"Ashura should be important for all Muslims, not just Shi'a Muslims."
Discuss this statement showing that you have considered more than one point of view. (You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.)
Model answer
There are strong arguments for this statement. Imam Husayn was the grandson of the Prophet Muhammad, and all Muslims love and honour him. The Prophet is reported to have said, 'Husayn is from me and I am from Husayn', and that Hasan and Husayn are the leaders of the youth of Paradise. Sunni Muslims bless the family of Muhammad in every prayer, and love for the Prophet's family is taught in the Qur'an (Qur'an 42:23). Sunni scholars throughout history have regarded the killing of Husayn at Karbala as a terrible tragedy and injustice. The lessons of Karbala are also universal: standing up to tyranny, speaking the truth whatever the cost and showing patience and courage in suffering are values for every Muslim, as the Prophet said that the best jihad is a word of truth before a tyrannical ruler. In fact, Ashura is already important to Sunni Muslims for another reason: the Prophet fasted on the tenth of Muharram, remembering the day Allah saved Musa from Pharaoh, and taught that this fast wipes out the sins of the previous year. In some places, such as parts of South Asia, Sunnis also take part in Muharram commemorations. Marking Ashura together could help unite the ummah, as the Qur'an commands believers not to be divided (Qur'an 3:103).
On the other hand, there are good reasons why Ashura cannot mean the same thing to all Muslims. For Shi'a Muslims, the commemoration is rooted in the belief that Husayn was the third Imam, appointed by Allah and free from sin, whose sacrifice preserved the true faith. Sunni Muslims do not share the belief in Imamah, so the day cannot carry the same religious meaning for them. Sunnis already mark Ashura in their own way, by fasting, which they see as following the Sunnah of the Prophet. Many Sunni scholars also disapprove of public mourning rituals such as matam, citing hadith against excessive displays of grief, and some, especially Salafis, regard certain practices as innovations. For Sunnis, Ashura is a day of voluntary fasting, not one of the main occasions, such as Ramadan and the two Ids, that all Muslims share. Insisting that everyone mark Ashura in the same way might even create tension, since the history of Karbala has sometimes divided the communities; respecting each tradition's approach may be better for unity.
In conclusion, I think Ashura already is important for all Muslims, but in different ways: for Sunnis as a day of fasting and remembrance of Musa, and for Shi'a as the day of Husayn's martyrdom. I agree that the lessons of Husayn's sacrifice, justice, courage and faithfulness, should be valued by every Muslim, because he was the Prophet's beloved grandson. However, the Shi'a form of commemoration naturally belongs to Shi'a belief in Imamah, so it is reasonable for Sunnis and Shi'a to mark the day differently while respecting each other.
Explanation
Level 5 answers show accurate knowledge of both Sunni and Shi'a ways of marking Ashura, explain the role of belief in Imamah and Sunni views on mourning practices, and use sources such as the hadith about Husayn and about fasting on Ashura, before reaching a balanced conclusion. Treat both traditions with respect and avoid suggesting either is less Muslim.