Question 1
40 marksA youth conference on the future of towns has invited young people to give speeches with the title 'The High Street of 2050'.
Write the text for a speech you will give at the conference describing the high street you would like to see in 2050.
In your speech, you could include:
- what high streets are like today and how people use them
- the shops, services and spaces you would like to see in 2050
- who the high street should be for and how to make it welcoming
as well as any other ideas you might have.
Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.
(24 marks for content and organisation, 16 marks for technical accuracy)
Model answer
Good afternoon, everyone. In 2050, I will be forty years old. I might have children of my own. And one Saturday morning, I would like to be able to say to them, 'Come on - let's go into town,' and have them be excited about it. That, really, is the whole of my speech. Everything else is detail.
But details matter, so let me start with the high street I know today. Picture it with me. A row of shops with their shutters down, some of them for so long that the 'To Let' signs have faded white. A phone repair shop, a vape shop, two charity shops and a bank that opens three days a week. A bench - one bench - next to a bin that is always overflowing. Cars crawling past, looking for somewhere to park. On a weekday afternoon, the busiest place on the whole street is the bus stop, because it is the quickest way out.
I don't say this to be cruel. The people who run those shops work incredibly hard. But we have to be honest with ourselves: the high street of our grandparents' day, a place you went to buy things, is not coming back. We buy things on our phones now, at midnight, in our pyjamas. If a high street exists only to sell, it will lose to the internet every single time.
So the question for 2050 is not 'How do we get people shopping again?' It is 'Why would anyone want to be there at all?'
My answer is that the high street of the future should be the town's living room: the place you go not because you need something, but because other people are there.
Imagine walking down it in 2050. The road has gone. In its place there are trees, wide pavements and children on scooters who don't need to be told to watch out for cars. The empty shops have been filled, but not only with shops. There is a repair cafe, where someone's grandad fixes toasters and teaches teenagers to do the same. There is a library that is also a workshop, with sewing machines and tools you can borrow by the hour. There is a covered market where local growers sell vegetables on Saturdays and young people sell their art and second-hand clothes on Sundays. Above the shops, in what are now empty storerooms, people live - students, older people, young families - so the street has lights in its windows in the evening and eyes on it at night.
And there are places to sit. That sounds like a small thing, but it isn't. Today, in too many town centres, you have to buy a coffee to earn the right to sit down. In 2050, I want benches, steps and squares that belong to everyone, because a town where you have to pay to rest is quietly telling some people that they are not welcome.
Which brings me to the most important question of all: who is the high street for? At the moment, young people are mostly treated as a problem to be moved on. We are told not to gather outside shops, not to sit on walls, not to make noise. But where else are we supposed to go? The high street of 2050 should have spaces designed with teenagers, not designed against them: a youth cafe, a music room, somewhere warm on a rainy evening that doesn't cost five pounds. And it should be just as welcoming to people at the other end of life, with toilets, shade, ramps and pedestrian crossings that give an eighty-year-old time to reach the other side without running.
Some of you will say that this is a dream. It is. But every high street that exists today was once somebody's plan, and the high streets of 2050 are being planned right now, in offices, by adults who will have retired by the time they are finished. We are the ones who will live in them. We should be in the room.
So here is my challenge to everyone at this conference. Don't just ask what our town centres should sell. Ask what they should feel like. And then let's go home and start building them, so that one Saturday morning in 2050, when we say, 'Come on - let's go into town,' our children will already be reaching for their coats.
Thank you.
Explanation
This reaches Level 5 because the vision is rooted in an argument - that a high street which exists only to sell will always lose to the internet - so the imagined details of 2050 are persuasive rather than decorative. Contrast between the present and the future, the extended image of the town's 'living room' and a frame that returns to the speaker's own future give the speech a clear, deliberate shape. Weaker answers list futuristic gadgets, describe only the present, or forget that they are addressing a conference.
Mark scheme
-
24 marks
Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). Communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively, selecting and adapting tone, style and register for different forms, purposes and audiences. Organise information and ideas, using structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion of texts.
Level 5 (20-24 marks): Sophisticated ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Shapes audience response with subtlety, with sophisticated and sustained use of tone, style and register. Manipulates complex ideas, utilising a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion.
Level 4 (15-19 marks): Secure ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Organises material for particular effect, with effective use of tone, style and register. Manages information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features used cohesively and deliberately across the text.
Level 3 (10-14 marks): Clear ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Selects material and stylistic or rhetorical devices to suit audience and purpose, with appropriate use of tone, style and register. Develops and connects appropriate information and ideas; structural and grammatical features and paragraphing make meaning clear.
Level 2 (5-9 marks): Some ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Shows an awareness of audience and purpose, with straightforward use of tone, style and register. Expresses and orders information and ideas; uses paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Limited ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Offers a basic response, with audience and/or purpose not fully established. Expresses information and ideas, with limited use of structural and grammatical features.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to write the text for a speech to inform and persuade: presenting a vision of the high street of the future and persuading the audience that it is worth working towards. Audience: the writing is for a youth conference: young people from different towns, perhaps with planners, councillors or other adults present. The register should be confident, imaginative and reasonably formal. The focus is on communicating ideas about the future of the high street and town centres. This can involve a range of approaches. Form: the response should be set out as a speech using organisational features. There should be clear organisation and structure with an introduction, development of points and a conclusion. Responses may: - describe high streets today: empty or boarded-up shops, charity shops, cafes, takeaways and banks, traffic and parking, online shopping, a lack of places to sit or for young people to go, but also the people who work hard there and what is still valued; - set out the speaker's vision for 2050: fewer cars, trees and green spaces, markets, independent shops, repair cafes, libraries and workshops, homes above shops, places for culture, sport and play, free seating and toilets, spaces for young people; - consider who the high street should be for (everyone: young people, older people, disabled people, families, people with little money) and how to make it welcoming and safe; - answer possible objections, for example cost, or that the vision is unrealistic; - use the conventions of a speech to a conference: a greeting, a hook, direct address, inclusive pronouns, signposting, imagined scenes ('Imagine ...'), rhetorical questions, contrast between present and future, and a call to action. Higher-level responses may make the vision vivid and specific while rooting it in a clear argument about what a high street is for; use contrast between today and 2050 to shape the audience's response; and give the speech a strong frame and call to action. Less successful responses may list futuristic gadgets (flying cars, robots) without argument; describe only the present; or forget the conference audience. Mark by best fit across the whole response.
-
16 marks
Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy). Candidates must use a range of vocabulary and sentence structures for clarity, purpose and effect, with accurate spelling and punctuation.
Level 5 (14-16 marks): Sophisticated ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses an extensive vocabulary strategically; rare spelling errors do not detract from overall meaning. Punctuates writing with accuracy to aid emphasis and precision, using a range of sentence structures accurately and selectively to achieve particular effects.
Level 4 (11-13 marks): Secure ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses a wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors. Positions a range of punctuation for clarity, managing sentence structures for deliberate effect.
Level 3 (8-10 marks): Sound ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses a varied vocabulary and spells words containing irregular patterns correctly. Uses accurate and varied punctuation, adapting sentence structure to contribute positively to purpose and effect.
Level 2 (5-7 marks): Some ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Writes with a range of correctly spelt vocabulary, e.g. words with regular patterns such as prefixes, suffixes, double consonants. Uses punctuation with control, creating a range of sentence structures, including coordination and subordination.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Limited ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses basic vocabulary, often misspelled. Uses punctuation with basic control, creating undeveloped, often repetitive, sentence structures.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Mark technical accuracy across the whole response, by best fit. Look for: sentences correctly demarcated (no comma splices or run-on sentences, even in a lively spoken style); a range of punctuation used accurately and for effect - question marks on rhetorical questions, commas after fronted adverbials and in lists, apostrophes for omission and possession, colons, semi-colons, dashes and brackets, and inverted commas for any words quoted or spoken; a range of sentence structures - simple, compound and complex, with coordination and subordination, and short sentences, questions and exclamations used selectively for effect; an extensive vocabulary used strategically and spelt correctly, including words with irregular patterns; Standard English and consistent control of tense. In a visionary speech, look for controlled long sentences that build up an imagined scene, accurate punctuation of lists and of questions, accurate apostrophes ('our grandparents' day', 'someone's grandad', 'doesn't'), and consistent tense as the speech moves between present and future. Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout; rare spelling errors do not prevent it, and ambitious vocabulary is credited even when occasionally misspelt. Frequent comma splices, missing paragraphs or uncontrolled tense shifts keep a response below Level 4 however ambitious its vocabulary. A response with nothing worth credit scores 0 on both points.