Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the vestment controversy (1565-66).
Model answer
In the vestment controversy, many Puritan clergy refused to wear the surplice because they saw it as the dress of a Catholic priest. In March 1566 the London clergy were summoned to Lambeth Palace, and 37 who would not promise to wear the vestments were suspended from their posts.
Explanation
Strong answers name a clear feature, such as the refusal to wear the surplice or Parker's Advertisements, and support it with a precise detail like the suspension of 37 London clergy. Avoid confusing this dispute with the earlier crucifix controversy, and avoid exaggerating the number of clergy who lost their posts.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the vestment controversy identified, e.g. some Protestant clergy refused to wear the surplice and other clerical dress required by the settlement / Elizabeth ordered Archbishop Parker to enforce uniformity in 1565 / Parker issued the Advertisements in 1566 / 37 London clergy refused to conform and were suspended in 1566 / leading Puritans at Oxford, Thomas Sampson and Laurence Humphrey, refused to wear vestments / it led to a war of pamphlets and to some Puritans worshipping separately
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Many Puritan clergy refused to wear the surplice (1), because they saw it as 'popish' dress left over from the Catholic priesthood (1). / In January 1565 Elizabeth ordered Archbishop Parker to make the clergy obey the rules (1), because practices varied from parish to parish (1). / Parker issued his Advertisements in 1566 (1), which required every minister to wear a surplice when leading services in a parish church (1). / In March 1566 the London clergy were summoned to Lambeth Palace (1), and 37 who would not promise to wear the vestments were suspended (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for refusal: they saw vestments as signs of popery and believed a minister should not be set apart from his congregation like a Catholic priest; for Elizabeth's order: her letter of January 1565 demanded uniformity, as Supreme Governor she believed she could decide ceremonies; for the Advertisements: the surplice in parish churches, the cope in cathedrals at communion, kneeling at communion and new preaching licences; Elizabeth did not formally approve them, so Parker issued them on his own authority; for the 37: they were given three months to conform or lose their posts, and they were about a third of the London clergy summoned; for Oxford: Sampson was deprived as Dean of Christ Church in 1565, while Humphrey kept his post as President of Magdalen College; for the pamphlets: Robert Crowley wrote against vestments; for separation: in June 1567 about 100 people were found worshipping secretly at Plumbers' Hall in London
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or general comments such as 'people argued about clothes'. Do not credit the crucifix controversy of 1559-60 as part of this dispute. Do not credit claims that hundreds or thousands of clergy were dismissed: the best-known figure is 37 in London (accept 'about a third of the London clergy'). Accept 'vestiarian controversy'. Accept 1565 or 1566 for the dispute as a whole.