Question 1
20 marksRomeo and Juliet
In Act 1 Scene 2, Capulet tells Paris that Juliet's own consent matters to him.
Explain the importance of obedience elsewhere in the play.
In your answer, you must consider:
- where obedience and disobedience are shown
- the effects of disobedience within the play.
You must refer to the context of the play in your answer.
Model answer
Obedience matters in Romeo and Juliet because the play is built on a series of demands for it: from the Prince to his subjects, from masters to servants and, above all, from fathers to daughters. Shakespeare shows that obedience holds Verona together, but also that when love and obedience collide, the result is secrecy, deception and death.
The opening scene presents a city in which obedience has broken down. The servants fight because they obey their masters' quarrel without question; as Gregory says, "The quarrel is between our masters and us their men." Only the Prince's threat of death stops them, which shows that public obedience has to be enforced by fear. Elizabethans were taught that order in society depended on obedience to God and the monarch, and the commandment to honour one's father and mother made obedience to parents a religious duty, so this violent disobedience would have seemed deeply threatening.
Juliet begins as a model daughter. When her mother raises marriage, she promises to go no further "Than your consent gives strength to make it fly". Her language is cautious and dutiful, which makes her later defiance more striking. Once she loves Romeo, her loyalties are reversed: in the balcony scene she wishes aloud, not knowing that he can hear, "Deny thy father and refuse thy name", imagining a world in which family duty can simply be abandoned.
The conflict between obedience and love reaches its height in Act 3. Capulet confidently tells Paris, "I think she will be rul'd / In all respects by me", taking her obedience for granted. When Juliet refuses, his fury is immediate: he calls her a "disobedient wretch" and tells her she can "hang, beg, starve, die in the streets". This reflects the reality of a patriarchal society, where a young unmarried daughter depended on her father for money and a home and was expected to accept the husband he chose, particularly in wealthy families where marriage brought alliances and status. In law a marriage needed her own consent, but refusing her father could cost her everything. Capulet's rage is the effect of disobedience, but it also exposes how conditional his love has become.
Shakespeare then shows that obedience can be performed. In Act 4 Scene 2 Juliet kneels and promises, "Henceforward I am ever rul'd by you." The audience knows this is a lie planned with the Friar, and the effect is bitterly ironic: her apparent obedience delights her father so much that he brings the wedding forward a day, which disrupts the Friar's timing. Juliet's only way to disobey is to pretend to obey.
Disobedience also shapes the ending. Romeo breaks the Prince's sentence by returning from banishment, and Balthasar ignores his master's order to keep away: "For all this same, I'll hide me hereabout." His loyal disobedience means that a witness survives to confirm the truth to the Prince, so that the families finally understand what has happened and end their feud.
Overall, obedience is important because it reveals the power structures of Verona. Shakespeare suggests that blind obedience fuels the feud, while forced obedience drives the lovers into secrecy; the tragedy comes from a society that demands obedience rather than listening.
Explanation
Level 5 responses argue about obedience across the whole play, not only between Capulet and Juliet: the servants and the Prince, Juliet's performed obedience in Act 4 Scene 2 and Balthasar's loyal disobedience. Context about a daughter's duty and order in society should explain why disobedience has such serious effects. Common errors are writing about the Act 1 Scene 2 conversation, which is not credited in part (b), and turning the answer into a narrative of the argument in Act 3 Scene 5.
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO1 (15 marks), AO3 (5 marks).
Level 5 (17-20 marks): There is an assured personal response, showing a high level of engagement with the text. A critical style is developed with maturity, perceptive understanding and interpretation. Discerning references are an integral part of the response, with points made with assurance and full support from the text. There is excellent understanding of context, and convincing understanding of the relationship between text and context is integrated into the response.
Level 4 (13-16 marks): The response has a developed personal response and thorough engagement, fully related to the text. The critical style is sustained, and there is well-developed interpretation. Well-chosen references to the text support a range of effective points. There is sustained comment on relevant context and detailed awareness of the relationship between text and context.
Level 3 (9-12 marks): The response shows a relevant personal response, soundly related to the text. There is an appropriate critical style, with comments showing a sound interpretation. The response is relevant and focused points are made with support from the text. There is sound comment on relevant context and sound relevant comment on the relationship between text and context.
Level 2 (5-8 marks): The response may be largely narrative but has some elements of personal response. There is some evidence of a critical style but it is not always applied securely. Some valid points are made, but without consistent or secure focus. There is some awareness of relevant context and some comment on the relationship between text and context.
Level 1 (1-4 marks): The response is simple with little personal response. There is little evidence of a critical style. Little reference is made to the content or themes of the play. There is little awareness of context and little comment on the relationship between text and context.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Pearson's grid: AO1 (15 marks) and AO3 (5 marks): in each level bullets 1, 2 and 3 are AO1 and bullet 4 is AO3. Indicative content (not prescriptive; reward all valid points): AO1: in Act 1 Scene 1 the servants obey their masters' feud ("The quarrel is between our masters and us their men"), and only the Prince's threat of death makes them stop; in Act 1 Scene 3 Juliet is dutiful, promising to look on Paris no further "Than your consent gives strength to make it fly"; in Act 1 Scene 5 Tybalt is forced to obey Capulet ("He shall be endur'd") and leaves vowing revenge; in Act 2 Scene 2 Juliet, not knowing that Romeo can hear, wishes aloud that he would reject family duty ("Deny thy father and refuse thy name"), and the secret marriage is an act of disobedience; in Act 3 Scene 4 Capulet assumes obedience ("I think she will be rul'd / In all respects by me") and in Act 3 Scene 5 explodes at her refusal: "disobedient wretch", "hang, beg, starve, die in the streets"; in Act 4 Scene 2 Juliet's false obedience, "Henceforward I am ever rul'd by you", leads Capulet to bring the wedding forward, which upsets the Friar's timing; Romeo disobeys the Prince by returning from banishment; in Act 5 Scene 3 Balthasar disobeys Romeo ("For all this same, I'll hide me hereabout") and survives to tell the truth. AO3: Elizabethans were taught that social order depended on obedience to God and the monarch, and the commandment to honour one's father and mother required children to obey their parents; daughters, especially in wealthy families, were expected to accept the husband their parents chose, since marriage linked families and wealth, even though in law a marriage needed the couple's own consent; civil disorder between powerful families was seen as a threat to the stability of the state. Part (b) is about the play outside the moment named in the question (in the exam, that moment is the extract printed for part (a)). Pearson's June 2022 examiners' report says that no marks could be awarded for discussing the extract in part (b), although contextual comments were credited. Pearson's mark scheme: candidates will be rewarded if they make relevant textual references or use short quotations from elsewhere in the play, outside of the extract provided; this includes relevant paraphrasing. Language analysis is not assessed in part (b).