"British Muslims should not spend thousands of pounds on Hajj when the money could help the poor."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
Hajj, the pilgrimage to Makkah, is the fifth pillar of Islam. For British Muslims a Hajj package can cost several thousand pounds per person, so some people ask whether that money would be better spent helping the poor.
There are arguments for the statement. Islam places enormous importance on helping those in need. The Qur'an describes righteousness as including giving wealth to relatives, orphans, the needy and travellers (2:177), and it compares charity to a seed that grows into seven ears of grain (2:261). The money spent on one person's Hajj could provide food, clean water or medical care for many people in poverty or after a disaster. The Qur'an makes Hajj a duty only for those who are able (3:97), and scholars teach that a Muslim must not go if it means neglecting their family or falling into debt. The Prophet himself performed Hajj only once, so some Muslims question wealthy people going again and again; some scholars teach that when there is urgent need, it is better to give the cost of an extra, voluntary pilgrimage to charity. A Humanist would argue that relieving human suffering does more good than any religious journey.
However, there are strong arguments against the statement. Hajj is not simply a holiday or an optional act of devotion; it is one of the Five Pillars, a duty that Allah places on every adult Muslim who can afford it (3:97). The Qur'an commands that people be called to the pilgrimage from every distant place (22:27). A Muslim cannot replace a duty from Allah with a different good deed, however worthy. In any case, a Muslim who can afford Hajj will already have paid zakah each year, so the poor are not forgotten, and Hajj itself involves giving, as the meat from the sacrifice is shared with the poor (22:37). The spiritual value of Hajj is immense: a hadith promises that a pilgrim who avoids wrongdoing returns home as free from sin as a newborn baby. Pilgrims follow in the footsteps of Ibrahim (2:125) and experience the equality and unity of the ummah, as Malcolm X described when he saw pilgrims of every colour treated as brothers. Many pilgrims return more humble, generous and committed to helping others.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement as far as the first, obligatory Hajj is concerned. It is a duty from Allah, it is only required of those who can afford it, and Islam already ensures that the poor are helped through zakah. However, I think the statement has some force when applied to repeated pilgrimages: where there is great need, giving the cost of a second or third Hajj to the poor may be the more loving choice. For most Muslims, the best approach is to fulfil the duty of Hajj while also giving generously throughout their lives.
Explanation
Top answers weigh the importance of charity in Islam against Hajj as a duty for those able (3:97), with sources on both sides, and often distinguish between the obligatory first Hajj and repeated pilgrimages. A non-religious view adds breadth. Avoid implying that Muslims who perform Hajj do not care about the poor.