Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Robert Dudley's acceptance of the title of Governor-General of the Netherlands in 1586.
Model answer
Dudley accepted the title in January 1586 without asking Elizabeth, even though she had told him not to take such power. Elizabeth was furious and sent Sir Thomas Heneage to the Netherlands to rebuke him and order him to give it up.
Explanation
A strong answer names one feature, such as Dudley's disobedience or Elizabeth's reaction, and develops it with a precise detail like the mission of Sir Thomas Heneage. A common mistake is to say that Elizabeth gave Dudley the title or wanted to rule the Netherlands herself, when she had refused the sovereignty.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of Dudley's acceptance of the title identified, e.g. the States General offered him the title and he accepted it in January 1586 / it gave him supreme authority over the war and the government of the rebel provinces / he accepted it without Elizabeth's permission and against her orders / Elizabeth was furious / Elizabeth sent Sir Thomas Heneage to rebuke him / she ordered him to resign the title publicly / it made it look as if Elizabeth was claiming to rule Philip II's provinces / it weakened Dudley's authority with the Dutch
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Dudley accepted the title without asking Elizabeth first (1), even though she had told him not to take such authority (1). / Elizabeth was furious (1). She sent Sir Thomas Heneage to the Netherlands with a letter accusing Dudley of breaking her commandment in a cause that touched her honour (1). / The title gave Dudley supreme authority over the rebel provinces (1), with the same power as earlier governors of the Netherlands (1). / It seemed to show that Elizabeth wanted to rule the Netherlands (1), even though her published declaration of 1585 had said she did not (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the offer: a deputation from the States General offered it on 1 January 1586 and he was installed on 25 January; for the authority: 'absolute authority' in warfare and in government and justice, with power to collect money for the war; for disobedience: Elizabeth had refused the sovereignty and told him not to take such power, and he delayed sending William Davison to explain; for her anger: her letter of February 1586 said that a man she had raised up had broken her commandment; for Heneage: he reached the Netherlands in March 1586 with orders that Dudley should resign as publicly as he had accepted; for her reputation: her declaration of October 1585 had said she did not seek to rule the Netherlands, so she feared other rulers would think her dishonest; for the outcome: Dudley kept the title, but his credit with the Dutch was damaged; for Spain: it looked like a direct challenge to Philip II's rights as ruler of the Netherlands
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or general comments such as 'Elizabeth was not happy'. Do not credit claims that Elizabeth gave Dudley the title, that he became King of the Netherlands, or that he was arrested or executed. Dudley was already Elizabeth's lieutenant-general of the English army; the Governor-General title was a separate post given by the Dutch, and answers that mix the two up should not gain the supporting mark. Accept January or early February 1586 for his acceptance (continental dates were ten days ahead of English ones).