Question 1
40 marksA family website has asked its readers to review places where parents and children can get close to animals and wildlife, to help other families plan trips in the school holidays.
Write a review of a wildlife park, aquarium or nature reserve you have visited, for the website.
In your review, you could include:
- the animals or wildlife you saw, and how well they seemed to be cared for or protected
- what it offers families with children of different ages
- whether the visit is good value and what could be improved
as well as any other ideas you might have.
Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.
(24 marks for content and organisation, 16 marks for technical accuracy)
Model answer
Otterholt Marsh Nature Reserve: Wild, Wet and Wonderful
Entry: free, but parking costs 5 pounds a car. Pond dipping: 3 pounds a child. Our rating: four out of five.
'There aren't even any lions,' my seven-year-old brother complained as we pulled into the car park at Otterholt Marsh. By the end of the afternoon, he had caught a newt, watched a heron swallow a fish whole and spent twenty silent minutes - a personal record - waiting for a kingfisher. Otterholt is not a zoo or a safari park; nothing here is in a cage, and nothing is guaranteed. That is exactly what makes it special, but it also means that it will not suit every family.
What you will see
The reserve is a patchwork of reed beds, meadows and shallow lakes, linked by a boardwalk and a network of gravel paths. Wooden hides overlook the water, and each one has a chart on the wall so that you can identify what you are looking at. On our visit in August, the air above the reeds was thick with dragonflies, some as long as my finger and as bright as jewels. We saw swans, herons and a whole fleet of ducks, and from the largest hide a volunteer helped us to spot a marsh harrier gliding low over the reeds. The kingfisher, when it finally appeared, was gone almost before we had seen it: a blue streak low over the water, perhaps two seconds long. My brother talked about it for a week.
Looked after with care
What impressed my mum most was how clearly the reserve puts its wildlife first. Signs explain why dogs are not allowed (some birds nest on the ground here) and why certain paths close in spring. Sections of reed are cut back in turn to create different habitats, and the information boards explain all of this in a way that children can follow. The volunteers we met were knowledgeable and patient, and not one of them seemed to mind being asked the same question three times.
For families
The highlight for younger children is the pond-dipping platform, where, for 3 pounds, they are given a net, a tray and a guide sheet. My brother caught water boatmen, a dragonfly nymph that looked like a tiny alien and, to his enormous delight, a newt, which a volunteer showed us how to return safely to the water. There is also a nature trail with wooden carvings to find, a small play area by the visitor centre and plenty of space to run about on the meadow paths. The main trail is flat and suitable for pushchairs and wheelchairs, although the paths to the furthest hides are rougher.
What could be better
Wildlife does not perform on demand, and children who expect constant excitement may find the hides frustrating, so take binoculars, snacks and a great deal of patience. The cafe is tiny and expensive: four drinks and two slices of cake came to almost 15 pounds, which makes a picnic a sensible idea. The only toilets are at the visitor centre, a long walk from the far end of the reserve, which led to one minor family emergency. Older teenagers who are not interested in birds or photography may find little to do beyond walking. Finally, wear insect repellent in summer; the midges by the water are merciless.
The verdict
Otterholt Marsh is a peaceful, beautifully managed reserve that rewards families who are willing to slow down. It is ideal for curious children aged about five to twelve, and it is excellent value: apart from the cafe, our whole day cost us only the parking and the pond dipping. If your children need rides and roaring animals, go elsewhere. If they can cope with a little waiting, they might just come home, like my brother, with a new favourite animal - and it will not be a lion.
Explanation
This reaches Level 5 for AO5 because every section is shaped for parents: the brother's complaint about lions frames the review and returns in the final line, care for wildlife is shown through specific details, and the criticisms (the cafe, the toilets, the waiting) become practical advice about which families the reserve suits. For AO6, vocabulary is precise and varied ('a patchwork of reed beds', 'merciless'), sentences range from long, detailed descriptions to short punchlines, and dashes, brackets, colons and quoted speech are accurate. A common weakness is a list of animals seen with no judgement of value, care or suitability.
Mark scheme
-
24 marks
Levels of response (24 marks). AO5 (content and organisation). Communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively, selecting and adapting tone, style and register for different forms, purposes and audiences. Organise information and ideas, using structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion of texts.
Level 5 (20-24 marks): Sophisticated ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Shapes audience response with subtlety, with sophisticated and sustained use of tone, style and register. Manipulates complex ideas, utilising a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion.
Level 4 (15-19 marks): Secure ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Organises material for particular effect, with effective use of tone, style and register. Manages information and ideas, with structural and grammatical features used cohesively and deliberately across the text.
Level 3 (10-14 marks): Clear ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Selects material and stylistic or rhetorical devices to suit audience and purpose, with appropriate use of tone, style and register. Develops and connects appropriate information and ideas; structural and grammatical features and paragraphing make meaning clear.
Level 2 (5-9 marks): Some ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Shows an awareness of audience and purpose, with straightforward use of tone, style and register. Expresses and orders information and ideas; uses paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Limited ability to communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively. Offers a basic response, with audience and/or purpose not fully established. Expresses information and ideas, with limited use of structural and grammatical features.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to write a review of a wildlife park, aquarium or nature reserve, to inform and/or persuade: families should finish knowing what a visit offers and whether it would suit them. Audience: the writing is for parents and carers reading a family website, who want an honest, practical judgement and will think about children of different ages. The focus is on communicating ideas when reviewing a place to see animals and wildlife. This can involve a range of approaches. Form: the response should be set out as a review using organisational features, such as a title, key details (prices, opening, facilities), subheadings and a clear verdict or rating. There should be clear organisation and structure with an introduction, development of points and a conclusion. Responses may: - describe the animals or wildlife seen, with vivid detail and a sense of what it is like to be there, for example a sighting, a feeding time, a tank or a hide; - comment on how well the animals are cared for or protected, for example the size and quality of enclosures or habitats, conservation work, rules that protect wildlife, information that helps visitors understand; - judge what the place offers families: activities for young children, older children and teenagers, accessibility for pushchairs and wheelchairs, toilets, food, play areas, staff and volunteers; - weigh value for money (entry and extra costs, food, parking) and suggest improvements, reaching a clear recommendation for particular kinds of family. Stronger responses write directly to parents, judge the place from the point of view of different children, and balance enthusiasm with fair criticism; they may raise questions about animal welfare thoughtfully without turning the review into an argument about zoos. Pearson's examiners' report on the November 2023 review task noted that stronger responses evaluated positive and negative aspects and advised readers on what to expect, while less successful responses were brief and purely descriptive. Less successful responses list the animals seen, or narrate the family's day, with little evaluation or advice. Mark by best fit across the whole response.
-
16 marks
Levels of response (16 marks). AO6 (technical accuracy). Candidates must use a range of vocabulary and sentence structures for clarity, purpose and effect, with accurate spelling and punctuation.
Level 5 (14-16 marks): Sophisticated ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses an extensive vocabulary strategically; rare spelling errors do not detract from overall meaning. Punctuates writing with accuracy to aid emphasis and precision, using a range of sentence structures accurately and selectively to achieve particular effects.
Level 4 (11-13 marks): Secure ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses a wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors. Positions a range of punctuation for clarity, managing sentence structures for deliberate effect.
Level 3 (8-10 marks): Sound ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses a varied vocabulary and spells words containing irregular patterns correctly. Uses accurate and varied punctuation, adapting sentence structure to contribute positively to purpose and effect.
Level 2 (5-7 marks): Some ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Writes with a range of correctly spelt vocabulary, e.g. words with regular patterns such as prefixes, suffixes, double consonants. Uses punctuation with control, creating a range of sentence structures, including coordination and subordination.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): Limited ability to write for clarity, purpose and effect. Uses basic vocabulary, often misspelled. Uses punctuation with basic control, creating undeveloped, often repetitive, sentence structures.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Mark this point for technical accuracy only, by best fit across the whole response. Look for: secure sentence demarcation, with no comma splices or run-on sentences; a range of punctuation used accurately and for effect, such as semi-colons, colons, dashes, brackets, question marks and exclamation marks, and apostrophes for possession and omission; a variety of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex, with short sentences, fragments or one-sentence paragraphs placed deliberately) chosen for clarity and effect; an extensive vocabulary used precisely and strategically, with ambitious words spelt correctly; accurate agreement and consistent control of tense; and Standard English in a register that suits the form and the audience. Prices, ages and other details should be expressed clearly and consistently, and quoted speech, if used, should be punctuated accurately. Pearson's June 2025 examiners' report lists the common errors in Section B as comma splicing, missing apostrophes, missing capital letters at the start of sentences, random capital letters and homophones (weather/whether, your/you're and there/their in particular), and notes that the strongest responses use a variety of sentence types and punctuation for effect. Frequent errors in sentence demarcation or basic spelling are not consistent with Level 4 ('Positions a range of punctuation for clarity') or Level 5 ('Punctuates writing with accuracy'), however ambitious the vocabulary; rare slips do not prevent Level 5. A response with nothing worth credit scores 0 on both points.