"Angels are better than humans because they always obey Allah."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Some Muslims might agree with this statement. The Qur'an says that angels never disobey Allah in what he commands them, but do whatever they are commanded (Qur'an 66:6). They glorify Allah night and day without ever tiring (Qur'an 21:20), and they are described as his honoured servants (Qur'an 21:26). Angels are created from light, live close to Allah and carry out his will in revelation, in nature and at the Day of Judgement. Humans, by contrast, often sin and forget. The Qur'an says that humans were created weak (Qur'an 4:28), and even before Adam was created the angels asked whether Allah would place on earth one who would cause corruption and shed blood (Qur'an 2:30). Human history, from the murder of Adam's son onwards, seems to prove them right. Some theologians in the past did teach that angels are superior to humans.
However, many Muslims would disagree. Angels always obey because they have no free will; their obedience is perfect but it is not chosen. Humans have free will (Qur'an 18:29), so when they choose to obey Allah despite temptation from Shaytan, their good deeds are a real moral achievement. It can be argued that obedience freely chosen is more praiseworthy than obedience that could not be otherwise. The Qur'an also shows the high honour given to humans. Allah taught Adam the names of all things, knowledge the angels did not have (Qur'an 2:31-33), and commanded the angels to bow to him (Qur'an 2:34). Allah made humans his khalifah on earth (Qur'an 2:30) and declares that he has honoured the children of Adam (Qur'an 17:70). The Qur'an even says humans accepted the trust that the heavens, the earth and the mountains refused to bear (Qur'an 33:72).
Many Sunni and Shi'a scholars teach that the prophets, and for Shi'a Muslims the Imams, are higher in rank than the angels, and that righteous believers can rise above the angels because they struggle to do good. At the same time, humans who choose evil can fall lower than animals (Qur'an 7:179). This suggests that humans can be better or worse than angels depending on their choices. A Humanist would not believe in angels at all, but would agree that the ability to make free moral choices is what gives human life its value.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Angels are more perfectly obedient than humans, but being unable to disobey is not the same as being morally better. Islam teaches that humans were given a unique honour and responsibility, and a human who freely chooses to obey Allah can reach a rank even higher than the angels. Perhaps the best answer is that angels and humans each have their own honoured place in Allah's creation, and comparing them as 'better' or 'worse' misses the point that both exist to serve Allah.
Explanation
This statement tests understanding of angels and free will. Level 5 answers use Qur'anic evidence on both sides (66:6 and 2:30 against 2:31-34, 17:70 and 33:72) and evaluate whether obedience without choice is really 'better'. Mentioning scholarly views on the rank of prophets and angels shows depth.