Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Elizabeth I's seizure of the Spanish treasure ships in 1568.
Model answer
Elizabeth kept the money the ships were carrying. It had been borrowed from Genoese bankers to pay the Duke of Alba's army in the Netherlands, and Elizabeth claimed she was simply taking over the loan, so the money never reached Alba.
Explanation
A strong answer identifies one clear aspect of the seizure, such as why the ships were in English ports or how Spain retaliated, and supports it with a specific fact. A common mistake is to think the ships were captured at sea by privateers or came from the Americas; in fact they had sheltered in Plymouth and Southampton while carrying pay for Alba's army.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the seizure of the Spanish treasure ships (1568) identified, e.g. the ships carried money to pay the Spanish army in the Netherlands / the ships were sheltering in English ports / Elizabeth kept the money / she claimed the money was a loan from Italian (Genoese) bankers / Spain retaliated by seizing English property / it led to a long halt in trade with the Netherlands
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. The ships were carrying money to pay the Spanish army in the Netherlands (1). It had been borrowed from Genoese bankers to pay the Duke of Alba's soldiers (1). / The ships had taken shelter in English ports (1). They had been chased by privateers in the Channel and put in at Plymouth and Southampton (1). / Elizabeth kept the money (1). She claimed that it still belonged to the Genoese bankers and that she was simply taking over the loan (1). / Spain retaliated (1). The Duke of Alba seized English ships and goods in the Netherlands, and Elizabeth then seized Spanish and Netherlands property in England (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the purpose: the money (gold and silver) was on its way to Antwerp to pay Alba's army, which had arrived to crush the Dutch revolt in 1567; for the shelter: the ships put into Plymouth and Southampton in late 1568 to escape privateers (and bad weather); for keeping the money: Philip's army did not receive it, and Elizabeth treated it as borrowed from the bankers rather than as Spanish property; for retaliation: Alba, advised by the Spanish ambassador Guerau de Spes, seized English goods in the Netherlands, and England seized Spanish ships and goods in return; for trade: trade between England and the Netherlands was stopped until the Convention of Nymegen (1573), and claims for compensation were settled by the Convention of Bristol (1574); English cloth was sent to Hamburg instead; for timing: it came in the same months as news of the Spanish attack on Hawkins at San Juan de Ulúa
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or general comments such as 'it made Philip angry'. Do not credit answers saying Drake or other privateers captured these ships at sea, that the money came from a New World treasure fleet, or that the event was part of the Armada. Accept 1568-69 for the crisis. The amount is given differently by different historians (often about £85,000); no figure is needed and any reasonable figure should not be penalised.