"After the Holocaust, it is impossible to believe in a loving God."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Some people agree with this statement. During the Holocaust (Shoah), about six million Jews, including over a million children, were murdered by the Nazis simply for being Jewish. If God is all-loving and all-powerful, it seems impossible that he would allow innocent people, including the people with whom he made a covenant, to suffer in this way. The Jewish theologian Richard Rubenstein concluded that he could no longer believe in the traditional God of history who chose Israel and acts to protect it. Elie Wiesel, who survived Auschwitz, described in Night how the experience consumed his faith, and he later wrote a play, The Trial of God, in which God is put on trial. Atheists and Humanists argue that the Holocaust is one of the clearest examples of the problem of evil: its scale seems far beyond anything that could be justified by free will or soul-making, and it is more honest to accept that no God watches over humanity, so that humans alone must make sure such evil never happens again.
However, many Jews and Christians continued to believe in a loving God after the Holocaust, which suggests it is not impossible. Eliezer Berkovits argued that God practised hester panim, 'hiding his face' (Deuteronomy 31:17-18), because humans must have free will, and free will means people can do terrible evil; the Nazis, not God, were responsible. Rabbi Hugo Gryn, who survived Auschwitz, suggested that the real question to ask is not where God was, but where humanity was. Emil Fackenheim argued that Jews have a duty to survive and keep their faith, so as not to give Hitler a posthumous victory. Many Jews in the camps kept praying and observing what they could, and some sang 'Ani Ma'amin', 'I believe with perfect faith'. Others turn to the Book of Job, which teaches that God's ways are beyond human understanding. Christians believe that God shares in human suffering through Jesus on the cross, and some Christians caught up in the Holocaust kept their faith and showed love in the midst of evil: Maximilian Kolbe, a Catholic priest, gave his life in place of another prisoner at Auschwitz, and Corrie ten Boom, who had hidden Jews, survived a concentration camp and spent the rest of her life speaking about forgiveness. Muslims would also say that people will be held to account by Allah on the Day of Judgement for the evil they freely chose.
It must also be remembered that these different responses come from people who experienced the Holocaust directly or lost family in it, and their views deserve respect whichever way they went.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. The Holocaust is an enormous challenge to belief in a loving God, and I understand why some people, both Jews and atheists, concluded that they could no longer believe. But it is clearly not 'impossible' to believe, since many survivors and religious thinkers did continue to believe, explaining the Holocaust as the result of human free will rather than God's will. The strongest religious response, in my view, is that the Holocaust shows how terrible human freedom can be, and places a duty on believers and non-believers alike to make sure it never happens again.