Question 1
15 marksRead Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.
Text 2
Four minutes under the snow
by Gareth Hartley (fictional, 2024)
This article was published in a national newspaper in 2024. The writer, a keen amateur skier, describes what happened on the last day of a skiing holiday in the Alps with three friends the winter before.
[1] The first thing I heard was a crack, a dull, dry snap like a branch breaking in a frozen wood. Above me, a line opened across the snow, as neat as a knife cut. For a second nothing happened. Then the whole hillside began to move.
[2] It was the last morning of our holiday. Thirty centimetres of fresh snow had fallen overnight. The marked runs were already churned up by the crowds, but from the chairlift we could see a smooth slope just beyond the boundary rope, untouched and glittering. 'One run,' said Matt. 'Then lunch.'
[3] We were not reckless, or so we told ourselves. All four of us wore avalanche transceivers and carried a probe and a shovel; Kit had made us practise with them on the first afternoon. At the lift, the warning board showed the avalanche risk as 'considerable': three on a scale of five. We read it. We went anyway.
[4] I was second to go. Twenty turns into the softest snow of my life, I heard the crack. I tried to ski off to the side, as every safety talk advises, but after three turns the snow took my legs and I was inside it, rolling over and over, with no idea which way was up. It was like falling down a staircase while the staircase fell with you.
[5] It stopped all at once. The snow that had poured like water set around me like concrete. I could not move my legs. I could not move my left arm. My right hand had ended up by my face, keeping a pocket of air in front of my mouth - the only sensible thing I did all day. It was dark, and so quiet that I could hear my heart. I remember thinking: what a stupid way to go.
[6] Above me, my friends were doing exactly what we had practised. They switched their transceivers to search and followed the signal, the numbers on the screen counting down the metres, then pushed their probes into the snow until one struck my shoulder, a metre down. Then they dug. Matt says it took four minutes. It felt like a second, and like a year.
[7] I had lost a ski and both poles, and I was shaking too hard to undo my boots. Otherwise I was fine. People often want this story to be an adventure, a thrilling escape. It was not. It was a mistake, made by four sensible adults who wanted fresh snow, and we were lucky: lucky that the slide was small, and lucky that Kit is the kind of friend who makes you practise.
[8] So here is my advice. If you want to ski beyond the markers, go with a qualified guide. Carry the kit and learn to use it before you need it. Read the warning board as if it had been written for you, because it was. Or do what I do now: stay on the piste and admire the untouched slopes from the chairlift. They will still be beautiful, and you will still be alive to see them.
Glossary: piste - a marked and prepared ski run; transceiver - a small radio that sends out a signal and can also search for one; probe - a long, thin folding pole pushed into snow to find a buried person
In this extract, the writer attempts to warn readers about the dangers of skiing away from the marked runs.
Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.
Support your views with detailed reference to the text.
Model answer
Hartley's warning is highly successful because it does not lecture from the start. Instead it makes the reader live through the danger first, so that the advice at the end feels earned.
The opening is a powerful hook. 'The first thing I heard was a crack' places us in the moment, and the simile 'like a branch breaking in a frozen wood' makes the start of an avalanche sound small and ordinary, which is exactly what makes it frightening: there is no warning roar. The image of a line opening 'as neat as a knife cut' is chillingly precise, and the short sentence 'For a second nothing happened.' creates a pause before the shock of 'Then the whole hillside began to move.'
The writer then cleverly goes back to show how ordinary the decision was. The fresh snow, the 'churned up' marked runs and the slope 'untouched and glittering' are exactly what would tempt any keen skier, and Matt's casual 'One run ... Then lunch.' shows how lightly the choice was made. This is effective because readers recognise themselves in it: the warning is aimed at sensible people, not daredevils. The honesty of 'We were not reckless, or so we told ourselves' and the blunt short sentences 'We read it. We went anyway.' are the turning point of the article. By admitting that the group ignored a warning board that said 'considerable', Hartley makes the mistake impossible to excuse, and so the warning becomes far more persuasive.
The description of the burial is the most successful part. The contrasting similes 'poured like water' and 'set around me like concrete' show the snow changing from something fluid to something that traps, and the repetition in 'I could not move my legs. I could not move my left arm.' conveys complete helplessness. Sensory details, 'dark, and so quiet that I could hear my heart', put the reader under the snow. The flat, almost humorous 'what a stupid way to go' is more chilling than dramatic language would be, because it shows that death could come from a silly decision.
Some readers might feel that the rescue weakens the warning, since the friends find Hartley in 'four minutes' and the writer is 'fine'. However, the writer turns this into part of the message: the rescue only worked because of practice and kit, and the antithesis 'It felt like a second, and like a year' shows that the terror was real. Hartley also rejects the idea of a 'thrilling escape' directly: 'It was not. It was a mistake'. The repetition of 'lucky' stresses chance rather than skill, so the reader cannot assume they would survive too.
Finally, the advice is clear and direct. The imperatives 'go with a qualified guide' and 'Carry the kit and learn to use it before you need it' are practical, and 'Read the warning board as if it had been written for you, because it was' addresses the reader personally. The last sentence, 'They will still be beautiful, and you will still be alive to see them', echoes the untouched slope of paragraph 2 and ends on a quiet but shocking reminder of what is at stake. Overall, the warning succeeds because it is honest, vivid and personal rather than preachy.
Explanation
Level 5 answers make a sustained judgement about how well the whole article warns readers, using methods as evidence: the sudden opening, the honest admission 'We read it. We went anyway.', the burial similes and the direct advice at the end. They may weigh up where the warning is weaker, such as the quick, successful rescue. Retelling the story, or spotting features without saying how they make the warning work, keeps an answer in the lower levels.
Mark scheme
-
15 marks
Levels of response (15 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual reference.
Level 5 (13-15 marks): Evaluation of ideas, events, themes or settings. There is a sustained and detached critical overview and judgement about the text. The selection of references is apt and discriminating and is persuasive in clarifying the points being made.
Level 4 (10-12 marks): Analysis of ideas, events, themes or settings. Well-informed and developed critical judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate, detailed and fully supports the points being made.
Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of ideas, events, themes or settings. Informed judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on ideas, events, themes or settings. Straightforward opinions with limited judgements are offered about the text. The selection of references is valid, but not developed.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Description of ideas, events, themes or settings. Limited assertions are offered about the text. The use of references is limited.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that evaluate how successfully the writer warns readers about the dangers of skiing away from the marked runs. References to writer's techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement of the text. Responses may include: - the opening places the reader in the moment ('The first thing I heard was a crack'); the simile 'like a branch breaking in a frozen wood' and 'as neat as a knife cut' make the start quiet and precise, so the danger seems sudden, and the short sentence 'For a second nothing happened.' before 'Then the whole hillside began to move.' creates shock: a strong hook for a warning; - the flashback in paragraph 2 shows how tempting and ordinary the choice was ('Thirty centimetres of fresh snow', 'untouched and glittering', Matt's 'One run'), so readers can recognise themselves and the warning feels relevant to them; - the honesty of paragraph 3 ('We were not reckless, or so we told ourselves'), the detail of the warning board ('considerable': three on a scale of five) and the short sentences 'We read it. We went anyway.' admit fault and show that carrying kit is not enough; - the experience of being caught: 'Twenty turns into the softest snow of my life' turns pleasure into danger, and the simile 'like falling down a staircase while the staircase fell with you' conveys complete loss of control; - the burial in paragraph 5 is the most powerful part of the warning: the contrasting similes 'poured like water' and 'set around me like concrete', the repetition of 'I could not move', the sensory detail 'so quiet that I could hear my heart' and the understated 'what a stupid way to go' frighten without melodrama; - the rescue shows why kit and practice matter ('They switched their transceivers to search', 'the numbers on the screen counting down the metres', 'one struck my shoulder, a metre down'), and the antithesis 'It felt like a second, and like a year' conveys terror; - some may judge the warning weaker because the writer survived, was 'fine' and was found in 'four minutes'; others that this honesty makes it more credible, since the writer insists 'It was not. It was a mistake' and repeats 'lucky'; - paragraph 7 rejects the adventure story readers might expect ('People often want this story to be an adventure, a thrilling escape') and stresses that 'four sensible adults' made the mistake, so no reader can think it only happens to the reckless; - the direct advice in paragraph 8 uses imperatives ('go with a qualified guide', 'Carry the kit and learn to use it before you need it') and direct address ('as if it had been written for you, because it was'); it does not forbid skiing off the piste, which may make it more persuasive to keen skiers; - the circular ending returns to the 'untouched slopes' seen from the chairlift, and the repetition of 'still' in the final sentence, 'you will still be alive to see them', leaves a memorable warning.