Question 1
15 marksRead Text 1 below. Then answer the question that follows.
Text 1
The Spell of the Rockies
by Enos A. Mills (1911)
This edited extract is taken from The Spell of the Rockies by Enos Mills, an American naturalist and mountain guide, published in 1911. One March, Mills went alone into the San Juan Mountains of Colorado to study snow slides (avalanches). After a night trapped by cloud on a high summit, he was coming down a steep, snow-covered slope on skis when the snow far above him began to move.
[1] A general slide had started. I whirled to escape, pointed my skees down the slope,--and went. In less than half a minute a tremendous snow avalanche, one hundred or perhaps two hundred feet deep and five or six hundred feet long, thundered over the spot where I had stood.
[2] There was no chance to dodge, no time to climb out of the way. The only hope of escape lay in outrunning the magnificent monster. It came crashing and thundering after me as swift as a gale and more all-sweeping and destructive than an earthquake tidal wave.
[3] I made a desperate start. Friction almost ceases to be a factor with skees on a snowy steep, and in less than a hundred yards I was going like the wind. For the first quarter of a mile, to the upper end of the gulch, was smooth coasting, and down this I shot, with the avalanche, comet-tailed with snow-dust, in close pursuit. A race for life was on.
[...]
[4] It was a second of most intense concern as I cleared the ridge blindly to go into what lay below and beyond. It was like leaping into the dark, and with the leap turning on the all-revealing light. As I cleared the ridge, there was just time to pull myself together for a forty-odd-foot leap across one arm of the horseshoe-shaped end of the gorge. In all my wild mountainside coasts on skees, never have I sped as swiftly as when I made this mad flight. As I shot through the air, I had a glimpse down into the pointed, snow-laden tops of a few tall fir trees that were firmly rooted among the rocks in the bottom of the gorge. Luckily I cleared the gorge and landed in a good place; but so narrowly did I miss the corner of a cliff that my shadow collided with it.
[...]
[5] At the bottom of the moraine I was forced between two trees that stood close together, and a broken limb of one pierced my open coat just beneath the left armhole, and slit the coat to the bottom. My momentum and the resistance of the strong material gave me such a shock that I was flung off my balance, and my left skee smashed against a tree. Two feet of the heel was broken off and the remainder split. I managed to avoid falling, but had to check my speed with my staff for fear of a worse accident.
[6] Battling breakers with a broken oar or racing with a broken skee are struggles of short duration. The slide did not slow down, and so closely did it crowd me that, through the crashing of trees as it struck them down, I could hear the rocks and splintered timbers in its mass grinding together and thudding against obstructions over which it swept. These sounds, and flying, broken limbs cried to me "Faster!" and as I started to descend another steep moraine, I threw away my staff and "let go." I simply flashed down the slope, dodged and rounded a cliff, turned awkwardly into Aspen Gulch, and tumbled heels over head--into safety.
[7] Then I picked myself up, to see the slide go by within twenty feet, with great broken trees sticking out of its side, and a snow-cloud dragging above.
Glossary: skees - skis; gulch - a narrow, steep-sided valley; gorge - a deep, narrow valley with steep rocky sides; moraine - a ridge of rocks and earth left behind by a glacier; staff - a long pole used to help with balance
Analyse how the writer uses language and structure to interest and engage the reader.
In your answer you should write about:
- language features and techniques
- structural techniques
- the effect on the reader.
Support your views with detailed reference to the text.
Model answer
The extract engages the reader at once by dropping them into the middle of the action. Its short opening sentence, 'A general slide had started.', gives no time to settle, and the dash in 'pointed my skees down the slope,--and went' creates a split-second pause before the sudden 'went', mirroring his instant reaction. Within three sentences the avalanche has 'thundered over the spot where I had stood', so the reader immediately realises how close he came to death.
The writer's language turns the avalanche into a living enemy. Calling it 'the magnificent monster' that 'came crashing and thundering after me' presents it as a beast hunting him, yet the adjective 'magnificent' reveals that he is thrilled as well as afraid, and the reader is invited to share his awe. The comparisons 'as swift as a gale' and 'more all-sweeping and destructive than an earthquake tidal wave' measure it against the most violent forces in nature, and the hyperbole makes the race seem impossible to win. Sound imagery keeps the threat close: the 'crashing of trees' and the 'rocks and splintered timbers in its mass grinding together and thudding' let us hear it gaining on him as he flees.
Structurally, the extract is a chase told in stages, each one raising the stakes. Paragraph 2 closes off every option with the parallel phrases 'no chance to dodge, no time to climb out of the way', leaving just one: 'The only hope of escape lay in outrunning the magnificent monster.' Paragraph 3 ends with the short, headline-like sentence 'A race for life was on.', which turns the event into a contest the reader wants him to win. Then come the obstacles: the blind leap over the ridge, described in the simile 'like leaping into the dark', and the branch that 'pierced my open coat' just before his ski 'smashed against a tree'. These setbacks keep the outcome in doubt.
Mills also controls pace through sentence length. In paragraph 6 the long sentence 'I simply flashed down the slope, dodged and rounded a cliff, turned awkwardly into Aspen Gulch, and tumbled heels over head--into safety' piles verbs together so that the reader is swept along at his speed, and the dash holds back the relief of 'into safety' until the very end. The personification of the dangers that 'cried to me "Faster!"' adds urgency, as if the mountain itself were shouting at him.
There is humour too, which makes the voice engaging rather than simply terrifying. The hyperbole 'so narrowly did I miss the corner of a cliff that my shadow collided with it' is playful, and the calm general statement 'Battling breakers with a broken oar or racing with a broken skee are struggles of short duration' is the dry understatement of an experienced mountain man who can joke about danger.
Finally, the one-sentence last paragraph changes the pace completely. 'Then' marks the end of the chase, and the writer becomes a spectator, watching the slide 'go by within twenty feet'. The closing image of 'a snow-cloud dragging above' is quiet but awe-inspiring, leaving the reader with a sense of the enormous force he has just escaped.
Explanation
Level 5 needs analysis of both language and structure across the whole text, with short, discriminating quotations and clear effects on the reader, as here: the 'magnificent monster' metaphor, the chase told in stages, the long sentence of the final run and the calm last paragraph. Answers that name features without explaining their effect stay in the lower levels, and answers that cover only language or only structure are capped at 6 marks. The '[...]' gaps are the editor's cuts, not the writer's structure.
Mark scheme
-
15 marks
Levels of response (15 marks). AO2: Explain, comment on and analyse how writers use language and structure to achieve effects and influence readers, using relevant subject terminology to support their views.
Level 5 (13-15 marks): Analysis of the text. Analysis of how both language and structure are used to achieve effects and influence readers, including use of vocabulary, sentence structure and other language features. The selection of references is discriminating and clarifies the points being made.
Level 4 (10-12 marks): Exploration of the text. Exploration of how both language and structure are used to achieve effects and influence readers, including use of vocabulary, sentence structure and other language features. The selection of references is detailed, appropriate and fully supports the points being made.
Level 3 (7-9 marks): Explanation of the text. Explanation of how both language and structure are used to achieve effects and influence readers, including use of vocabulary and sentence structure. The selection of references is appropriate and relevant to the points being made.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Comment on the text. Comment on the language and/or structure used to achieve effects and influence readers, including use of vocabulary. The selection of references is valid, but not developed. NB: The mark awarded cannot progress beyond the top of Level 2 if only language OR structure has been considered.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Limited comment on the text. Identification of the language and/or structure used to achieve effects and influence readers. The use of references is limited.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Max 6 if the response considers only language or only structure (Pearson: responses that are unbalanced cannot access Level 3 or above, where analysis of both language and structure is required). Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Reward responses that analyse how the text uses language and structure to interest and engage the reader. Responses may include the following points about the language of the text: - the metaphor 'the magnificent monster', which 'came crashing and thundering after me', turns the avalanche into a living beast hunting the writer; 'magnificent' shows awe as well as fear, so the reader shares his excitement; - comparisons of speed and power, the similes 'as swift as a gale' and 'going like the wind' and the hyperbolic 'more all-sweeping and destructive than an earthquake tidal wave', make the danger enormous; - sound imagery and forceful verbs ('thundered', 'crashing', 'grinding together and thudding') let the reader hear the slide closing in; - visual images such as 'comet-tailed with snow-dust' and the simile 'like leaping into the dark, and with the leap turning on the all-revealing light' make the speed and the blind jump vivid; - verbs of rapid movement ('whirled', 'shot', 'sped', 'flashed', 'dodged', 'tumbled') and the vocabulary of desperation ('desperate start', 'most intense concern', 'mad flight') keep the pace high; - precise measurements ('one hundred or perhaps two hundred feet deep', 'a forty-odd-foot leap', 'within twenty feet') make the account credible and show how narrow the escape was; - humorous hyperbole ('my shadow collided with it') and the calm present-tense generalisations of an expert ('Friction almost ceases to be a factor with skees on a snowy steep'; 'Battling breakers with a broken oar or racing with a broken skee are struggles of short duration', with alliteration) create a confident, engaging voice; - the personified dangers that 'cried to me "Faster!"' and the quoted '"let go."' bring the reader into the moment. Responses may include the following points about the structure of the text: - the extract's abrupt opening in the middle of the action, the short sentence 'A general slide had started.' and the dash before 'and went', plunges the reader into the chase; - the chase is told in chronological stages (the start, the smooth run, the blind leap, the trees and the broken ski, the final descent, safety), each obstacle renewing the suspense; - short sentences at key points ('I made a desperate start.', and 'A race for life was on.' at the end of paragraph 3) sum up the stakes; - the parallel phrases 'no chance to dodge, no time to climb out of the way' close off every option before 'The only hope of escape'; - the long sentence of actions in paragraph 6, ending with the dash in 'tumbled heels over head--into safety', speeds the pace and delays the relief; - the one-sentence final paragraph, opening 'Then', slows everything down: the writer becomes a spectator, and the closing image 'a snow-cloud dragging above' leaves the reader with the scale of what he escaped. The '[...]' marks are the editor's cuts, not the writer's structure.