Question 1
40 marksHobson's Choice: Harold Brighouse
Your response will be marked for the range of appropriate vocabulary and sentence structures, and accurate use of spelling and punctuation.
In Act Four, it is Tubby Wadlow, who has been left to look after the sick Hobson, who fetches Maggie to the house.
Explore how Tubby Wadlow is significant in the play.
You must refer to the context of the play in your answer.
(40 marks, including 8 marks for the range of appropriate vocabulary and sentence structures, and accurate use of spelling and punctuation)
Model answer
Tubby Wadlow is a minor character, but Brighouse uses him with great care. He is the foreman of Hobson's cellar workshop, the voice of the ordinary working man, and a useful dramatic device who reveals truths and carries messages at key moments. His significance lies partly in what he shows us about the world of Hobson's Choice and partly in the contrast between his fate and Willie's.
Tubby's first appearance in Act One is carefully staged. When Mrs Hepworth demands to see the workman who made her boots, Maggie calls down the trap, and Tubby comes up, a white-haired little man in "dingy clothes" with no collar and no coat. He stands half out of the trap, unwilling to come fully into the shop, and answers Mrs Hepworth with a respectful "No, ma'am". Brighouse presents the hierarchy of a Victorian workshop visually: the makers work below, out of sight, while the master and his daughters deal with customers above. Tubby's honesty matters too. Asked who made the boots, he names Willie at once, and it is this plain answer that reveals Willie's skill and sets the whole story in motion. Tubby has none of Hobson's vanity; he simply tells the truth.
He also has a quieter role in Maggie's plan. After she wins Willie from Ada Figgins, Maggie moves him out of his lodgings at Mrs Figgins's and sends him to Tubby Wadlow's, and it is there that she gives Willie his lessons before the wedding. Tubby's home becomes the staging post between Willie's old life and his new one, which suggests the solidarity of working people who help one another without fuss. It is also a quiet comment on Willie's position: a skilled man of about thirty still lodging in other people's houses, with no home of his own until Maggie provides one. Tubby's willingness to take him in, without any of the fuss or snobbery that the Hobson sisters show, places him firmly among the play's decent characters.
Tubby is most significant in Act Two, where Brighouse uses him to show the effect of Maggie's departure. A month has passed, and the shop is in chaos. Tubby has no orders because nobody wants boots made, and he can only suggest making clogs for stock, though he knows clogs will not pay the rent. When Alice tells him to get on with it, he is cautious: "I'm not a rash man", he says, and he will not risk the master's anger, with "his temper so nowty" since Maggie went. The comedy of the scene - the polite foreman and the helpless daughters passing responsibility back and forth - hides a serious point. Alice's despairing question, asking Tubby what Miss Maggie would have told him to do, shows that Maggie was the real manager all along, and that Hobson's business cannot survive without the skill and management he undervalued. Clogs were the cheap, hard-wearing footwear of working people, while the high-class trade bought boots; Tubby's clogs for stock are a sign of a business losing its best customers.
In Act Four Tubby takes on a more caring role. He has been left to look after the sick Hobson, and it is he who fetches Maggie, telling her that her father is dangerously ill. Hobson's response is typical: on hearing that Tubby fetched her, he declares that Tubby can quit his shop at once, and has to be pushed back into his chair by the doctor. The loyal servant who has done the right thing is threatened with the sack, which shows how little Hobson has learned. Tubby's quiet decency contrasts both with Hobson's ingratitude and with the selfishness of Alice and Vickey, who refuse to take their father in.
The contrast with Willie may be Tubby's deepest significance. Both men are skilled workmen in the same cellar, dressed in the same poor clothes; indeed the stage directions describe Willie's clothes as "an even poorer edition of Tubby's". Yet by Act Four Willie is a prosperous master with his name above Hobson's, while Tubby remains an employee. Brighouse does not mock Tubby for this; rather, he shows that rising in the world in 1880 needed more than skill. Willie needed Maggie's brain, Mrs Hepworth's money and his own growing confidence. For most working men of Tubby's generation, with little schooling and no patron, loyalty and hard work earned respect but not escape. Brighouse's audience in 1915, living in a society still deeply divided by class, would recognise how rare Willie's story was.
Tubby is therefore significant as a witness, a messenger and a contrast. He reveals Willie's talent, shows the shop's decline, brings Maggie back to save her father and reminds the audience of the many working people for whom the chances Willie seized never came.
Explanation
A Level 5 answer explores Tubby's dramatic functions (revealing Willie's skill, showing the shop's decline in Act Two, fetching Maggie in Act Four) and his thematic meaning as a loyal workman who does not rise, contrasted with Willie, with context on workshop hierarchy and working-class opportunity integrated. Answers that only describe his appearances, or confuse what he does with Willie's actions, stay in the lower levels. Remember that 8 of the 40 marks are for accurate spelling and punctuation and a varied, controlled style.
Mark scheme
-
32 marks
Levels of response (32 marks). AO1 (16 marks), AO3 (16 marks).
Level 5 (27-32 marks): There is an assured personal response, showing a high level of engagement with the text and discerning choice of references to the text. A critical style is developed with maturity, perceptive understanding and interpretation with discerning choice of references to the text. The understanding of relevant contexts is excellent. Understanding of the relationship between text and context is integrated convincingly into the response.
Level 4 (20-26 marks): The response has a developed personal response and thorough engagement, fully related to the text with well-chosen references to the text. The critical style is sustained and there is well-developed interpretation with well-chosen references to the text. Sustained comment is offered on relevant contexts. There is detailed awareness of the relationship between text and context.
Level 3 (13-19 marks): The response shows a relevant personal response, soundly related to the text with focused supporting textual references. There is an appropriate critical style, with comments showing a sound interpretation with focused supporting textual references. Sound comment is offered on relevant contexts. There is relevant comment on the relationship between text and context.
Level 2 (7-12 marks): The response may be largely narrative but has some elements of personal response; there is some reference to the text without consistent or secure focus. There is some evidence of a critical style and there is some reference to the text without consistent or secure focus. Some awareness of relevant contexts is shown. There is some comment on the relationship between text and context.
Level 1 (1-6 marks): Pearson's descriptors for this level are given word for word at the start of the comments.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Pearson's grid: AO1 (16 marks) and AO3 (16 marks): in each level bullets 1 and 2 are AO1 and bullets 3 and 4 are AO3. Pearson's descriptors (continued). Level 1 (1-6 marks): The response is simple with little personal response and little relevant supporting reference to the text. There is little evidence of a critical style and little relevant supporting reference to the text. Little awareness of relevant contexts is shown. There is little comment on the relationship between text and context. Indicative content (not prescriptive; reward all valid points): Interpretation of text (AO1): Tubby is the foreman of the cellar workshop, first seen coming up the trap in "dingy clothes" with no collar and no coat: the face of Hobson's workforce; his deference to Mrs Hepworth ("No, ma'am") and his honest answer that the boots are Willie's making reveal Willie's skill; after the proposal Maggie moves Willie from Mrs Figgins's to Tubby Wadlow's lodgings, where Maggie gives Willie his lessons before the wedding; in Act Two, with Maggie and Willie gone, he has no orders and can only make clogs for stock; his line "I'm not a rash man" and his fear of Hobson's temper ("his temper so nowty") show the business falling apart; Alice's helpless question to Tubby, asking what Miss Maggie would have told him to do, shows that Tubby, like everyone, relied on Maggie; in Act Four he looks after Hobson and fetches Maggie; Hobson's angry threat to sack him shows the master's ingratitude; he contrasts with Willie: both are skilled workmen, but Tubby stays a loyal employee while Willie rises; his gentle comedy and plain speech give the audience a working man's view of the Hobsons' quarrels. Relationship between text and context (AO3): Victorian workshops were hierarchical: makers worked out of sight while the shop and the master dealt with customers; Pearson's mark scheme notes that working-class customers bought hard-wearing clogs while the high-class trade bought boots; Tubby's clogs for stock show a business losing its best custom; working men of Tubby's generation had little schooling and few chances of rising, which makes Willie's rise exceptional; loyalty and deference to a master were expected of workmen in 1880, though employers often exploited them. Candidates will be rewarded if they make relevant textual references or use short quotations from the text; this includes relevant paraphrasing (Pearson's mark scheme). AO2 (language, form and structure) is not assessed in Section B.
-
8 marks
SPaG. AO4 (8 marks).
Level 3 (6-8 marks): high performance - in the context of the Level of Demand of the question. Learners spell and punctuate with consistent accuracy, and consistently use vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve effective control of meaning.
Level 2 (3-5 marks): intermediate performance - in the context of the Level of Demand of the question. Learners spell and punctuate with considerable accuracy, and use a considerable range of vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve general control of meaning.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): threshold performance - in the context of the Level of Demand of the question. Learners spell and punctuate with reasonable accuracy, and use a reasonable range of vocabulary and sentence structures; any errors do not hinder meaning in the response.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Pearson's AO4 grid is used for all questions in Paper 1 Section B. AO4 is judged on the whole response: the range of vocabulary and sentence structures and the accuracy of spelling and punctuation, in the context of the level of demand of the question. The content of the answer is credited only in the first mark point.