"Tawalia and Tabarra are the most important of the Ten Obligatory Acts."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Many Shi'a Muslims would see real strength in this statement. Tawalia (love for the friends of Allah) and Tabarra (disapproval of evil-doers) express the belief in Imamah, one of the Usul ad-Din, which is at the heart of Shi'a Islam. The Qur'an asks believers for love for the Prophet's near relatives (Qur'an 42:23) and describes the People of the House as purified by Allah (Qur'an 33:33). The Prophet said he left behind two weighty things, the Qur'an and his family, and that whoever took him as mawla should take Ali as mawla. Shi'a narrations teach that love for the Ahl al-Bayt is a condition for good deeds to be accepted. Unlike Hajj, which may be done once, or khums, paid once a year, Tawalia and Tabarra are attitudes that shape every moment of a believer's life. Loving what is good and rejecting what is evil gives direction to all the other acts, so they could be seen as the root from which the others draw their meaning. Imam Husayn's refusal to support Yazid at Karbala shows Tabarra in action, and his example continues to inspire Shi'a Muslims to stand against injustice.
However, there are strong arguments against the statement. Salah is described in hadith, in both Sunni and Shi'a sources, as the pillar of religion and the first deed for which a person will be judged on the Day of Judgement. The Qur'an repeatedly and explicitly commands prayer, fasting, zakah and Hajj (for example Qur'an 2:43, 2:183, 3:97). All ten acts are obligatory, so many Shi'a scholars would say ranking them is unhelpful: a Shi'a Muslim who neglected prayer could not claim to be fulfilling Tawalia. In fact, Tawalia and Tabarra are mostly expressed through other acts, such as visiting shrines, attending majalis and practising Amr-bil-Maroof, and would be empty without them. Above all, worship of Allah alone, Tawhid, comes before love for any human being, however holy. Sunni Muslims also love the Prophet's family and include them in the blessings in every prayer, but they do not list these duties as pillars at all. There is also a concern that Tabarra, if misunderstood as insulting others, causes division in the ummah; for this reason many senior Shi'a scholars stress that it means rejecting evil and injustice, and they forbid insulting figures revered by Sunnis.
In conclusion, I think Tawalia and Tabarra are among the most important acts for Shi'a identity, because they express the belief in Imamah and give moral direction to the others. However, I do not think they are the most important overall, because salah is the pillar of religion and the first act to be judged, and because Tawalia and Tabarra depend on the other acts for their expression. It is best to see the ten acts as interconnected, with love of good and rejection of evil running through all of them.
Explanation
Level 5 answers explain why Tawalia and Tabarra are central to Shi'a belief (Imamah, 42:23, the hadith of the two weighty things) and weigh this against the importance of salah and the interdependence of the acts, including a Sunni perspective. Discuss Tabarra respectfully and accurately. Answers that simply argue that prayer is more important, without explaining Tawalia and Tabarra, cannot reach the higher levels.