"Non-violent protest is the best way to fight racism."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Many religious believers would agree that non-violent protest is the best way to fight racism. The most famous example is Martin Luther King, a Baptist minister, who led the civil rights movement using boycotts, marches and sit-ins. The Montgomery Bus Boycott of 1955-56 ended segregation on the city's buses, and the March on Washington in 1963 helped persuade the US government to pass the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965. King based his methods on Jesus' teaching in the Sermon on the Mount to turn the other cheek and to love your enemies (Matthew 5:39-44), and on Jesus' warning that 'all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword' (Matthew 26:52). He believed that hatred cannot be overcome by more hatred, only by love (agape). He was also inspired by Gandhi, who developed satyagraha (truth-force) and ahimsa (non-violence) while challenging racial discrimination in South Africa. Buddhists would agree: the First Precept forbids harming living beings, and the Dhammapada teaches that 'hatred is never ended by hatred, but by love' (verse 5). Non-violent protest also works in practice, because it exposes injustice, wins public sympathy and does not create new hatred.
However, others argue that non-violent protest is not always the best way. Some religious traditions accept that force may be used as a last resort to defend the oppressed. Guru Gobind Singh taught that when all other means have failed, it is right to take up the sword, and Sikhs believe in protecting the weak. Christian Just War theory and the strict conditions of lesser jihad in Islam also allow force in defence against serious injustice, though most believers would say these apply to war, not to fighting racism in a democracy. Some civil rights activists also argued that people facing attacks had the right to defend themselves.
A stronger argument is that other non-violent methods may be more effective than protest. Laws such as the Equality Act 2010 make racial discrimination illegal and can be enforced. Education and interfaith dialogue, like the work of the Christian/Muslim Forum, tackle the prejudice and stereotypes that cause racism. Practical help, such as HIAS's work with refugees, shows love in action, and religious practices like the Sikh langar, where everyone eats together, teach equality by example. Protests can sometimes be ignored, and if they become disorderly they may turn public opinion against the cause. Humanists generally support peaceful protest as a democratic right, but would also stress the importance of education, reason and human rights law.
In conclusion, I believe non-violent protest is the best way to protest against racism, because it is consistent with religious teachings about love and non-violence and, as King and Gandhi showed, it can bring about great change. However, protest on its own is not enough. Racism is best fought by a combination of peaceful protest, good laws, education and the change of heart that religion seeks to bring about, so the statement is only partly true.
Explanation
A top answer uses King and Gandhi in detail, with the teachings behind their non-violence, and then evaluates alternatives: other methods such as law and education, and religious views that allow force as a last resort. Treat any discussion of force carefully and in terms of teaching and conditions. A judgement that distinguishes between the best method of protest and the best overall strategy shows strong evaluation.