Question 1
40 marksLord of the Flies: William Golding
Your response will be marked for the range of appropriate vocabulary and sentence structures, and accurate use of spelling and punctuation.
In Chapter 10, Jack's hunters attack the shelters in the dark, and Jack leaves with Piggy's broken glasses hanging from his hand.
How is the relationship between Piggy and Jack presented in the novel?
You must refer to the context of the novel in your answer.
(40 marks, including 8 marks for the range of appropriate vocabulary and sentence structures, and accurate use of spelling and punctuation)
Model answer
The relationship between Piggy and Jack is the most purely hostile in Lord of the Flies. Ralph and Jack begin with a wary liking; Piggy and Jack begin with contempt on one side and fear on the other, and nothing ever softens it. Golding uses their conflict to dramatise a clash between reason and force, but also between social classes, and the way the relationship develops - from insult to theft to murder - charts the destruction of everything Piggy stands for.
From the start Jack treats Piggy as beneath notice. In Chapter 1 he silences him with "Shut up, Fatty", and when Ralph, Jack and Simon set off to explore, Jack dismisses Piggy with a flat "We don't want you". Jack's hostility is partly about Piggy's body - his weight, his asthma, his glasses - but it is also about class. Jack is the leader of a choir and a head boy; Piggy speaks with an accent and non-standard grammar that the other boys mock, and he was brought up by his auntie, who kept a sweet shop. In the strictly divided Britain of the early 1950s, accent and schooling placed people instantly. Jack's contempt is that of a privileged boy for someone he regards as common, and Piggy's habit of correcting and lecturing makes it worse.
Yet Jack needs what Piggy has. In Chapter 2, when the boys cannot light the signal fire, the narrator records that "Jack snatched the glasses off his face" and used them to focus the sun. Piggy's terror at losing his sight is ignored, and his practical advice about shelters and counting the littluns is brushed aside. This pattern is the heart of their relationship: Jack exploits Piggy's tools and despises the boy who owns them. Golding wrote in a period that placed enormous faith in science and technology, and the glasses can be read as that knowledge - useful to the powerful, but never respected by them.
The hostility turns violent in Chapter 4. When the hunters return from their first kill to find that the fire has gone out and a ship has passed, Piggy blames Jack directly. Jack, humiliated in his moment of triumph, hits him, and one lens of the glasses shatters on the rocks. It is the first blow one boy deliberately strikes another, and it is significant that its victim is Piggy. Jack cannot strike Ralph, who still has the authority of the vote, so he strikes the weaker boy who has told him the truth. Afterwards no meat is offered to Piggy until Simon shares his own, a small sign of the exclusion that will become deadly.
Piggy fears Jack, but he never stops challenging him, and this gives him a kind of courage the novel quietly honours. In the chaotic assembly of Chapter 5 he demands, "What are we? Humans? Or animals? Or savages?" - a question aimed squarely at Jack and the hunters. When Jack leaves the group in Chapter 8, Piggy is openly relieved and tells Ralph that Jack is the cause of their troubles. For the first time Ralph treats Piggy as an equal, and the reader sees how much Piggy's intelligence could have achieved if he had been listened to.
The raid in Chapter 10 turns contempt into theft. Piggy assumes the attackers have come for the conch, but they leave the shell and take his glasses. Jack does not want the symbol of democracy; he wants the power to make fire. At the end of the chapter he runs off with the glasses dangling from his hand, and Piggy, almost blind, is left helpless. Golding's point is sharp: Jack's tribe has learned that power lies in practical control, not in the rituals of assembly.
The final confrontation in Chapter 11 brings the relationship to its end. Piggy insists on going to Castle Rock to ask for his glasses back, holding the conch and asking whether it is better "to have rules and agree" or to hunt and kill. The appeal to reason is answered by Roger's rock, which kills Piggy and destroys the conch, and Jack screams with joy that the conch is gone. Golding presents Piggy's death as the triumph of force over argument. In his essay Fable Golding wrote with horror about the totalitarian states, and dictatorships have always hated those who ask awkward questions; Jack's delight is the delight of a tyrant rid of a critic.
The relationship is therefore presented as a struggle that Piggy cannot win, because he fights with words and Jack fights with fists, fire and finally a boulder. Yet Golding ensures that the moral victory is Piggy's. In the last chapter Ralph weeps for "the true, wise friend called Piggy", and the phrase contrasts painfully with Jack's early insult. Jack never learns Piggy's real name, and neither does the reader; but by the end, Golding makes clear who was right.
Explanation
High-level answers analyse how the relationship develops (insult, exploitation, violence, theft, murder) and what it represents - reason against force and class prejudice - using discerning references from across the novel and integrating context such as the 1950s class system and Golding's view of totalitarian states. Answers that only describe Jack bullying Piggy, or that drift into a general essay on Piggy, stay in the lower levels. Avoid inventing quotations; 8 of the 40 marks are for SPaG.
Mark scheme
-
32 marks
Levels of response (32 marks). AO1 (16 marks), AO3 (16 marks).
Level 5 (27-32 marks): There is an assured personal response, showing a high level of engagement with the text and discerning choice of references to the text. A critical style is developed with maturity, perceptive understanding and interpretation with discerning choice of references to the text. The understanding of relevant contexts is excellent. Understanding of the relationship between text and context is integrated convincingly into the response.
Level 4 (20-26 marks): The response has a developed personal response and thorough engagement, fully related to the text with well-chosen references to the text. The critical style is sustained and there is well-developed interpretation with well-chosen references to the text. Sustained comment is offered on relevant contexts. There is detailed awareness of the relationship between text and context.
Level 3 (13-19 marks): The response shows a relevant personal response, soundly related to the text with focused supporting textual references. There is an appropriate critical style, with comments showing a sound interpretation with focused supporting textual references. Sound comment is offered on relevant contexts. There is relevant comment on the relationship between text and context.
Level 2 (7-12 marks): The response may be largely narrative but has some elements of personal response; there is some reference to the text without consistent or secure focus. There is some evidence of a critical style and there is some reference to the text without consistent or secure focus. Some awareness of relevant contexts is shown. There is some comment on the relationship between text and context.
Level 1 (1-6 marks): Pearson's descriptors for this level are given word for word at the start of the comments.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Pearson's grid: AO1 (16 marks) and AO3 (16 marks): in each level bullets 1 and 2 are AO1 and bullets 3 and 4 are AO3. Pearson's descriptors (continued). Level 1 (1-6 marks): The response is simple with little personal response and little relevant supporting reference to the text. There is little evidence of a critical style and little relevant supporting reference to the text. Little awareness of relevant contexts is shown. There is little comment on the relationship between text and context. Indicative content (not prescriptive; reward all valid points): AO1 (interpretation of the text): (a) Chapter 1: Jack silences Piggy with "Shut up, Fatty", and he refuses to let Piggy join the exploration ("We don't want you"); contempt for Piggy's body, accent and manner. (b) Chapter 2: "Jack snatched the glasses off his face" to light the fire; Piggy protests and later mocks the result. (c) Chapter 4: Piggy blames Jack for the fire going out; Jack hits him and a lens breaks; at first no meat is given to Piggy. (d) Chapter 5: Jack taunts Piggy at the assembly; Piggy asks "What are we? Humans? Or animals? Or savages?" (e) Chapter 8: Piggy is glad Jack has gone and blames him for the breakdown. (f) Chapter 10: the raid - the glasses, not the conch, are what Jack wants; he takes the power to make fire. (g) Chapter 11: Piggy confronts Jack's tribe with the conch, asking whether it is better "to have rules and agree"; Roger kills him, and Jack rejoices that the conch is gone. (h) The relationship sets reason and weakness against force and status; Piggy fears Jack yet keeps challenging him, and Jack's hatred grows as Piggy's usefulness grows. AO3 (text and context): (a) the 1950s class system - Piggy's accent and grammar mark him as lower in status than the choir leader and head boy. (b) Reason against force: dictators' hatred of intellectuals; Golding's essay Fable on the totalitarian states. (c) Post-war faith in science and technology (the glasses) and its abuse by those in power. (d) Bullying in schools, which Golding knew as a teacher. Candidates will be rewarded if they make relevant textual references or use short quotations from the text; this includes relevant paraphrasing (Pearson's mark scheme). AO2 (language, form and structure) is not assessed in Section B.
-
8 marks
SPaG. AO4 (8 marks).
Level 3 (6-8 marks): high performance - in the context of the Level of Demand of the question. Learners spell and punctuate with consistent accuracy, and consistently use vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve effective control of meaning.
Level 2 (3-5 marks): intermediate performance - in the context of the Level of Demand of the question. Learners spell and punctuate with considerable accuracy, and use a considerable range of vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve general control of meaning.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): threshold performance - in the context of the Level of Demand of the question. Learners spell and punctuate with reasonable accuracy, and use a reasonable range of vocabulary and sentence structures; any errors do not hinder meaning in the response.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Pearson's AO4 grid is used for all questions in Paper 1 Section B. AO4 is judged on the whole response: the range of vocabulary and sentence structures and the accuracy of spelling and punctuation, in the context of the level of demand of the question. The content of the answer is credited only in the first mark point.