Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/9

Non-fiction: evaluating a text (Q6)

Practise 27 exam-style questions on Non-fiction: evaluating a text (Q6) for Edexcel GCSE English Language (Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 27 questions
  • 15 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

15 marks

Read Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.

Text 2

Four minutes under the snow
by Gareth Hartley (fictional, 2024)

This article was published in a national newspaper in 2024. The writer, a keen amateur skier, describes what happened on the last day of a skiing holiday in the Alps with three friends the winter before.

[1] The first thing I heard was a crack, a dull, dry snap like a branch breaking in a frozen wood. Above me, a line opened across the snow, as neat as a knife cut. For a second nothing happened. Then the whole hillside began to move.

[2] It was the last morning of our holiday. Thirty centimetres of fresh snow had fallen overnight. The marked runs were already churned up by the crowds, but from the chairlift we could see a smooth slope just beyond the boundary rope, untouched and glittering. 'One run,' said Matt. 'Then lunch.'

[3] We were not reckless, or so we told ourselves. All four of us wore avalanche transceivers and carried a probe and a shovel; Kit had made us practise with them on the first afternoon. At the lift, the warning board showed the avalanche risk as 'considerable': three on a scale of five. We read it. We went anyway.

[4] I was second to go. Twenty turns into the softest snow of my life, I heard the crack. I tried to ski off to the side, as every safety talk advises, but after three turns the snow took my legs and I was inside it, rolling over and over, with no idea which way was up. It was like falling down a staircase while the staircase fell with you.

[5] It stopped all at once. The snow that had poured like water set around me like concrete. I could not move my legs. I could not move my left arm. My right hand had ended up by my face, keeping a pocket of air in front of my mouth - the only sensible thing I did all day. It was dark, and so quiet that I could hear my heart. I remember thinking: what a stupid way to go.

[6] Above me, my friends were doing exactly what we had practised. They switched their transceivers to search and followed the signal, the numbers on the screen counting down the metres, then pushed their probes into the snow until one struck my shoulder, a metre down. Then they dug. Matt says it took four minutes. It felt like a second, and like a year.

[7] I had lost a ski and both poles, and I was shaking too hard to undo my boots. Otherwise I was fine. People often want this story to be an adventure, a thrilling escape. It was not. It was a mistake, made by four sensible adults who wanted fresh snow, and we were lucky: lucky that the slide was small, and lucky that Kit is the kind of friend who makes you practise.

[8] So here is my advice. If you want to ski beyond the markers, go with a qualified guide. Carry the kit and learn to use it before you need it. Read the warning board as if it had been written for you, because it was. Or do what I do now: stay on the piste and admire the untouched slopes from the chairlift. They will still be beautiful, and you will still be alive to see them.

Glossary: piste - a marked and prepared ski run; transceiver - a small radio that sends out a signal and can also search for one; probe - a long, thin folding pole pushed into snow to find a buried person

In this extract, the writer attempts to warn readers about the dangers of skiing away from the marked runs.

Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.

Support your views with detailed reference to the text.

Model answer

Hartley's warning is highly successful because it does not lecture from the start. Instead it makes the reader live through the danger first, so that the advice at the end feels earned.

The opening is a powerful hook. 'The first thing I heard was a crack' places us in the moment, and the simile 'like a branch breaking in a frozen wood' makes the start of an avalanche sound small and ordinary, which is exactly what makes it frightening: there is no warning roar. The image of a line opening 'as neat as a knife cut' is chillingly precise, and the short sentence 'For a second nothing happened.' creates a pause before the shock of 'Then the whole hillside began to move.'

The writer then cleverly goes back to show how ordinary the decision was. The fresh snow, the 'churned up' marked runs and the slope 'untouched and glittering' are exactly what would tempt any keen skier, and Matt's casual 'One run ... Then lunch.' shows how lightly the choice was made. This is effective because readers recognise themselves in it: the warning is aimed at sensible people, not daredevils. The honesty of 'We were not reckless, or so we told ourselves' and the blunt short sentences 'We read it. We went anyway.' are the turning point of the article. By admitting that the group ignored a warning board that said 'considerable', Hartley makes the mistake impossible to excuse, and so the warning becomes far more persuasive.

The description of the burial is the most successful part. The contrasting similes 'poured like water' and 'set around me like concrete' show the snow changing from something fluid to something that traps, and the repetition in 'I could not move my legs. I could not move my left arm.' conveys complete helplessness. Sensory details, 'dark, and so quiet that I could hear my heart', put the reader under the snow. The flat, almost humorous 'what a stupid way to go' is more chilling than dramatic language would be, because it shows that death could come from a silly decision.

Some readers might feel that the rescue weakens the warning, since the friends find Hartley in 'four minutes' and the writer is 'fine'. However, the writer turns this into part of the message: the rescue only worked because of practice and kit, and the antithesis 'It felt like a second, and like a year' shows that the terror was real. Hartley also rejects the idea of a 'thrilling escape' directly: 'It was not. It was a mistake'. The repetition of 'lucky' stresses chance rather than skill, so the reader cannot assume they would survive too.

Finally, the advice is clear and direct. The imperatives 'go with a qualified guide' and 'Carry the kit and learn to use it before you need it' are practical, and 'Read the warning board as if it had been written for you, because it was' addresses the reader personally. The last sentence, 'They will still be beautiful, and you will still be alive to see them', echoes the untouched slope of paragraph 2 and ends on a quiet but shocking reminder of what is at stake. Overall, the warning succeeds because it is honest, vivid and personal rather than preachy.

Explanation

Level 5 answers make a sustained judgement about how well the whole article warns readers, using methods as evidence: the sudden opening, the honest admission 'We read it. We went anyway.', the burial similes and the direct advice at the end. They may weigh up where the warning is weaker, such as the quick, successful rescue. Retelling the story, or spotting features without saying how they make the warning work, keeps an answer in the lower levels.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual reference.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): Evaluation of ideas, events, themes or settings. There is a sustained and detached critical overview and judgement about the text. The selection of references is apt and discriminating and is persuasive in clarifying the points being made.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Analysis of ideas, events, themes or settings. Well-informed and developed critical judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate, detailed and fully supports the points being made.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of ideas, events, themes or settings. Informed judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on ideas, events, themes or settings. Straightforward opinions with limited judgements are offered about the text. The selection of references is valid, but not developed.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Description of ideas, events, themes or settings. Limited assertions are offered about the text. The use of references is limited.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that evaluate how successfully the writer warns readers about the dangers of skiing away from the marked runs. References to writer's techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement of the text. Responses may include: - the opening places the reader in the moment ('The first thing I heard was a crack'); the simile 'like a branch breaking in a frozen wood' and 'as neat as a knife cut' make the start quiet and precise, so the danger seems sudden, and the short sentence 'For a second nothing happened.' before 'Then the whole hillside began to move.' creates shock: a strong hook for a warning; - the flashback in paragraph 2 shows how tempting and ordinary the choice was ('Thirty centimetres of fresh snow', 'untouched and glittering', Matt's 'One run'), so readers can recognise themselves and the warning feels relevant to them; - the honesty of paragraph 3 ('We were not reckless, or so we told ourselves'), the detail of the warning board ('considerable': three on a scale of five) and the short sentences 'We read it. We went anyway.' admit fault and show that carrying kit is not enough; - the experience of being caught: 'Twenty turns into the softest snow of my life' turns pleasure into danger, and the simile 'like falling down a staircase while the staircase fell with you' conveys complete loss of control; - the burial in paragraph 5 is the most powerful part of the warning: the contrasting similes 'poured like water' and 'set around me like concrete', the repetition of 'I could not move', the sensory detail 'so quiet that I could hear my heart' and the understated 'what a stupid way to go' frighten without melodrama; - the rescue shows why kit and practice matter ('They switched their transceivers to search', 'the numbers on the screen counting down the metres', 'one struck my shoulder, a metre down'), and the antithesis 'It felt like a second, and like a year' conveys terror; - some may judge the warning weaker because the writer survived, was 'fine' and was found in 'four minutes'; others that this honesty makes it more credible, since the writer insists 'It was not. It was a mistake' and repeats 'lucky'; - paragraph 7 rejects the adventure story readers might expect ('People often want this story to be an adventure, a thrilling escape') and stresses that 'four sensible adults' made the mistake, so no reader can think it only happens to the reckless; - the direct advice in paragraph 8 uses imperatives ('go with a qualified guide', 'Carry the kit and learn to use it before you need it') and direct address ('as if it had been written for you, because it was'); it does not forbid skiing off the piste, which may make it more persuasive to keen skiers; - the circular ending returns to the 'untouched slopes' seen from the chairlift, and the repetition of 'still' in the final sentence, 'you will still be alive to see them', leaves a memorable warning.

Question 2

15 marks

Read Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.

Text 2

Dear Fifteen-Year-Old Me
by Rosie Kendrick (fictional, 2024)

This is an open letter that Rosie Kendrick, a university student, wrote to herself at the age of fifteen. It was published in her university's student magazine in 2024.

[1] Dear fifteen-year-old me, I know exactly where you are as you read this, because it is where you always are at ten past eleven at night: under the duvet, thumb moving, the blue light of your phone on your face. You are not enjoying it. You just cannot stop.

[2] Every Sunday morning your phone sends you a little report: daily average, five hours and forty minutes, up twelve per cent on last week. You read it the way other people read a bad school report, and then you make a plan. You always make a plan.

[3] You have three apps to manage your time, which is funny when you think about it. One turns homework into a game of streaks, so that missing a single day feels like a disaster. One locks your other apps for twenty-five minutes at a time. One is a planner in which you colour-code your week: blue for revision, green for exercise and yellow for "reading for pleasure", which you have scheduled, I promise you, for Thursdays from seven to half past.

[4] And when the plan goes wrong, as it always does, you feel guilty. Not a little guilty: the heavy kind that sits on your chest. An afternoon lying on your bedroom floor, listening to the same album three times, counts in your head as an afternoon wasted. A Saturday at Gran's, shelling peas and talking about nothing much, gets no colour at all. You treat every hour like a coin you are terrified of spending wrongly.

[5] So here is what I have learned, five years and one university place later. Some of those hours really were wasted, and you know which ones. Scrolling at midnight was not rest. It left you more tired, and it was not even fun. Put the phone in the kitchen at night: that one rule did more for me than all three apps together.

[6] But the floor afternoons were not wasted. Lying there doing nothing was how you worked out what you actually thought: about the friend who had stopped speaking to you, about whether you even wanted to take sciences. The Saturdays were not wasted either. Gran is not here to shell peas with any more, and I would trade every colour-coded Thursday for one more of those afternoons.

[7] These days I rest on purpose. I walk to lectures without headphones. I read novels that are on nobody's reading list. On Sunday afternoons I sometimes lie on the grass outside my halls and watch the clouds for an hour, and I no longer tell myself that I should be doing something else. My marks have not fallen. If anything, they have gone up.

[8] You have exactly the same twenty-four hours as everyone else, and you are right that they matter. But using time well does not mean filling every minute of it. A day is not a timetable to be completed; it is somewhere to live. So go easy on yourself. Love from you, at twenty.

Glossary: halls - halls of residence, buildings where university students live

In this extract, the writer attempts to show that rest is not a waste of time.

Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.

Support your views with detailed reference to the text.

Model answer

Kendrick succeeds in showing that rest is not a waste of time, largely because she does not pretend that all free time is good. By separating real rest from mindless scrolling, she makes her argument balanced and believable.

The letter form is an inspired choice. Writing to 'Dear fifteen-year-old me' lets her be honest and affectionate at once, and readers, especially teenagers, are likely to recognise themselves in the younger self. The opening image, 'under the duvet, thumb moving, the blue light of your phone on your face', is precise and uncomfortable, and the short sentences 'You are not enjoying it. You just cannot stop.' show that this is not rest at all. This careful distinction is the foundation for everything that follows.

She then shows how the attempt to control time has gone too far. The weekly report, 'up twelve per cent on last week', is read like 'a bad school report', so time becomes something to be judged and failed. Her humour is particularly effective here: 'You have three apps to manage your time, which is funny when you think about it', and "reading for pleasure" is 'scheduled ... for Thursdays from seven to half past'. The absurdity makes the reader laugh while seeing that pleasure cannot be timetabled.

The emotional cost is made very clear. The guilt is 'the heavy kind that sits on your chest', and the simile 'like a coin you are terrified of spending wrongly' suggests that treating time as money turns every hour into a source of fear. By this point the reader feels sympathy for the younger self and is ready for the turn.

The turning point, 'So here is what I have learned', is persuasive precisely because it begins with a concession: 'Some of those hours really were wasted'. This honesty, and the practical advice to 'Put the phone in the kitchen at night', earn the reader's trust before the main claim: 'But the floor afternoons were not wasted.' Lying there 'doing nothing' becomes thinking time: it 'was how you worked out what you actually thought'. The most powerful moment is the reference to Gran: 'Gran is not here to shell peas with any more, and I would trade every colour-coded Thursday for one more of those afternoons.' The quiet sadness shows, more convincingly than any argument, that the time she once saw as wasted was some of the most valuable she had.

Kendrick supports her case with evidence from her present life: a list of restful habits, and the claim that 'My marks have not fallen. If anything, they have gone up.' A sceptical reader might say that this is one person's experience and proves little. However, the ending offers a memorable final image: 'A day is not a timetable to be completed; it is somewhere to live.' The gentle command 'So go easy on yourself' and the witty sign-off 'Love from you, at twenty' leave the reader with warmth rather than a lecture, which makes the message far more likely to be taken to heart.

Explanation

Level 5 answers judge how successfully the whole letter makes its case, using the writer's methods as evidence: the distinction between scrolling and real rest, the humour about apps and scheduled pleasure, the coin simile, the honest concession, the reference to Gran and the final metaphor of a day as 'somewhere to live'. Weaker answers summarise the letter or list techniques without a judgement; strong answers may also weigh how far one person's experience proves the point.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual reference.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): Evaluation of ideas, events, themes or settings. There is a sustained and detached critical overview and judgement about the text. The selection of references is apt and discriminating and is persuasive in clarifying the points being made.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Analysis of ideas, events, themes or settings. Well-informed and developed critical judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate, detailed and fully supports the points being made.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of ideas, events, themes or settings. Informed judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on ideas, events, themes or settings. Straightforward opinions with limited judgements are offered about the text. The selection of references is valid, but not developed.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Description of ideas, events, themes or settings. Limited assertions are offered about the text. The use of references is limited.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that evaluate how successfully the writer shows that rest is not a waste of time. References to writer's techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement of the text. Responses may include: - the open-letter form, addressed to 'Dear fifteen-year-old me', makes the argument intimate and gentle, and readers can identify with the younger self; - the opening image, 'under the duvet, thumb moving, the blue light of your phone on your face', and the short sentences 'You are not enjoying it. You just cannot stop.' separate mindless scrolling from real rest, which makes the later argument more convincing; - the precise figures of the weekly report ('daily average, five hours and forty minutes, up twelve per cent on last week') and the comparison with 'a bad school report' show how time has become something to be judged and failed; - humour and irony about productivity apps ('You have three apps to manage your time, which is funny when you think about it') and the "reading for pleasure" scheduled 'for Thursdays from seven to half past' show the absurdity of timetabling every hour; - the emotive description of guilt, 'the heavy kind that sits on your chest', and the simile 'like a coin you are terrified of spending wrongly' show the harm of treating time like money; - the turning point, 'So here is what I have learned', begins with an honest concession, 'Some of those hours really were wasted', and practical advice, 'Put the phone in the kitchen at night', which make the writer trustworthy; - the contrast 'But the floor afternoons were not wasted' and the repetition of 'not wasted' present rest as thinking time ('how you worked out what you actually thought'); - the reference to Gran, 'Gran is not here to shell peas with any more, and I would trade every colour-coded Thursday for one more of those afternoons', is the emotional climax and shows that the 'wasted' time was among the most valuable; - the writer's present life is offered as evidence: 'These days I rest on purpose', the list of restful habits, and 'My marks have not fallen. If anything, they have gone up.'; - the ending sums up the argument in a metaphor, 'A day is not a timetable to be completed; it is somewhere to live.', with the gentle command 'So go easy on yourself' and the witty sign-off 'Love from you, at twenty'; - some may judge that the case rests on one person's experience and on a claim about marks that cannot be checked, or that the line between rest and wasted time is left vague ('you know which ones'), but the balance and honesty of the letter can be seen as making it more persuasive.

Question 3

15 marks

Read Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.

Text 2

Same beach, different bucket
by Owen Garside (fictional, 2023)

This is an extract from a travel column in a national newspaper, written in 2023 by Owen Garside. He describes a week's holiday with his two children in the small seaside town on the east coast of England where he spent his summer holidays as a boy.

[1] For six summers in the 1990s, the first week of August meant the same things: the back seat of my grandparents' car, a cool box of egg sandwiches, and the moment, just past the old water tower, when someone shouted, 'I can see the sea!' It was usually me.

[2] This summer I drove the same road with my own children: Ruby, who is nine, and Sol, who is twelve and too old for everything. Nobody shouted. Sol had his headphones in. Ruby was watching a video of somebody else's holiday. When I pointed out the sea, glittering beyond the water tower, she looked up, said 'Nice', and looked down again.

[3] The town has changed, as towns do. The pier I remembered as endless is quite short, and its far end is fenced off after storm damage. The joke shop where I bought my first whoopee cushion is a nail bar now, and the cafe where my grandmother ordered a pot of tea and four iced buns is boarded up. I stood outside it for longer than I meant to.

[4] Then there is the cost. As a boy I was given a pound for the arcade and made it last all afternoon. Ruby spent ten pounds in twenty minutes on a claw machine that seemed to have been designed by someone who hates children. I did not dare add up what we spent on chips.

[5] On Tuesday it rained: proper seaside rain, sideways and endless. We ate our sandwiches in the car with the windows steamed up while the radio talked about sunshine somewhere else. Halfway through a soggy cheese roll I realised, with a jolt, that this is exactly what my grandparents used to do with me, and that I had completely forgotten it.

[6] And then, on Wednesday, the sun came out and something happened. Sol, who is too old for everything, spent three hours building a dam across a stream on the beach with a boy he had met that morning. Ruby found a crab under a rock, kept it in a bucket all afternoon, named it Kevin, and cried when it was time to put it back. Neither of them looked at a phone until teatime.

[7] Watching them, I understood something about my memories of this place. They are like an old postcard: bright, sunny, with the edges trimmed off. I don't remember what anything cost, because I never had to pay. I don't remember the rain, because someone else was worrying about it. The magic was never really in the town. It was in being a child there.

[8] On the drive home, Ruby asked whether we could come back next year. Then she fell asleep with sand between her toes and a shell in her fist. I didn't point out the sea as we passed the water tower. I didn't need to.

Glossary: claw machine - an arcade game in which players pay to steer a metal claw that tries to pick up a prize

In this extract, the writer attempts to show his mixed feelings about returning to the seaside town of his childhood.

Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.

Support your views with detailed reference to the text.

Model answer

Garside conveys his mixed feelings very successfully, largely because he sets nostalgia against disappointment with humour, and then resolves the tension in a final insight that feels earned rather than sentimental.

The opening paragraph is pure nostalgia. The list of remembered details, 'the back seat of my grandparents' car, a cool box of egg sandwiches', is specific and homely, and the direct speech 'I can see the sea!' recreates a child's excitement. The short, fond 'It was usually me.' makes the reader warm to him at once, which makes the deflation of paragraph 2 more effective. The blunt sentence 'Nobody shouted.' and the images of Sol with 'his headphones in' and Ruby 'watching a video of somebody else's holiday' are funny, but the irony carries a real sadness: Ruby is watching someone else's holiday instead of enjoying her own. Ruby's single word, 'Nice', before she 'looked down again', is a perfectly judged anticlimax.

The changes to the town are handled with restraint. 'The town has changed, as towns do' sounds resigned, and the contrast between 'The pier I remembered as endless' and 'quite short' shows how memory enlarges things. The list of losses, the joke shop that 'is a nail bar now' and his grandmother's cafe 'boarded up', moves from comedy to a sense of loss, and the understated 'I stood outside it for longer than I meant to' says more about his feelings than any description of sadness could. This is one of the most moving moments in the piece.

Other frustrations are turned into comedy, which keeps the tone balanced. The hyperbole of the claw machine 'designed by someone who hates children' and the admission 'I did not dare add up what we spent on chips' make the cost amusing rather than bitter. The rain paragraph is cleverer still: the irony of 'the radio talked about sunshine somewhere else' gives way to 'a jolt' of recognition that 'this is exactly what my grandparents used to do with me'. Here a disappointing day becomes a link between generations, which is the heart of his mixed feelings.

The turning point, 'And then, on Wednesday, the sun came out and something happened', is structured like the climax of a story. The echo of 'too old for everything' is now affectionately ironic as Sol spends 'three hours building a dam', and the comic, touching detail that Ruby 'named it Kevin' shows the children finding the same simple joys he once had. The simile 'like an old postcard: bright, sunny, with the edges trimmed off' and the parallel sentences beginning 'I don't remember' explain why his memories were so perfect: 'someone else was worrying about it'. The short statements that close paragraph 7, 'The magic was never really in the town. It was in being a child there.', resolve his feelings neatly.

Some readers may find this resolution a little tidy, and because the negatives are always softened by jokes, the balance tilts towards the positive. However, the circular ending, 'I didn't point out the sea as we passed the water tower. I didn't need to.', is so understated that it avoids sentimentality. Overall, the extract succeeds because it lets nostalgia and disappointment sit side by side.

Explanation

Level 5 needs a sustained, critical overview of how well the writer conveys mixed feelings across the whole extract, with apt quotations used as evidence: here the nostalgic opening, the comic anticlimax, the restrained sense of loss, the humour about cost, the turning point and the reflective, circular ending, with a judgement about the balance. Weaker answers simply list what has changed in the town or focus on only the positive or only the negative feelings.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual reference.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): Evaluation of ideas, events, themes or settings. There is a sustained and detached critical overview and judgement about the text. The selection of references is apt and discriminating and is persuasive in clarifying the points being made.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Analysis of ideas, events, themes or settings. Well-informed and developed critical judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate, detailed and fully supports the points being made.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of ideas, events, themes or settings. Informed judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on ideas, events, themes or settings. Straightforward opinions with limited judgements are offered about the text. The selection of references is valid, but not developed.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Description of ideas, events, themes or settings. Limited assertions are offered about the text. The use of references is limited.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that evaluate how successfully the writer shows his mixed feelings about returning to the seaside town of his childhood. References to writer's techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement of the text. Responses may include: - the opening is warmly nostalgic, with a list of specific, homely memories and the excitement of a child's shout in direct speech: 'the back seat of my grandparents' car, a cool box of egg sandwiches', 'I can see the sea!', 'It was usually me'; - the anticlimax of paragraph 2 is comic but sad, contrasting the past with children absorbed in screens: 'Nobody shouted.', 'Sol had his headphones in', 'watching a video of somebody else's holiday', 'said 'Nice', and looked down again'; - the changes to the town are told with resigned restraint, and the contrast shows how memory enlarges things: 'The town has changed, as towns do', 'The pier I remembered as endless is quite short'; - the list of losses moves from comedy to a sense of loss, and understatement conveys his sadness more powerfully than description: 'is a nail bar now', 'boarded up', 'I stood outside it for longer than I meant to'; - frustration at the cost is turned into comedy through hyperbole and wry admission, keeping the tone balanced: 'designed by someone who hates children', 'I did not dare add up what we spent on chips'; - the rain paragraph moves from irony to a moment of recognition that links the generations: 'the radio talked about sunshine somewhere else', 'with a jolt', 'this is exactly what my grandparents used to do with me'; - the turning point is structured like a story's climax, and the echo of 'too old for everything' becomes affectionately ironic as the children rediscover simple pleasures: 'And then, on Wednesday, the sun came out and something happened', 'three hours building a dam', 'named it Kevin', 'Neither of them looked at a phone until teatime'; - the reflective simile and parallel sentences explain why his memories seemed perfect: 'like an old postcard: bright, sunny, with the edges trimmed off', 'I don't remember the rain, because someone else was worrying about it'; - the short statements that end paragraph 7 resolve his mixed feelings: 'The magic was never really in the town. It was in being a child there.'; - the circular, understated ending returns to the water tower and the sea, suggesting the children now have memories of their own: 'I didn't point out the sea as we passed the water tower. I didn't need to.'; - a detached evaluation may note that the negatives are always softened by humour, so the feelings tilt towards the positive, or that some readers may find the resolution a little neat, though the restraint of the ending avoids sentimentality.

Question 4

15 marks

Read Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.

Text 2

After the ocean, the noise
by Hannah Cottam (fictional, 2022)

This extract is from a magazine article by a young woman who rowed alone across the Atlantic Ocean, from the Canary Islands to the Caribbean. She wrote it a few weeks after she arrived.

[1] For sixty-three days, my world was seven metres long. I rowed, I ate, I slept in two-hour scraps, and I talked to the seabirds because there was nobody else to talk to. Some days I saw nothing but grey water. A tracker showed my little dot crawling across a map, but for weeks the only voice I heard was my own.

[2] So nothing had prepared me for the noise. As I rowed the last mile towards the harbour, boats came out to meet me, sounding their horns, and music was thumping from somewhere on the quay. There were people on every wall and balcony, waving flags and phones. A drone hovered above my head like a huge, curious insect. I remember thinking that someone famous must be arriving at the same time as me.

[3] Nobody was. It was all for me. My mum and my brother were at the front of the crowd, and when I stepped onto the quay, my legs, which had forgotten how to stand on anything still, folded underneath me. I sat on the warm concrete and cried, and my mum cried, and somebody pushed a cold drink into my hand. It was the happiest minute of my life. I had no idea that thousands of people were already watching it.

[4] By the time I had showered and slept, a video of me collapsing on the quay had been watched more than two million times. My phone, silent for two months, would not stop buzzing. Most of the messages were lovely: children who had followed my dot across the ocean for a school project, a woman of eighty-four who said I had made her want to take up rowing. But scattered among them were the others.

[5] Strangers had opinions about my hair, my weight and my 'skinny arms'. One man wrote that I was 'reckless' and should have been 'stopped for my own good'. Another decided that a girl could only have done it with a man secretly helping. A headline called me 'Atlantic Annie', which is not my name, and three different interviewers asked whether I had a boyfriend waiting at home. Not one of them asked about the night a wave rolled my boat right over.

[6] I know how lucky I am to be complaining about this. Plenty of people would love two million views, and the attention raised a lot of money for the hospice that cared for my grandad. But it is a strange thing to be turned, in a single afternoon, from a person into a story that other people get to tell. Out there, the ocean never once cared what I looked like.

[7] Last week, back at home, I switched off my phone and walked down to the beach at dawn, when nobody was about. The sea was flat and pink and perfectly quiet. I sat on the sand and, for the first time since I landed, I felt like myself again. I will row another ocean one day, I think. But next time, I might arrive at night.

In this extract, the writer attempts to show the mixed feelings that sudden fame can bring.

Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.

Support your views with detailed reference to the text.

Model answer

The writer is highly successful in showing the mixed feelings that sudden fame brings, because the article moves carefully between joy, gratitude and unease without letting one feeling cancel out the others.

The extract's opening establishes the solitude that makes the fame so shocking. The metaphor 'my world was seven metres long' shrinks her life to the size of the boat, and the short, repetitive clauses 'I rowed, I ate, I slept in two-hour scraps' capture the bare routine of the crossing, while the 'little dot crawling across a map' subtly hints that people were already watching her.

Paragraph 2 turns on the short sentence 'So nothing had prepared me for the noise.' Details such as 'music was thumping' and 'people on every wall and balcony' convey the scale of the welcome, but the simile of the drone 'like a huge, curious insect' adds a faintly uncomfortable note: the attention is already intrusive. Her modest assumption that 'someone famous must be arriving' and the blunt reply 'Nobody was. It was all for me.' capture her astonishment.

The joy of arrival is movingly conveyed. The polysyndeton in 'I sat on the warm concrete and cried, and my mum cried, and somebody pushed a cold drink into my hand' makes the moment feel overwhelming, and she calls it 'the happiest minute of my life'. The next sentence, 'I had no idea that thousands of people were already watching it', is a clever structural shift: a private moment has become public property, and the reader senses something darker coming.

The writer is fair about the good side of fame: the 'children who had followed my dot across the ocean' and 'a woman of eighty-four' show that her journey inspired people. However, the short sentence 'But scattered among them were the others' turns the article, and paragraph 5 is its most powerful. Comments on 'my hair, my weight' and her 'skinny arms' judge her body rather than her achievement, the quoted words 'reckless' and 'stopped for my own good' are patronising, and the claim that 'a girl could only have done it with a man secretly helping' is open sexism. The nickname 'Atlantic Annie', 'which is not my name', shows her identity being taken over, and the paragraph's final sentence, about 'the night a wave rolled my boat right over', reminds the reader of the real danger that the interviewers ignored.

Paragraph 6 stops the article sounding self-pitying. 'I know how lucky I am' and the money raised for 'the hospice that cared for my grandad' show genuine gratitude, but the 'But' that follows introduces her central insight: being turned 'from a person into a story that other people get to tell'. The personification in 'the ocean never once cared what I looked like' suggests, ironically, that the sea was kinder than people.

The extract's ending returns to solitude, with the calm 'flat and pink and perfectly quiet' echoing the opening, and this circular structure shows her recovering: 'I felt like myself again'. The humorous final line, 'next time, I might arrive at night', sums up the mixed feelings perfectly, as she still loves the adventure but would happily avoid the fame. The negative feelings perhaps take up more space than the positive ones, but that imbalance feels honest and makes the article convincing.

Explanation

Top answers judge how successfully the article balances joy, gratitude and unease, tracking how the structure moves from solitude to celebration to intrusive attention and back to quiet, and support the judgement with precise quotations rather than a list of techniques. A common error is to discuss only the hostile comments in paragraph 5 and miss the mixed feelings that the question asks about.

Mark scheme
  1. 15 marks

    Levels of response (15 marks). AO4: Evaluate texts critically and support this with appropriate textual reference.
    Level 5 (13-15 marks): Evaluation of ideas, events, themes or settings. There is a sustained and detached critical overview and judgement about the text. The selection of references is apt and discriminating and is persuasive in clarifying the points being made.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Analysis of ideas, events, themes or settings. Well-informed and developed critical judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate, detailed and fully supports the points being made.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of ideas, events, themes or settings. Informed judgement is offered about the text. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on ideas, events, themes or settings. Straightforward opinions with limited judgements are offered about the text. The selection of references is valid, but not developed.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Description of ideas, events, themes or settings. Limited assertions are offered about the text. The use of references is limited.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that evaluate how successfully the writer shows the mixed feelings that sudden fame can bring. References to writer's techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement of the text.
    Responses may include:
    - the opening's metaphor 'my world was seven metres long', the list of short, repetitive clauses 'I rowed, I ate, I slept in two-hour scraps' and 'the only voice I heard was my own' establish solitude, which makes the noise that follows more shocking; the 'little dot crawling across a map' hints that she was already being watched
    - 'So nothing had prepared me for the noise.' is a clear turning point, and sensory details ('sounding their horns', 'music was thumping', 'people on every wall and balcony') show the scale of the welcome
    - the simile of the drone 'like a huge, curious insect' introduces unease about being watched
    - humour and modesty: 'someone famous must be arriving at the same time as me' and the short reply 'Nobody was. It was all for me.'
    - the joy of arrival through the polysyndeton 'I sat on the warm concrete and cried, and my mum cried, and somebody pushed a cold drink into my hand' and the superlative 'the happiest minute of my life'
    - the structural shift 'I had no idea that thousands of people were already watching it' foreshadows her loss of privacy
    - the good side of fame is shown fairly ('children who had followed my dot across the ocean for a school project', 'a woman of eighty-four'), but the short sentence 'But scattered among them were the others' turns the article
    - paragraph 5's comments on 'my hair, my weight' and her 'skinny arms', the quoted insults ('reckless', 'stopped for my own good'), the sexism of 'a girl could only have done it with a man secretly helping', the nickname 'Atlantic Annie', 'which is not my name', and the 'boyfriend' question show fame reducing her to her looks and gender
    - the last sentence of paragraph 5, 'Not one of them asked about the night a wave rolled my boat right over', contrasts trivial attention with the real danger she faced
    - paragraph 6 balances gratitude ('I know how lucky I am', the money for 'the hospice that cared for my grandad') with her central insight, being turned 'from a person into a story that other people get to tell'
    - personification: 'the ocean never once cared what I looked like' suggests, ironically, that the sea was kinder than people
    - the circular ending returns to solitude ('flat and pink and perfectly quiet', 'I felt like myself again'), and the humorous last line 'next time, I might arrive at night' sums up the mixed feelings: love of the adventure, dislike of the fame
    - possible reservations: the negative feelings may seem to outweigh the positive; the good messages are summarised briefly; some readers may find the complaints ungrateful, although paragraph 6 anticipates this. Such views must be explained and supported

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.