution. Although the Old Testament allowed 'eye for eye' (Exodus 21:24), Jesus told his followers not to take revenge but to turn the other cheek (Matthew 5:38-39). For this reason many Christians see reformation as the most important aim: Jesus told the woman caught in adultery, 'go, and sin no more' (John 8:11). The Catholic Church teaches that punishment should put right the harm done to society, protect people and, as far as possible, help to correct the offender. These beliefs inspire Christians to work as prison chaplains and to run courses such as Prison Fellowship's Sycamore Tree. Conservative Christians may give more weight to retribution and deterrence than liberal Christians do.

Jews also believe that punishment must serve justice: 'Justice, justice shall you pursue' (Deuteronomy 16:20). The Torah sets out proportionate retribution, 'eye for eye, tooth for tooth' (Leviticus 24:20), which the rabbis of the Talmud interpreted as fair compensation for injury. Deterrence is also found in the Torah: after a punishment, others 'shall hear, and fear' and will not do the same evil (Deuteronomy 19:20). Reformation is central because of teshuvah, the belief that anyone can turn back to God and change their ways. Orthodox Jews uphold the Torah's principles of justice as God's law, while Reform Jews put particular emphasis on rehabilitation and on the dignity of offenders, who are made in God's image (Genesis 1:27).

Explanation

A strong answer covers several aims (justice, retribution, deterrence and reformation) for each religion, with a source for each, rather than just listing the aims. Level 4 also shows diversity, for example how Jesus' teaching led many Christians to reject retribution as revenge, or how the rabbis reinterpreted 'eye for eye'. Make sure both religions are developed equally, or the mark will be halved.

Mark scheme
  1. 8 marks

    Levels of response (8 marks). AO1: knowledge and understanding.
    Level 4 (7-8 marks): An excellent, highly detailed explanation of attitudes towards the aims of punishment (justice, retribution, deterrence and reformation) from two religions or religious traditions, showing knowledge and understanding of the diversity of these attitudes (e.g. which aims are stressed, attitudes to revenge, differences within a religion) and excellent understanding of their influence on individuals, communities and societies; a range of specialist terms and sources of wisdom and authority used extensively and accurately.
    Level 3 (5-6 marks): A very good, detailed explanation of attitudes towards the aims of punishment from two religions or traditions, with very good understanding of their diversity and influence; specialist terms and sources used accurately.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): A good, generally accurate explanation of some attitudes towards the aims of punishment with some understanding of their diversity; specialist terms and/or sources used generally accurately.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): A limited and/or poorly organised explanation, e.g. a list of the aims with little religious content; limited use of specialist terms and sources.
    0 marks: no relevant information.
    If only one religion or religious tradition is explained, mark using the levels and then halve the mark (round down).

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Christianity: justice: God is just and the state has authority to punish wrongdoers (Romans 13:1-4); retribution: 'eye for eye' (Exodus 21:24) limited revenge, but Jesus taught 'resist not evil' and to turn the other cheek (Matthew 5:38-39), so many Christians reject revenge; deterrence and protection accepted by many; reformation central: 'sinners to repentance' (Luke 5:32), 'go, and sin no more' (John 8:11), the Prodigal Son (Luke 15); the Catholic Catechism says punishment should redress the disorder caused, protect society and help correct the offender; chaplains, Prison Fellowship (Sycamore Tree); conservative Christians may stress retribution more than liberal Christians. Judaism: 'justice, justice shall you pursue' (Deuteronomy 16:20); proportionate retribution, 'eye for eye' (Leviticus 24:19-20), interpreted by the rabbis as compensation (Bava Kamma 83b-84a); deterrence: others 'shall hear, and fear' (Deuteronomy 19:20); reformation through teshuvah; Reform Jews stress rehabilitation. Islam: Allah commands justice (16:90); hudud (fixed punishments), qisas (retribution with the option of forgiveness and diyah, 2:178) and ta'zir; deterrence: 'in retaliation there is life' (2:179); reformation: Allah forgives those who repent and reform (5:39). Hinduism: danda, the ruler's duty to punish to uphold dharma and protect society (Manusmriti 7): justice, deterrence and protection; karma is cosmic justice; ahimsa leads many Hindus to favour reform. Sikhism: justice and equality before God; punishment should be fair and reform the offender; tankhah, a penance such as sewa imposed for breaking the Sikh code, is reformative. Buddhism: reformation most important (Angulimala; Milarepa); revenge rejected: hatred is overcome only by non-hatred (Dhammapada 5); karma brings its own consequences; protection of society accepted; karuna and metta.

Question 4

15 marks

"'An eye for an eye' is the fairest way to punish criminals."

Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)

Model answer

Some people would agree with this statement. The principle of 'an eye for an eye' appears in the Torah: 'Breach for breach, eye for eye, tooth for tooth: as he hath caused a blemish in a man, so shall it be done to him again' (Leviticus 24:20; also Exodus 21:24). Its central idea is proportion: the punishment should match the crime, no more and no less. This seems fair because offenders get exactly what they deserve, victims see that justice has been done, and the same rule applies to rich and poor alike. In its own time the law was a great advance, because it limited revenge and stopped blood feuds in which a minor injury could lead to killing. The Qur'an also refers to this principle, saying that in the Torah God ordained 'a life for a life, an eye for an eye' (5:45), and Shariah law permits proportionate retribution, qisas, for murder and injury (2:178). Some non-religious thinkers, such as the philosopher Immanuel Kant, also argued that punishment should be based on what the offender deserves. Supporters of the death penalty for murder often appeal to this principle.

However, many religious believers disagree. Jesus directly challenged it: 'Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth: But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil' (Matthew 5:38-39). He taught Christians to turn the other cheek and to love their enemies (Matthew 5:43-47), and most Christians believe that punishment should aim at reformation and reconciliation, not at repaying harm with harm. Even in Judaism, the rabbis of the Talmud did not apply the principle literally: they interpreted 'eye for eye' as requiring fair financial compensation for an injury. The Qur'an, while allowing qisas, also says that whoever gives up the right to retaliation as an act of charity will have it count as atonement for their own sins (5:45), and that whoever pardons will be rewarded by Allah (42:40). Buddhists would argue that answering harm with harm only increases suffering and bad karma, because hatred is overcome only by non-hatred (Dhammapada 5), and many Hindus and Sikhs influenced by ahimsa would agree. There are also practical problems: an 'eye for an eye' cannot apply literally to many crimes, such as fraud, drug dealing or cybercrime, and if taken literally it would require the state to commit acts of cruelty. It also ignores the circumstances of the crime, such as poverty or mental illness, which a relative approach to morality would take into account. Humanists would argue that punishment should reduce future harm through rehabilitation and protection, not simply repay suffering.

In conclusion, I think the idea behind 'an eye for an eye', that punishment should be proportionate to the crime, is an important part of fairness, and religions such as Judaism and Islam rightly value it. However, as a literal method of punishment it is not the fairest way, because it ignores the circumstances of the offender, cannot be applied to many crimes and leaves no room for reform, mercy or forgiveness. A fair punishment should be proportionate, but it should also aim to change the offender, as Jesus' teaching and the rabbinic interpretation of the law both suggest.

Explanation

Strong answers distinguish between the principle of proportion, which most people accept as fair, and literal retaliation, which few support. Knowing that the rabbis interpreted 'eye for eye' as compensation, and that the Qur'an praises forgiveness even where qisas is allowed, shows excellent understanding of diversity. Answers that only quote Jesus' 'turn the other cheek' without evaluating the case for proportionate justice stay at Level 2 or 3.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO2: analysis and evaluation.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): An excellent, highly detailed analysis and evaluation of whether 'an eye for an eye' (proportionate retribution) is the fairest way to punish criminals, based on detailed knowledge of religion, religious teaching and moral reasoning; presents different viewpoints (including views within the same religion, e.g. literal and rabbinic readings of the Torah, or qisas and the Qur'an's encouragement to forgive) and reaches well-supported judgements; excellent understanding of how belief influences individuals, communities and societies; uses and interprets specialist terms and sources of wisdom and authority extensively and accurately.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Very good, detailed analysis and evaluation of the statement with accurate knowledge, alternative viewpoints and judgements; specialist terms and sources used appropriately and in detail.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Good, generally detailed analysis of the statement with generally accurate knowledge, reasonable judgements and recognition of different viewpoints; some specialist terms or sources.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Limited statements of more than one viewpoint about 'an eye for an eye', based on limited knowledge; limited terms and sources.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A basic statement of one point of view, e.g. that criminals should suffer what they made others suffer, with very little or no attempt at judgement or alternative views.
    0 marks: no relevant point of view stated.
    An answer that gives only one point of view, or that does not refer to religion and belief, cannot go above Level 2.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Arguments for: proportionate justice: the punishment matches the crime (Leviticus 24:19-20; Exodus 21:23-25); offenders get what they deserve and victims see justice done; the same rule for rich and poor; it originally limited revenge and prevented blood feuds; the Qur'an refers to the principle ordained in the Torah (5:45) and Shariah permits qisas for murder and injury (2:178); Orthodox Jews see the principle of proportion as part of God's law; the philosopher Immanuel Kant argued that punishment should be based on what the offender deserves; supporters of the death penalty for murder appeal to it. Arguments against: Jesus challenged it: 'resist not evil', turn the other cheek, love your enemies (Matthew 5:38-39, 43-47); most Christians stress reformation and reconciliation; the rabbis interpreted it as compensation, not literal injury (Talmud, Bava Kamma 83b-84a); the Qur'an says that forgoing retaliation as charity is an atonement (5:45) and that whoever pardons will be rewarded by Allah (42:40); Buddhism: hatred is overcome only by non-hatred (Dhammapada 5) and revenge creates bad karma; Hindu and Sikh ahimsa; it cannot be applied literally to many crimes (fraud, drug offences, cybercrime) and would require the state to be cruel; it ignores circumstances such as poverty or mental illness (relative morality); it leaves no room for reform, mercy or forgiveness; Humanists stress reducing future harm through rehabilitation and protection. Possible conclusions: proportion is an essential part of fairness, but a literal 'eye for an eye' is not the fairest method; or retribution is fair for the most serious crimes; fairness needs justice combined with mercy and reform.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.