Question 1
40 marksAnimal Farm: George Orwell
Your response will be marked for the range of appropriate vocabulary and sentence structures, and accurate use of spelling and punctuation.
"The hens, said Napoleon, should welcome this sacrifice as their own special contribution towards the building of the windmill."
How are the hens presented in Animal Farm?
You must refer to the context of the novel in your answer.
(40 marks, including 8 marks for the range of appropriate vocabulary and sentence structures, and accurate use of spelling and punctuation)
Model answer
The hens are presented as some of the humblest animals on the farm, and Orwell uses that humility to powerful effect. They are not clever, strong or eloquent, yet they are the first animals since the expulsion of Jones to rebel against the new regime. Through the hens Orwell shows how the revolution's promise to end exploitation is broken, how resistance is crushed, and how the truth about suffering is hidden.
Old Major makes the hens a central example of human exploitation. In Chapter 1 he asks them how many of their eggs ever hatched into chickens, and answers his own question: "The rest have all gone to market to bring in money for Jones and his men." The eggs stand for the produce of the workers' labour, and for their future, since every egg sold is a chick that will never be born. Major's analysis echoes Marx's argument that workers are robbed of what they produce, and it gives the hens a clear stake in the Rebellion. In the early chapters they play their part: in the harvest of Chapter 3 the hens and ducks gather up "the very last stalk" and save five bushels of corn, and Snowball forms an Egg Production Committee for them. They are classed among "the stupider animals" who cannot learn the Commandments, but they are loyal, useful members of the farm.
The quotation in the question marks the moment Napoleon turns Major's argument upside down. In Chapter 6 he announces that eggs will be sold to pay for the windmill's materials, and that the hens "should welcome this sacrifice". The language of sacrifice disguises a return to Jones's practice of sending the eggs to market. By Chapter 7 a contract for four hundred eggs a week has been agreed through Whymper, and the hens' reaction is the most direct protest in the novel. They declare that to take the eggs now, when they are preparing their clutches for spring, is "murder", and the narrator records that for the first time since Jones there was "something resembling a rebellion".
Orwell presents this rebellion with admiration and pity. Led by three young Black Minorca pullets, the hens fly up to the rafters and lay their eggs there, so that they smash on the floor. Their weapon is self-destruction: they would rather destroy what they produce than surrender it. Napoleon's response is swift and ruthless. Their rations are stopped, anyone giving them a grain of corn is to be punished by death, and "The dogs saw to it that these orders were carried out." After five days the hens capitulate, nine of them dead. Their bodies are buried in the orchard and it is given out that they died of coccidiosis, a disease. The lie matters as much as the cruelty, because it shows that the regime controls the story of suffering as well as the suffering itself.
Many readers see a close historical parallel. When Stalin forced peasants into collective farms from 1929, many resisted by slaughtering their own livestock rather than hand it over, just as the hens smash their eggs. The famine that followed in 1932-33 killed millions, worst of all in Ukraine, and like the coccidiosis story it was officially denied; some Western journalists, such as Walter Duranty of the New York Times, played down reports of starvation. Orwell's hens are tiny, but their story stands for one of the great crimes of the twentieth century.
The hens' suffering does not end with their surrender. In the purge of Chapter 7, the three ringleaders confess that Snowball appeared to them in a dream and incited them to disobey, and they are slaughtered. Orwell's dark humour lies in the absurdity of the confession, which makes the executions even more horrifying. In Chapter 8 three more hens confess to a plot to murder Napoleon, and one hen is heard to remark that "Under the guidance of our Leader, Comrade Napoleon" she has laid five eggs in six days. The image is bitterly ironic: the hens now give Napoleon credit for the very eggs he takes from them.
By Chapter 9 the egg contract has risen to six hundred a week, and the hens barely hatch enough chicks to keep their numbers level. Their eggs are being sold just as Jones sold them, which is exactly the exploitation Major had condemned. Orwell presents the hens, then, as the clearest measure of the revolution's failure. They begin as Major's example of human greed, become the first animals to resist the pigs, and end as silent producers whose eggs are sold to keep the farm, and the pigs, in comfort. Their story suggests that the smallest and least powerful members of a society are often the first to feel tyranny, and the first to be made to disappear from its official history.
Explanation
A Level 5 answer explores how the hens are presented across the novel - Major's example, loyal workers, the first rebels, silenced victims - with discerning references such as the "sacrifice", the smashed eggs and the coccidiosis lie, and integrates context such as collectivisation and the 1932-33 famine at the points where it explains the text. Eight marks are for SPaG. Common errors are writing only about the Chapter 7 rebellion, narrating it at length, and treating the Soviet history as a separate topic.
Mark scheme
-
32 marks
Levels of response (32 marks). AO1 (16 marks), AO3 (16 marks).
Level 5 (27-32 marks): There is an assured personal response, showing a high level of engagement with the text and discerning choice of references to the text. A critical style is developed with maturity, perceptive understanding and interpretation with discerning choice of references to the text. The understanding of relevant contexts is excellent. Understanding of the relationship between text and context is integrated convincingly into the response.
Level 4 (20-26 marks): The response has a developed personal response and thorough engagement, fully related to the text with well-chosen references to the text. The critical style is sustained and there is well-developed interpretation with well-chosen references to the text. Sustained comment is offered on relevant contexts. There is detailed awareness of the relationship between text and context.
Level 3 (13-19 marks): The response shows a relevant personal response, soundly related to the text with focused supporting textual references. There is an appropriate critical style, with comments showing a sound interpretation with focused supporting textual references. Sound comment is offered on relevant contexts. There is relevant comment on the relationship between text and context.
Level 2 (7-12 marks): The response may be largely narrative but has some elements of personal response; there is some reference to the text without consistent or secure focus. There is some evidence of a critical style and there is some reference to the text without consistent or secure focus. Some awareness of relevant contexts is shown. There is some comment on the relationship between text and context.
Level 1 (1-6 marks): Pearson's descriptors for this level are given word for word at the start of the comments.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Pearson's grid: AO1 (16 marks) and AO3 (16 marks): in each level bullets 1 and 2 are AO1 and bullets 3 and 4 are AO3. Pearson's descriptors (continued). Level 1 (1-6 marks): The response is simple with little personal response and little relevant supporting reference to the text. There is little evidence of a critical style and little relevant supporting reference to the text. Little awareness of relevant contexts is shown. There is little comment on the relationship between text and context. Indicative content (not prescriptive; reward all valid points): Reward responses that explore the hens in the novel.
Interpretation of text (AO1):
- Chapter 1: Major asks the hens how many of their eggs ever hatched - "The rest have all gone to market to bring in money for Jones and his men"
- Chapter 2: a hen recalls that Jones mixed milk into the mash, raising the question of where the milk goes
- Chapter 3: hens and ducks gather the last stalks and save five bushels of corn; Snowball forms an Egg Production Committee; they are among the stupider animals; the birds object to "Four legs good, two legs bad"
- Chapter 6: Napoleon announces that eggs will be sold, calling it the hens' "sacrifice"
- Chapter 7: the contract for four hundred eggs a week; the hens call it "murder" and, led by three young Black Minorca pullets, smash their eggs from the rafters - "something resembling a rebellion"
- Chapter 7: rations stopped, death for anyone who feeds them; after five days they give in; nine hens have died and the cause is given out as coccidiosis; the three ringleaders confess and are slaughtered
- Chapter 8: a hen credits Napoleon for her laying ("I have laid five eggs in six days"); three hens confess to a plot to murder Napoleon and are executed
- Chapter 9: the egg contract rises to six hundred a week and the hens barely hatch enough chicks to keep their numbers level - the fate Major described under Jones has returned
Relationship between text and context (AO3):
- the hens' resistance recalls peasant resistance to Stalin's collectivisation from 1929, when many peasants killed their own livestock rather than hand it over
- their starvation recalls the famine of 1932-33, in which millions died, worst in Ukraine
- the cover story of coccidiosis and the deception of Whymper echo the denial of the famine; some Western journalists, such as Walter Duranty of the New York Times, played it down
- Major's speech on the hens' eggs reflects Marx's idea that workers are robbed of what they produce; under Napoleon the theft resumes
Reward all valid points. Candidates will be rewarded if they make relevant textual references or use short quotations from the text; this includes relevant paraphrasing (Pearson's mark scheme). AO2 (language, form and structure) is not assessed in Section B. -
8 marks
SPaG. AO4 (8 marks).
Level 3 (6-8 marks): high performance - in the context of the Level of Demand of the question. Learners spell and punctuate with consistent accuracy, and consistently use vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve effective control of meaning.
Level 2 (3-5 marks): intermediate performance - in the context of the Level of Demand of the question. Learners spell and punctuate with considerable accuracy, and use a considerable range of vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve general control of meaning.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): threshold performance - in the context of the Level of Demand of the question. Learners spell and punctuate with reasonable accuracy, and use a reasonable range of vocabulary and sentence structures; any errors do not hinder meaning in the response.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Pearson's AO4 grid is used for all questions in Paper 1 Section B. AO4 is judged on the whole response: the range of vocabulary and sentence structures and the accuracy of spelling and punctuation, in the context of the level of demand of the question. The content of the answer is credited only in the first mark point.