Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/12

Never Let Me Go (Kazuo Ishiguro)

Practise 30 exam-style questions on Never Let Me Go (Kazuo Ishiguro) for OCR GCSE English Literature (Component 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 30 questions
  • 20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

20 marks

Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro

You should spend about 30 minutes on this question.

Explore another moment in Never Let Me Go, not the team-picking in Chapter 1, where a character is humiliated in front of others. [20]

Model answer

A painful moment of humiliation comes in Chapter 16, in a ruined churchyard. Unlike a playground joke, it happens between three close friends, and Ishiguro makes it more wounding because the humiliation depends on a betrayal.

The moment is carefully prepared. Earlier in the chapter Tommy has shown Kathy the imaginary animals he has been drawing in secret, and she has admired them. Then, in a conversation with Ruth, Kathy laughs with her about the animals. In the churchyard Ruth turns that private laughter into a weapon: she tells Tommy that his animals are a joke and that Kathy thinks so too. Ruth's cruelty lies in its precision. She does not simply mock Tommy's work; she takes away the one person whose admiration he trusted, and she does it with Kathy standing there, so that both of them are exposed.

The moment's force comes from Kathy's silence. She does not deny what Ruth says, and she explains it in one short sentence: "Something in me just gave up." The verb "gave up" suggests exhaustion rather than malice, as if Kathy has been resisting Ruth for so long that she cannot do it any more. The vague "Something in me" is typical of Kathy's narration: she describes her own failure as though it happened to her, which makes her sound both honest and evasive. Her silence becomes a second humiliation, because it leaves Tommy no reason to doubt that the friend who praised his drawings was laughing at them too.

The setting adds to the effect. A ruined churchyard is a place of old graves and endings, and in a novel about lives that end early it hints that something between the three friends is also dying. The moment ends with Kathy walking away, which leaves the damage unrepaired; it is still unrepaired when she leaves the Cottages in the next chapter.

Ishiguro has shown Tommy humiliated before. In the Juniors, after the elephant painting, there were "sneers and giggles all around him", and in Chapter 13 Ruth humiliates him in front of Chrissie and Rodney for admitting that he has never heard of deferrals. But the churchyard is different, because the humiliation is built from laughter that Kathy really shared, and Kathy's narration admits it. The pattern is only resolved in Chapter 19, when Ruth admits that she kept Kathy and Tommy apart.

Through this moment Ishiguro shows that humiliation is most powerful when it uses intimacy as its tool. The cruelty is Ruth's, but the silence is Kathy's, and the flat sentence "Something in me just gave up." captures how people can fail each other at the moment that matters most.

Explanation

A top-level answer explores one moment of humiliation outside the team-picking, such as Ruth's mockery of Tommy's animals in the churchyard in Chapter 16, and analyses how Ishiguro presents the cruelty, the victim's position and the part played by onlookers through Kathy's narration. Common errors are writing about the team-picking in Chapter 1, which the question excludes, retelling the plot of the Cottages chapters, and misreporting what happens: in the churchyard Kathy does not agree with Ruth aloud, she fails to deny what Ruth says.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks). AO1 and AO2 are equally weighted (OCR, J352/01 Section A part (b)). The response is marked holistically.
    Level 6 (18-20 marks): Sustained critical style in an informed personal response to both text and task.
    - Coherent critical style sustained in an informed personal response to the text, showing consistently perceptive understanding (AO1)
    - Textual references and quotations are precise, pertinent and skilfully interwoven (AO1)
    - Detailed and well-developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Consistently effective use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    Level 5 (15-17 marks): Convincing critical style in a well-developed personal response to both text and task.
    - Convincing critical style maintained in a well-developed personal response to the text, showing some insightful understanding (AO1)
    - Textual references and quotations are well-selected and fully integrated (AO1)
    - Thoughtful and developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Good use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    Level 4 (11-14 marks): Credible critical style in a detailed personal response to both text and task.
    - Some critical style demonstrated in a detailed personal response to the text, showing clear understanding (AO1)
    - Relevant textual references and quotations are selected to support the response (AO1)
    - Some analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Competent use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    Level 3 (7-10 marks), Level 2 (4-6 marks), Level 1 (1-3 marks), 0 marks: OCR's descriptors for these are given word for word in the comments, straight after the limits on the mark.

    Max 0 if the answer writes only about the team-picking in Chapter 1, the moment the question excludes (OCR: where a candidate has used only the part (a) extract, "the mark awarded should be 0"). References to that moment are ignored; only references to the rest of the novel are credited.

    OCR's level descriptors (continued): Level 3 (7-10 marks): A reasonably developed personal response to both text and task.
    - Reasonably detailed personal response to the text showing understanding (AO1)
    - Some use of relevant textual references and quotations to support the response (AO1)
    - Reasonable explanation of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Some use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): A straightforward personal response to both text and task.
    - Begins to develop a straightforward personal response to the text showing some understanding (AO1)
    - Some relevant support from the text (AO1)
    - Simple comments on writer's use of language, form or structure (AO2)
    - Limited use of subject terminology (AO2)
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A basic response to both text and task.
    - Makes a few relevant comments about the text (AO1)
    - Makes limited references to the text (AO1)
    - A little awareness of language, form or structure (AO2)
    - Very little use of subject terminology (AO2)
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Indicative content (OCR: "Please bear in mind that other content may be equally valid and should be credited."):
    AO1:
    - suitable moments: Ruth tells Tommy in the churchyard that his animals are a joke (Chapter 16); Ruth mocks Tommy over deferrals in the cafe (Chapter 13); the teasing after the elephant (Chapter 2); the unzipping joke (Chapter 7); Kathy's outburst at Tommy's fake laughter (Chapter 9)
    - who humiliates whom, who watches, and the part played by silence
    - the effect on the relationships between Kathy, Ruth and Tommy
    AO2:
    - Kathy's narration of her own failure ("Something in me just gave up.")
    - reported speech, and settings such as the ruined churchyard
    - structure: patterns of humiliation and later repair (Ruth's confession, Chapter 19)

Question 2

20 marks

Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro

You should spend about 30 minutes on this question.

Explore another moment in Never Let Me Go, not Kathy's outburst at Tommy in Chapter 9, where characters seem childlike. [20]

Model answer

A moment in which characters seem strikingly childlike comes in Chapter 19, when Kathy leads Ruth and Tommy through the woods towards the stranded boat. By now Ruth and Tommy are donors and Kathy is Ruth's carer, yet Ishiguro presents the three adults almost as children again, and the effect is both tender and painful.

The childlike quality appears as soon as they leave the car. While Kathy studies her sheet of directions, she becomes "suddenly conscious" of Ruth and Tommy behind her, not talking, "waiting almost like children" for her to show them "which way to go". The simile makes Kathy the guardian and the other two her pupils. It also reverses their old roles: at Hailsham Ruth was the leader, but now she stands silently waiting for instructions. The word "almost" keeps the comparison gentle, as though Kathy is reluctant to say it outright.

The barbed wire fence brings the moment to a crisis. Ruth stops abruptly and turns on Kathy: "You didn't say anything about this." The complaint sounds like a child's accusation against a grown-up who has not warned her. Kathy's reply is the calm reassurance of an adult to a frightened child: "We can go under it", she says; they only have to "hold it for each other". Ruth's fear seems out of proportion to the obstacle, but Ishiguro gives it a real cause. It is here that Tommy seems to become aware "just how frail she was", and the childlike behaviour becomes a sign of what her donations have done to her.

Kathy's narration adds guilt to the tenderness. She thinks that she and Tommy both remembered the car journey, when "we'd more or less ganged up on her", and that this made them go to her "almost as an instinct". Kathy takes an arm and Tommy supports her elbow, and they guide her through, as adults might guide a small child. Afterwards Ruth makes light of it in simple, slightly awkward words: "I'm sometimes not so clever at it." Tommy is "looking sheepish", and he turns to Kathy for direction: "Is that right, Kath?"

Ishiguro's choice to show the three as children has a wider meaning. The students were sheltered at Hailsham and never given ordinary adult lives, and here, as adults, they still look to someone to tell them which way to go. The darkening woods, where "the ground became more and more marshy", give the walk the feel of a fairy-tale journey, but one leading to a beached boat rather than a happy ending.

The moment contrasts with the cruelty of the Juniors, where Tommy's childish art brought "sneers and giggles all around him". There, being childlike meant being mocked; here it means being vulnerable, and it draws out kindness. Through this walk Ishiguro presents childlike behaviour as the result of the characters' history: people who were treated as children for so long, and whose bodies are now failing, become children again when the world asks too much of them.

Explanation

A top-level answer explores one moment where characters seem childlike, such as the walk to the boat in Chapter 19, and analyses how Ishiguro uses simile, dialogue and Kathy's narration to link that childlikeness to the characters' history and frailty. Common errors are writing about Kathy's outburst at Tommy in Chapter 9, which the question excludes, listing childish actions without analysing their effect, and ignoring how the roles between the three friends have changed.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks). AO1 and AO2 are equally weighted (OCR, J352/01 Section A part (b)). The response is marked holistically.
    Level 6 (18-20 marks): Sustained critical style in an informed personal response to both text and task.
    - Coherent critical style sustained in an informed personal response to the text, showing consistently perceptive understanding (AO1)
    - Textual references and quotations are precise, pertinent and skilfully interwoven (AO1)
    - Detailed and well-developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Consistently effective use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    Level 5 (15-17 marks): Convincing critical style in a well-developed personal response to both text and task.
    - Convincing critical style maintained in a well-developed personal response to the text, showing some insightful understanding (AO1)
    - Textual references and quotations are well-selected and fully integrated (AO1)
    - Thoughtful and developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Good use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    Level 4 (11-14 marks): Credible critical style in a detailed personal response to both text and task.
    - Some critical style demonstrated in a detailed personal response to the text, showing clear understanding (AO1)
    - Relevant textual references and quotations are selected to support the response (AO1)
    - Some analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Competent use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    Level 3 (7-10 marks), Level 2 (4-6 marks), Level 1 (1-3 marks), 0 marks: OCR's descriptors for these are given word for word in the comments, straight after the limits on the mark.

    Max 0 if the answer writes only about Kathy's outburst at Tommy in Chapter 9, the moment the question excludes (OCR: where a candidate has used only the part (a) extract, "the mark awarded should be 0"). References to that moment are ignored; only references to the rest of the novel are credited.

    OCR's level descriptors (continued): Level 3 (7-10 marks): A reasonably developed personal response to both text and task.
    - Reasonably detailed personal response to the text showing understanding (AO1)
    - Some use of relevant textual references and quotations to support the response (AO1)
    - Reasonable explanation of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Some use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): A straightforward personal response to both text and task.
    - Begins to develop a straightforward personal response to the text showing some understanding (AO1)
    - Some relevant support from the text (AO1)
    - Simple comments on writer's use of language, form or structure (AO2)
    - Limited use of subject terminology (AO2)
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A basic response to both text and task.
    - Makes a few relevant comments about the text (AO1)
    - Makes limited references to the text (AO1)
    - A little awareness of language, form or structure (AO2)
    - Very little use of subject terminology (AO2)
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Indicative content (OCR: "Please bear in mind that other content may be equally valid and should be credited."):
    AO1:
    - suitable moments: the walk to the boat and the barbed wire (Chapter 19); Tommy's panic at the pond (Chapter 3); the unzipping joke (Chapter 7); Ruth's imaginary horses (Chapter 4); the Hailsham group huddling together at the Cottages (Chapter 10)
    - childlikeness as innocence, dependence or vulnerability
    - how the roles between Kathy, Ruth and Tommy change
    AO2:
    - simile ("waiting almost like children")
    - dialogue: Ruth's complaint and Tommy's "Is that right, Kath?"
    - setting (the darkening woods) and retrospective narration

Question 3

20 marks

Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro and The Fire Engine by Alan Gatesby (fictional)

Read the two extracts below and then answer the question. You should spend about 45 minutes on this question. Focus only on the two extracts rather than referring to the rest of your studied text.

Compare how mixed feelings are presented in these two extracts. You should consider:
- the situations and experiences faced by the characters
- how the characters react to these situations and experiences
- how the writers' use of language and techniques creates effects. [20]

Extract 1 from: Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro
This extract is described here, not printed: use your own copy of the novel. Look at the part of Chapter 15 (Part Two) where Kathy and Tommy look for a copy of Kathy's lost tape, from the moment Tommy tells her that he has looked for it in Woolworths until he buys the copy that she finds in a second-hand shop.

Extract 2 from: The Fire Engine by Alan Gatesby. Alan Gatesby is a fictional writer: this passage was written for this course.

In this extract, set in the North East of England in the 1990s, fifteen-year-old Leanne has been going with her grandfather, who grew up in Sunderland in the 1930s, to toy fairs where collectors buy and sell old toys. In the 1930s many men in Sunderland lost their jobs when the shipyards closed.

Grandad had been to every toy fair in the North East that spring, and I had been to most of them with him, because Mam said he wasn't to go on the buses on his own any more. They were all the same: a leisure centre or a church hall, trestle tables, men in anoraks with magnifying glasses round their necks, and boxes of tin soldiers that smelt of other people's lofts.

He never said what he was looking for. He walked the rows with his hands behind his back like a policeman, stopping now and then to lift something and set it down again, very carefully, as if it might be asleep.

At Houghton, in the second week of May, he stopped and did not move on.

It was a fire engine, about as long as my hand, its red paint worn through to the silver along the sides, a ladder folded on its back and a little brass bell behind the driver. The man behind the table said it was pre-war, German, clockwork, key missing, fifteen pounds to anybody else.

Grandad picked it up. He turned it over and looked underneath, and then he ran his thumb along the ladder, slowly, the way you'd test the edge of a knife.

"Ours had a dent here," he said, to nobody. "Our Ronnie stood on it."

I had never heard of a Ronnie.

"We had it one Christmas. Nineteen thirty-two. Then Dad was finished at the yard, and in the February Mam sold it, with the clock and the good chairs. I came home from school and it had gone. She let the rag-and-bone man have it for a shilling." He tapped the bell with his fingernail and it made a sound like a spoon against a cup. "I never said anything. You didn't, then."

The man said he could do it for twelve.

Grandad paid him in coins, counting them out of his purse one at a time, and the man wrapped the fire engine in a sheet of newspaper. On the bus home Grandad sat with the parcel on his knees and both hands on top of it.

"Is it the same one?" I said, though I knew it couldn't be.

"No," he said. He was looking straight ahead, past the driver, at the road coming towards us in the rain. "It's the wrong one. It's exactly right."

Glossary: clockwork: worked by a spring wound up with a key; the yard: the shipyard; rag-and-bone man: a man who went round the streets with a cart, buying unwanted goods for very little; shilling: a coin worth 5p

Model answer

Both extracts present a moment that ought to be simply happy, when something lost long ago turns up again, yet neither writer lets the recovery be pure joy. In Never Let Me Go, Kathy finds, in a second-hand shop in Norfolk, a copy of the tape she lost at Hailsham, and Tommy, who has already looked for it in Woolworths, buys it for her. In The Fire Engine, Grandad finds at a toy fair a fire engine like the one his mother sold when he was a boy. In both, pleasure is mixed with doubt, loss and regret, and both writers show these mixed feelings mostly through what the characters do not say.

The situations explain why the feelings are so tangled. Grandad's fire engine was taken from him by poverty: "Dad was finished at the yard", and in the February his mother sold it, "with the clock and the good chairs", to the rag-and-bone man "for a shilling". The man behind the table asks "fifteen pounds to anybody else", so a toy his family could not afford to keep is now a collector's item, and finding it brings back the hardship of 1930s Sunderland. Kathy and Tommy grew up at Hailsham, where students' possessions came from the Sales and the Exchanges, and the tape is a copy of one bought at a Sale and lost years before. As young adults they are hunting through the cast-offs of an ordinary Norfolk town, part of an outside world they are only beginning to explore. In both extracts the past is on sale among other people's old belongings, from tin soldiers "that smelt of other people's lofts" to the musty bric-a-brac of the Norfolk shops.

The searches carry different mixtures of feeling. Grandad's is purposeful but silent: he "never said what he was looking for", walks the rows "like a policeman", and lifts things and sets them down "as if it might be asleep", a simile that shows his tenderness. Leanne's own feelings begin cooler: she goes out of duty, because Mam has said he is not to go on the buses on his own, and finds the fairs "all the same", so what follows takes her by surprise. Kathy and Tommy's search, by contrast, becomes a pleasure in itself. Kathy admits that Judy Bridgewater had "more or less slipped from our minds", because they were simply enjoying browsing together. Tommy's earlier search in Woolworths shows how much he cares about her, so the hunt becomes happy time spent together rather than a task.

The moment of finding is where the mixed feelings are strongest, and both writers slow the action to show it. Grandad "stopped and did not move on", then runs his thumb along the ladder "the way you'd test the edge of a knife": the simile suggests that touching the memory may hurt. Kathy, who has been exclaiming at other finds, says "I didn't exclaim" and stands quite still. She is "unsure whether or not I was delighted", and for a moment "it even felt like a mistake". Ishiguro's hesitant, retrospective narration, with phrases such as "in all honesty", lets Kathy examine a feeling she cannot quite name; perhaps finding the tape means the happy search is over. Gatesby is more direct, giving Grandad a paradox that holds both feelings at once: "It's the wrong one. It's exactly right."

Each writer also shows mixed feelings in the companion. Tommy is sorry that he did not spot the tape first, yet he buys it for Kathy all the same, so his disappointment gives way to generosity. Leanne asks, "Is it the same one?", "though I knew it couldn't be", a question that is both curious and tactful. She also learns of a Ronnie she "had never heard of", which shows how much of his childhood Grandad has kept hidden. "I never said anything. You didn't, then," he explains, linking his silence to a generation that bore hardship without complaint.

Neither ending resolves these feelings. Grandad sits on the bus "with the parcel on his knees and both hands on top of it", protecting it as if it might be taken again, while he looks at "the road coming towards us in the rain", an image of sadness set beside the comfort of the parcel. Ishiguro's moment ends with Tommy paying for the copy, a quiet gift that expresses what neither of them says aloud.

Overall, both writers present the recovery of a lost object as bittersweet. Gatesby states the contradiction openly in Grandad's final words, while Ishiguro lets Kathy's careful, uncertain narration reveal it, so that in both extracts the joy of finding cannot be separated from the memory of losing.

Explanation

A top-level answer compares the mixed feelings throughout - in the two searches, at the moment of finding and in the companions' responses - and draws AO3 inferences from both extracts, such as the poverty of 1930s Sunderland and what a Sale-bought tape means to young people who grew up at Hailsham. Common errors are writing about one extract and then the other, treating either find as simply happy, and bringing in earlier scenes at Hailsham in detail, which go beyond the extract.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks). AO1 and AO3 are the equally dominant assessment objectives, with AO2 (OCR, J352/01 Section A part (a)). The response is marked holistically.
    Level 6 (18-20 marks): Sustained critical style in an informed personal response to both text and task.
    - Perceptive and sensitive understanding of context and how it informs evaluation of the text (AO3)
    - Coherent critical style sustained in an informed personal response to the text, showing consistently perceptive understanding (AO1)
    - Textual references and quotations are precise, pertinent and skilfully interwoven (AO1)
    - Detailed and well-developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Consistently effective use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    - Achieves a sustained, interwoven comparison of texts
    Level 5 (15-17 marks): Convincing critical style in a well-developed personal response to both text and task.
    - Convincing understanding of context which informs the response to the text (AO3)
    - Convincing critical style maintained in a well-developed personal response to the text, showing some insightful understanding (AO1)
    - Textual references and quotations are well-selected and fully integrated (AO1)
    - Thoughtful and developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Good use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    - Achieves a sustained comparison of texts
    Level 4 (11-14 marks), Level 3 (7-10 marks), Level 2 (4-6 marks), Level 1 (1-3 marks), 0 marks: OCR's descriptors for these are given word for word in the comments, straight after the limits on the mark.

    Max 10 if the answer is about only one of the two extracts (OCR: it "cannot move beyond Level 3").

    OCR's level descriptors (continued): Level 4 (11-14 marks): Credible critical style in a detailed personal response to both text and task.
    - Clear understanding of context which informs the response to the text (AO3)
    - Some critical style demonstrated in a detailed personal response to the text, showing clear understanding (AO1)
    - Relevant textual references and quotations are selected to support the response (AO1)
    - Some analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Competent use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    - Develops some key points of comparison between texts
    Level 3 (7-10 marks): A reasonably developed personal response to both text and task.
    - Some relevant comments about context inform the response to the text (AO3)
    - Reasonably detailed personal response to the text showing understanding (AO1)
    - Some use of relevant textual references and quotations to support the response (AO1)
    - Reasonable explanation of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Some use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    - Makes some explicit, relevant comparisons between texts
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): A straightforward personal response to both text and task.
    - Some awareness of context, which may be implied (AO3)
    - Begins to develop a straightforward personal response to the text showing some understanding (AO1)
    - Some relevant support from the text (AO1)
    - Simple comments on writer's use of language, form or structure (AO2)
    - Limited use of subject terminology (AO2)
    - Some identification of key links between texts
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A basic response to both text and task.
    - A little awareness of context implied, related to the text (AO3)
    - Makes a few relevant comments about the text (AO1)
    - Makes limited references to the text (AO1)
    - A little awareness of language, form or structure (AO2)
    - Very little use of subject terminology (AO2)
    - Limited, if any, attempt to make obvious links between texts
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Extract 1 is described, not printed: credit accurate reference to this part of the novel (quotation from memory or close paraphrase) as reference to it. Only the two extracts are compared: material from elsewhere in the set text earns no extra credit. Extract 2 is by a fictional writer: its context is inferred from the extract and its introduction.

    Indicative content (OCR: "Please bear in mind that other content may be equally valid and should be credited."):
    AO3:
    - Extract 1: a tape bought at a Hailsham Sale and lost years before; two young adults from Hailsham in a Norfolk town's second-hand shops
    - Extract 2: 1930s Sunderland, when the shipyards closed, and the 1990s North East; a toy sold for a shilling, now a collector's item; a generation that did not complain
    - age: an old man and his teenage granddaughter; two friends who grew up together
    AO1:
    - in both a lost object is found again as a copy, bringing pleasure and pain together
    - the searches: Grandad's silent purpose and Leanne's duty; Kathy and Tommy's shared search, a pleasure in itself
    - the finding: Kathy "unsure whether or not I was delighted"; Grandad's paradox "It's the wrong one. It's exactly right."
    - the companions: Tommy sorry not to have found the tape first, yet buying it; Leanne's tactful question and the Ronnie she never knew of
    AO2:
    - Ishiguro: Kathy's hesitant retrospective narration ("in all honesty"), the stillness after the plain sentence that announces the find
    - Gatesby: tactile detail (the thumb along the ladder, the bell), short paragraphs and dialogue, the closing paradox, the road in the rain
    - both: feelings held back rather than stated

Question 4

20 marks

Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro and The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton

Read the two extracts below and then answer the question. You should spend about 45 minutes on this question. Focus only on the two extracts rather than referring to the rest of your studied text.

Compare how characters accept being separated from someone they love in these two extracts. You should consider:
- the situations and experiences faced by the characters
- how the characters react to these situations and experiences
- how the writers' use of language and techniques creates effects. [20]

Extract 1 from: Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro
This extract is described here, not printed: use your own copy of the novel. Look at the part of Chapter 23 (Part Three) where Tommy tells Kathy about a river, from the moment he says that he keeps thinking about a river somewhere until he says that in the end they cannot stay together forever.

Extract 2 from: The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton (a novel first published in 1920).

In this extract, set in Paris in the early 1900s, Newland Archer, a fifty-seven-year-old widower from New York, is travelling with his grown-up son, Dallas, who has arranged for them both to call on Madame Ellen Olenska, the woman Archer loved but gave up nearly thirty years earlier when he stayed with his wife, Dallas's mother. They have just found the building where she lives, and Dallas has learned that her flat is the one on the fifth floor with awnings (canvas sun-blinds) over its balcony.

The father glanced away at an empty bench under the trees.

"I believe I'll sit there a moment," he said.

"Why--aren't you well?" his son exclaimed.

"Oh, perfectly. But I should like you, please, to go up without me."

Dallas paused before him, visibly bewildered. "But, I say, Dad: do you mean you won't come up at all?"

"I don't know," said Archer slowly.

"If you don't she won't understand."

"Go, my boy; perhaps I shall follow you."

Dallas gave him a long look through the twilight.

"But what on earth shall I say?"

"My dear fellow, don't you always know what to say?" his father rejoined with a smile.

"Very well. I shall say you're old-fashioned, and prefer walking up the five flights because you don't like lifts."

His father smiled again. "Say I'm old-fashioned: that's enough."

Dallas looked at him again, and then, with an incredulous gesture, passed out of sight under the vaulted doorway.

Archer sat down on the bench and continued to gaze at the awninged balcony. He calculated the time it would take his son to be carried up in the lift to the fifth floor, to ring the bell, and be admitted to the hall, and then ushered into the drawing-room. He pictured Dallas entering that room with his quick assured step and his delightful smile, and wondered if the people were right who said that his boy "took after him."

Then he tried to see the persons already in the room--for probably at that sociable hour there would be more than one--and among them a dark lady, pale and dark, who would look up quickly, half rise, and hold out a long thin hand with three rings on it.... He thought she would be sitting in a sofa-corner near the fire, with azaleas banked behind her on a table.

"It's more real to me here than if I went up," he suddenly heard himself say; and the fear lest that last shadow of reality should lose its edge kept him rooted to his seat as the minutes succeeded each other.

He sat for a long time on the bench in the thickening dusk, his eyes never turning from the balcony. At length a light shone through the windows, and a moment later a man-servant came out on the balcony, drew up the awnings, and closed the shutters.

At that, as if it had been the signal he waited for, Newland Archer got up slowly and walked back alone to his hotel.

Model answer

Both extracts show a man who accepts that he must be separated from the woman he loves, and both men express that acceptance through an image rather than an argument. Newland Archer, sitting on a bench in Paris, decides not to climb the stairs to Ellen Olenska's flat; Tommy, talking to Kathy near the end of the novel, describes two people in a river who cannot hold on to each other. But the separations differ: Archer chooses his, while Tommy accepts one that is forced on him.

The situations are shaped by time. Archer is fifty-seven, a widower who gave Ellen up nearly thirty years earlier when he stayed with his wife, and the visit his son has arranged is a chance to see her again after a whole lifetime apart. Tommy's situation is the reverse. He can say to Kathy that "we've loved each other all our lives", yet they have had very little time as a couple, and he is a donor whose time is running out. Archer has had too much time apart; Tommy has had too little time together.

The images at the heart of each extract express acceptance in different ways. Archer imagines the room upstairs in loving detail: Ellen "pale and dark", with "a long thin hand with three rings on it", sitting "in a sofa-corner near the fire, with azaleas banked behind her". Then he hears himself say, "It's more real to me here than if I went up". For him the imagined Ellen is safer than the real one, and his acceptance is a choice to keep a picture intact. Tommy's image is not of a person but of a force. "I keep thinking about this river somewhere", he says, with two people in it trying to hold on, and then explains why they cannot: "The current's too strong." The current is no one's fault; it is simply stronger than they are. The conclusion follows with terrible simplicity: "They've got to let go, drift apart."

The language of the two men is equally restrained. Wharton's sentences are long and measured, and Archer's feelings show in small actions: he "calculated the time it would take his son" to reach the flat, he gazes at the "awninged balcony", and he waits "in the thickening dusk". Tommy's speech is simple and colloquial, built from short clauses. The plainness makes his acceptance sound tender rather than bitter. He acknowledges the love, "we've loved each other all our lives", and then turns, with "But in the end", to its limit: "we can't stay together forever." The speech moves from image to love to acceptance, so that the river becomes a way of explaining their own situation.

The reactions of those around them differ. Archer's son is "visibly bewildered" and goes in with "an incredulous gesture"; he belongs to a younger, more open generation and cannot understand a man who will not go up. Kathy is the person Tommy is speaking to, so the reader feels the separation as something said to the one who will be left behind. The contrast is striking: Archer leaves Ellen waiting, unaware; Tommy prepares Kathy for losing him.

The endings complete the acceptance. Archer waits until "a man-servant came out on the balcony, drew up the awnings, and closed the shutters", and then, "as if it had been the signal he waited for", walks "back alone to his hotel". The closing shutters are a final image of the past being shut away. Tommy's extract ends with "we can't stay together forever", a sentence that closes the possibility of a shared future just as firmly.

The contexts explain these choices. Archer belongs to wealthy New York society, where respectability and duty to marriage once outweighed passion, and his son's freer generation shows how much has changed. Tommy belongs to a world in which donors' lives are set by others, and his acceptance reflects how deeply the students have learned not to fight what they cannot change.

Overall, Wharton presents separation as a choice made to preserve a cherished image, and the extract ends with Archer walking away alone. Ishiguro presents separation as something imposed by forces stronger than love, and Tommy's river image lets him accept it with gentleness. In both, the most moving thing is not the parting but the calm with which it is accepted.

Explanation

A top-level answer compares the two men's acceptance of separation, the images they use and the reactions of those around them throughout, and draws AO3 inferences from both extracts, such as the duty to marriage in Archer's world and Tommy's position as a donor. Common errors are writing about one extract and then the other, treating the river as a real place rather than a metaphor, and bringing in what happens at the end of the novel, which goes beyond the extract.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks). AO1 and AO3 are the equally dominant assessment objectives, with AO2 (OCR, J352/01 Section A part (a)). The response is marked holistically.
    Level 6 (18-20 marks): Sustained critical style in an informed personal response to both text and task.
    - Perceptive and sensitive understanding of context and how it informs evaluation of the text (AO3)
    - Coherent critical style sustained in an informed personal response to the text, showing consistently perceptive understanding (AO1)
    - Textual references and quotations are precise, pertinent and skilfully interwoven (AO1)
    - Detailed and well-developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Consistently effective use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    - Achieves a sustained, interwoven comparison of texts
    Level 5 (15-17 marks): Convincing critical style in a well-developed personal response to both text and task.
    - Convincing understanding of context which informs the response to the text (AO3)
    - Convincing critical style maintained in a well-developed personal response to the text, showing some insightful understanding (AO1)
    - Textual references and quotations are well-selected and fully integrated (AO1)
    - Thoughtful and developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Good use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    - Achieves a sustained comparison of texts
    Level 4 (11-14 marks), Level 3 (7-10 marks), Level 2 (4-6 marks), Level 1 (1-3 marks), 0 marks: OCR's descriptors for these are given word for word in the comments, straight after the limits on the mark.

    Max 10 if the answer is about only one of the two extracts (OCR: it "cannot move beyond Level 3").

    OCR's level descriptors (continued): Level 4 (11-14 marks): Credible critical style in a detailed personal response to both text and task.
    - Clear understanding of context which informs the response to the text (AO3)
    - Some critical style demonstrated in a detailed personal response to the text, showing clear understanding (AO1)
    - Relevant textual references and quotations are selected to support the response (AO1)
    - Some analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Competent use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    - Develops some key points of comparison between texts
    Level 3 (7-10 marks): A reasonably developed personal response to both text and task.
    - Some relevant comments about context inform the response to the text (AO3)
    - Reasonably detailed personal response to the text showing understanding (AO1)
    - Some use of relevant textual references and quotations to support the response (AO1)
    - Reasonable explanation of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
    - Some use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
    - Makes some explicit, relevant comparisons between texts
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): A straightforward personal response to both text and task.
    - Some awareness of context, which may be implied (AO3)
    - Begins to develop a straightforward personal response to the text showing some understanding (AO1)
    - Some relevant support from the text (AO1)
    - Simple comments on writer's use of language, form or structure (AO2)
    - Limited use of subject terminology (AO2)
    - Some identification of key links between texts
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A basic response to both text and task.
    - A little awareness of context implied, related to the text (AO3)
    - Makes a few relevant comments about the text (AO1)
    - Makes limited references to the text (AO1)
    - A little awareness of language, form or structure (AO2)
    - Very little use of subject terminology (AO2)
    - Limited, if any, attempt to make obvious links between texts
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Extract 1 is described, not printed: credit accurate reference to this part of the novel (quotation from memory or close paraphrase) as reference to it. Only the two extracts are compared: material from elsewhere in the set text earns no extra credit.

    Indicative content (OCR: "Please bear in mind that other content may be equally valid and should be credited."):
    AO3:
    - Extract 1: Tommy, a donor who has already made three donations, speaking to Kathy, his carer; a love that began in childhood ("all our lives") and has run out of time
    - Extract 2: a wealthy New York widower of fifty-seven in Paris in the early 1900s; a love given up for duty to his wife; a son of a freer generation
    - age and time: a man who has had a lifetime apart; young adults who have had little time together
    AO1:
    - Archer chooses not to meet Ellen; Tommy accepts that he and Kathy must part
    - both speak calmly about something painful and turn it into an image
    - reactions: Dallas's bewilderment; Archer's wait until the shutters close; Tommy preparing Kathy for the parting
    AO2:
    - Wharton: the imagined room, the balcony and shutters, "It's more real to me here than if I went up"
    - Ishiguro: the extended river metaphor ("The current's too strong.") and plain diction
    - the turn from "we've loved each other all our lives" to "we can't stay together forever"

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.