Question 1
14 marksRead Text 1 and Text 2 below. Then answer the question that follows.
Text 1
The Spell of the Rockies
by Enos A. Mills (1911)
This edited extract is taken from The Spell of the Rockies by Enos Mills, an American naturalist and mountain guide, published in 1911. One March, Mills went alone into the San Juan Mountains of Colorado to study snow slides (avalanches). After a night trapped by cloud on a high summit, he was coming down a steep, snow-covered slope on skis when the snow far above him began to move.
[1] A general slide had started. I whirled to escape, pointed my skees down the slope,--and went. In less than half a minute a tremendous snow avalanche, one hundred or perhaps two hundred feet deep and five or six hundred feet long, thundered over the spot where I had stood.
[2] There was no chance to dodge, no time to climb out of the way. The only hope of escape lay in outrunning the magnificent monster. It came crashing and thundering after me as swift as a gale and more all-sweeping and destructive than an earthquake tidal wave.
[3] I made a desperate start. Friction almost ceases to be a factor with skees on a snowy steep, and in less than a hundred yards I was going like the wind. For the first quarter of a mile, to the upper end of the gulch, was smooth coasting, and down this I shot, with the avalanche, comet-tailed with snow-dust, in close pursuit. A race for life was on.
[...]
[4] It was a second of most intense concern as I cleared the ridge blindly to go into what lay below and beyond. It was like leaping into the dark, and with the leap turning on the all-revealing light. As I cleared the ridge, there was just time to pull myself together for a forty-odd-foot leap across one arm of the horseshoe-shaped end of the gorge. In all my wild mountainside coasts on skees, never have I sped as swiftly as when I made this mad flight. As I shot through the air, I had a glimpse down into the pointed, snow-laden tops of a few tall fir trees that were firmly rooted among the rocks in the bottom of the gorge. Luckily I cleared the gorge and landed in a good place; but so narrowly did I miss the corner of a cliff that my shadow collided with it.
[...]
[5] At the bottom of the moraine I was forced between two trees that stood close together, and a broken limb of one pierced my open coat just beneath the left armhole, and slit the coat to the bottom. My momentum and the resistance of the strong material gave me such a shock that I was flung off my balance, and my left skee smashed against a tree. Two feet of the heel was broken off and the remainder split. I managed to avoid falling, but had to check my speed with my staff for fear of a worse accident.
[6] Battling breakers with a broken oar or racing with a broken skee are struggles of short duration. The slide did not slow down, and so closely did it crowd me that, through the crashing of trees as it struck them down, I could hear the rocks and splintered timbers in its mass grinding together and thudding against obstructions over which it swept. These sounds, and flying, broken limbs cried to me "Faster!" and as I started to descend another steep moraine, I threw away my staff and "let go." I simply flashed down the slope, dodged and rounded a cliff, turned awkwardly into Aspen Gulch, and tumbled heels over head--into safety.
[7] Then I picked myself up, to see the slide go by within twenty feet, with great broken trees sticking out of its side, and a snow-cloud dragging above.
Glossary: skees - skis; gulch - a narrow, steep-sided valley; gorge - a deep, narrow valley with steep rocky sides; moraine - a ridge of rocks and earth left behind by a glacier; staff - a long pole used to help with balance
Text 2
Four minutes under the snow
by Gareth Hartley (fictional, 2024)
This article was published in a national newspaper in 2024. The writer, a keen amateur skier, describes what happened on the last day of a skiing holiday in the Alps with three friends the winter before.
[1] The first thing I heard was a crack, a dull, dry snap like a branch breaking in a frozen wood. Above me, a line opened across the snow, as neat as a knife cut. For a second nothing happened. Then the whole hillside began to move.
[2] It was the last morning of our holiday. Thirty centimetres of fresh snow had fallen overnight. The marked runs were already churned up by the crowds, but from the chairlift we could see a smooth slope just beyond the boundary rope, untouched and glittering. 'One run,' said Matt. 'Then lunch.'
[3] We were not reckless, or so we told ourselves. All four of us wore avalanche transceivers and carried a probe and a shovel; Kit had made us practise with them on the first afternoon. At the lift, the warning board showed the avalanche risk as 'considerable': three on a scale of five. We read it. We went anyway.
[4] I was second to go. Twenty turns into the softest snow of my life, I heard the crack. I tried to ski off to the side, as every safety talk advises, but after three turns the snow took my legs and I was inside it, rolling over and over, with no idea which way was up. It was like falling down a staircase while the staircase fell with you.
[5] It stopped all at once. The snow that had poured like water set around me like concrete. I could not move my legs. I could not move my left arm. My right hand had ended up by my face, keeping a pocket of air in front of my mouth - the only sensible thing I did all day. It was dark, and so quiet that I could hear my heart. I remember thinking: what a stupid way to go.
[6] Above me, my friends were doing exactly what we had practised. They switched their transceivers to search and followed the signal, the numbers on the screen counting down the metres, then pushed their probes into the snow until one struck my shoulder, a metre down. Then they dug. Matt says it took four minutes. It felt like a second, and like a year.
[7] I had lost a ski and both poles, and I was shaking too hard to undo my boots. Otherwise I was fine. People often want this story to be an adventure, a thrilling escape. It was not. It was a mistake, made by four sensible adults who wanted fresh snow, and we were lucky: lucky that the slide was small, and lucky that Kit is the kind of friend who makes you practise.
[8] So here is my advice. If you want to ski beyond the markers, go with a qualified guide. Carry the kit and learn to use it before you need it. Read the warning board as if it had been written for you, because it was. Or do what I do now: stay on the piste and admire the untouched slopes from the chairlift. They will still be beautiful, and you will still be alive to see them.
Glossary: piste - a marked and prepared ski run; transceiver - a small radio that sends out a signal and can also search for one; probe - a long, thin folding pole pushed into snow to find a buried person
Compare how the writers of Text 1 and Text 2 present ideas and perspectives about danger in the mountains.
You should write about:
- the ideas and perspectives
- how they are presented
- how they are similar/different.
Support your answer with detailed references to the texts.
Model answer
Both writers describe trying to escape an avalanche on skis, but their perspectives on that danger are almost opposite. Mills, in a book published in 1911, presents it as a thrilling contest that tested his skill, while Hartley, writing in 2024, presents it as a mistake that should never have happened.
Both texts open in the middle of the danger, but in different ways. The extract from Mills begins with action, 'A general slide had started. I whirled to escape', plunging the reader straight into the chase. Hartley begins with a sound, 'a crack, a dull, dry snap', and the quiet image 'as neat as a knife cut', so the danger creeps up on us. Mills then keeps moving forward through the race, whereas Hartley stops and goes back to explain how the friends chose to take the risk, which suits an article whose purpose is to warn.
Their attitudes to the avalanche are strikingly different. Mills's metaphor 'the magnificent monster' shows awe and even admiration, and he boasts that 'never have I sped as swiftly as when I made this mad flight'. Hartley sees nothing magnificent: the snow 'set around me like concrete', and the repeated 'I could not move my legs. I could not move my left arm.' stresses helplessness. Mills's danger is something he races and beats; Hartley's is something that simply swallows the writer.
This links to a key difference in how each survives. Mills escapes alone through his own speed and decisions: 'I threw away my staff and "let go."' and 'I simply flashed down the slope, dodged and rounded a cliff'. Although he admits 'Luckily I cleared the gorge', the credit is mainly his. Hartley is rescued by others using modern kit, 'They switched their transceivers to search and followed the signal', and insists that 'we were lucky', repeating 'lucky' to show that survival was chance, not skill.
Both writers convey the speed and confusion of the moment through sentence structure. Mills's long, breathless list of verbs in paragraph 6 ends with the dash in 'tumbled heels over head--into safety', while Hartley's 'rolling over and over, with no idea which way was up' and the simile 'like falling down a staircase while the staircase fell with you' show a total loss of control. Both also play with time: Mills's 'a second of most intense concern' and Hartley's 'It felt like a second, and like a year'.
Their purposes shape their endings. Mills ends as a spectator: 'a snow-cloud dragging above'. The danger becomes an awe-inspiring sight for the reader to enjoy. Hartley ends with direct advice to the reader, using imperatives such as 'go with a qualified guide' and the warning that 'you will still be alive to see them'. Interestingly, Hartley almost answers Mills directly: 'People often want this story to be an adventure, a thrilling escape. It was not.' That is exactly the kind of story Mills tells.
The writers' situations also explain their perspectives. Mills is an expert who calmly generalises, 'Friction almost ceases to be a factor with skees on a snowy steep', whereas Hartley is a holiday skier who 'read' the warning board and 'went anyway' and now feels regret. Overall, Mills celebrates danger as adventure, while Hartley exposes it as a risk that ordinary people should respect.
Explanation
Level 5 answers compare throughout, balancing both texts: Mills's exhilaration against Hartley's regret, skill against luck and kit, the 'magnificent monster' against snow 'like concrete', and a spectacular ending against direct advice. Each comparison links what the writers think to how they present it. Writing about one text and then the other, or listing content without analysing methods, keeps an answer below the top levels; considering only one text in detail caps it at 5.
Mark scheme
-
14 marks
Levels of response (14 marks). AO3: Compare writers' ideas and perspectives, as well as how these are conveyed, across two or more texts.
Level 5 (12-14 marks): The response considers a varied and comprehensive range of comparisons between the texts. Analysis of writers' ideas and perspectives including how the theme, language and/or structure are used across the texts. References are balanced across both texts, they are discriminating, and clarify the points being made.
Level 4 (9-11 marks): The response considers a wide range of comparisons between the texts. Exploration of writers' ideas and perspectives including how the theme, language and/or structure are used across the texts. References are balanced across both texts and fully support the points being made.
Level 3 (6-8 marks): The response considers a range of comparisons between the texts. Explanation of writers' ideas and perspectives including theme, language and/or structure. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
Level 2 (3-5 marks): The response considers obvious comparisons between the texts. Comment on writers' ideas and perspectives, including theme, language and/or structure. The selection of references is valid, but not developed. NB: The mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE text has been considered in detail.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): The response does not compare the texts. Description of writers' ideas and perspectives, including theme, language and/or structure. The use of references is limited.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Max 5 if only one text has been considered in detail (Pearson: the mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE text has been considered in detail; responses that are unbalanced will not be able to access Level 3 or above). Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that compare how each writer presents ideas and perspectives about danger in the mountains. Responses may include: - both writers describe skiing for their lives as an avalanche comes down a slope, but Mills presents it as an exhilarating contest ('A race for life was on.', 'this mad flight') and Hartley as a regrettable mistake ('It was not. It was a mistake'); - the avalanche: Mills personifies it as a pursuing beast, 'the magnificent monster' that 'came crashing and thundering after me', which shows awe; Hartley presents it as a substance that changes from 'poured like water' to 'set around me like concrete', which shows helplessness; - survival: Mills escapes alone through skill and speed ('I simply flashed down the slope, dodged and rounded a cliff'), although 'Luckily I cleared the gorge'; Hartley is saved by friends and modern kit ('They switched their transceivers to search') and stresses luck ('lucky that the slide was small'); - openings: both printed texts begin at the moment the slide starts, the extract from Mills with action ('A general slide had started.') and Hartley's article with a quiet sound ('a crack, a dull, dry snap like a branch breaking in a frozen wood'); Mills tells his story in strict order, while Hartley uses a flashback to the decision ('It was the last morning of our holiday'); - responsibility: Mills had gone into the mountains to study snow slides (introduction) and expresses no regret; Hartley admits ignoring a warning ('We read it. We went anyway.'); - how pace and loss of control are conveyed: Mills's long list of verbs and the dash in 'tumbled heels over head--into safety'; Hartley's 'rolling over and over, with no idea which way was up' and the staircase simile; - time: 'In less than half a minute' and 'a second of most intense concern' in Text 1; 'It felt like a second, and like a year' in Text 2; - endings and purpose: Mills ends on spectacle ('a snow-cloud dragging above'); Hartley ends with advice and direct address ('go with a qualified guide', 'you will still be alive to see them'); - Hartley rejects the kind of story Mills tells: 'People often want this story to be an adventure, a thrilling escape.'; - voice: Mills is an expert with calm generalisations ('Friction almost ceases to be a factor with skees on a snowy steep', 'struggles of short duration') and playful humour ('my shadow collided with it'); Hartley is an ordinary skier relying on 'every safety talk', confessional and wry ('what a stupid way to go'); - form and audience: Text 1 is a first-person adventure from a book of mountain writing, meant to thrill; Text 2 is a newspaper article for a general readership, meant to warn.