Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the Ridolfi Plot (1571).
Model answer
One feature of the Ridolfi Plot was its plan for a foreign invasion. The Duke of Alba was to send Spanish troops from the Netherlands to support a rising of English Catholics, so that Mary, Queen of Scots could marry the Duke of Norfolk and replace Elizabeth.
Explanation
Full marks need one clear feature, such as the planned Spanish invasion or the marriage of Mary to Norfolk, and a precise detail that develops it. A common error is to say Walsingham uncovered the plot: in 1571 he was ambassador in France and the investigation was led by Cecil.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the Ridolfi Plot identified, e.g. it was organised by Roberto Ridolfi, an Italian banker in London / it planned a Spanish invasion from the Netherlands / English Catholics were to rise up / Elizabeth was to be overthrown (or killed) / Mary, Queen of Scots was to marry the Duke of Norfolk and become queen / it had the backing of the Pope and Philip II / it was discovered through intercepted messages and money / the Duke of Norfolk was executed because of it
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. The plot planned a Spanish invasion (1). The Duke of Alba was to send troops from the Netherlands to support a rising of English Catholics (1). / Mary was to marry the Duke of Norfolk (1). Together they would then rule England as Catholic king and queen (1). / Ridolfi travelled abroad to win support (1), visiting the Duke of Alba, the Pope and Philip II in 1571 (1). / The plot was uncovered by the government (1) after a messenger, Charles Baillie, was arrested at Dover carrying letters (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for Ridolfi: he was an Italian (Florentine) banker who acted as a go-between for Mary, the Pope and Spain; for the invasion: Alba was to land troops (accounts give between about 6,000 and 10,000 men; accept any figure in that range), at Harwich or Portsmouth; for the rising: Ridolfi claimed many English nobles were secretly Catholic; for Mary and Norfolk: the marriage would make Mary queen with England's only duke as her husband; for foreign backing: Pope Pius V approved the plan and Philip II considered it, but Alba doubted it would work; for discovery: Charles Baillie was arrested at Dover in April 1571 and revealed the cipher; in August 1571 a draper, Thomas Browne, found gold and coded letters in a bag from Norfolk's secretaries and reported it to Cecil (Lord Burghley); for the results: Norfolk was tried in January 1572 and executed on 2 June 1572, and the Spanish ambassador, de Spes, was expelled in December 1571
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or general comments such as 'it was a dangerous plot'. Do not credit Walsingham as the man who uncovered this plot: he was ambassador in France in 1571, and Cecil (Lord Burghley) led the investigation. Do not credit 'Ridolfi was executed': he was abroad when the plot was discovered and never returned. Do not confuse the Duke of Alba with the Duke of Guise (Throckmorton Plot).