"A merciful God would not punish anyone in Hell."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
There are strong reasons to agree with this statement. Islam places great emphasis on Allah's mercy: every surah but one begins by calling him al-Rahman and al-Rahim, the Most Gracious and the Most Merciful. The Qur'an says that his mercy encompasses all things (Qur'an 7:156), and a hadith qudsi teaches that Allah's mercy prevails over his anger. In another hadith, Muhammad pointed to a mother holding her baby and said that Allah is more merciful to his servants than she is to her child. A loving mother would never torment her child, so some argue that a merciful God would not punish people in Hell, especially if the punishment were out of all proportion to the wrongs done in a short human life. Many Muslims believe that sinful believers who enter Hell will eventually be taken out by Allah's mercy and the intercession of the Prophet, and Shi'a Muslims also believe in the intercession of the Imams, which shows that mercy limits punishment. Non-religious people, such as Humanists and atheists, argue that the idea of everlasting punishment is cruel and has been used to frighten people into obedience, and that a good God would not create such a place.
On the other hand, most Muslims would disagree with the statement, because Allah is also al-Adl, the Just. The Qur'an teaches that on the Day of Judgement whoever has done an atom's weight of good will see it, and whoever has done an atom's weight of evil will see it (Qur'an 99:7-8). If murderers, tyrants and oppressors were never held accountable, their victims would never receive justice, and the difference between good and evil would become meaningless. Hell (Jahannam) is described many times in the Qur'an, so both Sunni and Shi'a Muslims accept it as real. Shi'a Muslims, who make Adalat a root of religion, stress that a just God must reward and punish fairly.
Muslims would also argue that punishment in Hell does not contradict mercy, because Allah does not wrong anyone (Qur'an 4:40). He gives people free will, sends prophets to guide them and does not punish anyone until a messenger has reached them (Qur'an 17:15). His forgiveness is offered to everyone who repents, and the Qur'an tells people never to despair of his mercy (Qur'an 39:53). In this view, people who end up in Hell have chosen to reject the mercy that was always available to them. Allah's mercy is shown in the warning itself, since the Qur'an warns of Hell so that people can turn back in time.
In conclusion, I think the statement is too simple. From a non-religious point of view it may seem that mercy and punishment cannot go together, but in Islam mercy and justice are two sides of Allah's perfect nature. Muslims believe that Hell is real because justice matters, yet that Allah's mercy is wider than his anger, so no one who sincerely turns to him need despair. A God who ignored all evil would not be truly merciful to the victims of that evil.
Explanation
This statement asks you to weigh Allah's mercy against his justice, so the best answers use sources for both (Qur'an 7:156, 39:53 against 99:7-8, 4:40) and explain how Muslims reconcile them. Including beliefs about intercession, repentance and free will adds depth, and non-religious views make a useful counter-argument. Remember to reach your own justified conclusion.