Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Richard Hakluyt's 'Discourse of Western Planting' (1584).
Model answer
The Discourse of Western Planting was written by Richard Hakluyt at Raleigh's request to persuade Elizabeth to support colonies in North America. It argued, for example, that a colony would give work to England's many unemployed people, who could cut timber and make pitch and tar for ships.
Explanation
A strong answer names one feature of the Discourse, such as its purpose or one of its arguments, and supports it with a precise detail, such as its presentation to the queen in 1584 or the claim that colonies would employ the idle poor. Vague comments that it 'praised colonies' are not specific enough for full marks.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the Discourse identified, e.g. it was written by Richard Hakluyt at Raleigh's request / its purpose was to persuade Elizabeth to support English colonies in North America / it was presented to the queen in 1584 / it was a private manuscript, not a printed book / it argued that colonies would spread the Protestant religion / it argued that colonies would provide new markets for English goods, especially cloth / it argued that colonies would give work to England's unemployed and idle people / it argued that colonies would help England to restrain or attack Spain / it claimed that England had a better right to North America than Spain
Award one mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Hakluyt wrote it at Raleigh's request (1) to persuade Elizabeth to make colonisation a royal project, and presented it to her in October 1584 (1). / It argued that a colony would give work to England's many idle and unemployed people (1). They could cut timber, make pitch and tar for ships and work in mines, instead of filling the prisons (1). / It argued that colonies would weaken Spain (1). It said a colony would be a 'greate bridle' to the King of Spain's Indies, because ships based there could attack Spanish shipping (1). / It argued that colonies would spread the Protestant religion (1). Its first chapter said that the queen, as the leading Protestant ruler, had a duty to spread the gospel (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for its writing: Hakluyt wrote it between July and September 1584 at the 'requeste and direction' of Raleigh, in 21 chapters; for the queen: he presented it to Elizabeth on 5 October 1584, but she did not take on colonisation as a royal project; for the manuscript: it was not printed until 1877; for religion: Protestant England should spread the gospel to the Indigenous peoples, as Catholic Spain claimed to do; for trade: English trade in Spain's lands had become 'beggerly or daungerous', so new markets were needed for cloth; for work: England had grown more populous and its prisons were full of idle people who could be employed in a colony; for Spain: bases in America could be used against Spain's treasure fleets and its fishing fleets at Newfoundland; for England's title: it answered the Pope's grant of the Indies to Spain; for other benefits: more ships and sailors for the navy, more customs revenue for the queen, and a search for a Northwest Passage to Asia
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or general comments such as 'it said colonies were good for England'. Do not credit claims that it was a printed book that persuaded the public (it stayed in manuscript), that Hakluyt sailed to Virginia, or that it was written after the 1585 colony. Do not confuse it with Hakluyt's later printed collection of voyages, The Principal Navigations (1589).