Question 1
20 marksNever Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro
You should spend about 30 minutes on this question.
Explore another moment in Never Let Me Go, not the team-picking in Chapter 1, where a character is humiliated in front of others. [20]
Model answer
A painful moment of humiliation comes in Chapter 16, in a ruined churchyard. Unlike a playground joke, it happens between three close friends, and Ishiguro makes it more wounding because the humiliation depends on a betrayal.
The moment is carefully prepared. Earlier in the chapter Tommy has shown Kathy the imaginary animals he has been drawing in secret, and she has admired them. Then, in a conversation with Ruth, Kathy laughs with her about the animals. In the churchyard Ruth turns that private laughter into a weapon: she tells Tommy that his animals are a joke and that Kathy thinks so too. Ruth's cruelty lies in its precision. She does not simply mock Tommy's work; she takes away the one person whose admiration he trusted, and she does it with Kathy standing there, so that both of them are exposed.
The moment's force comes from Kathy's silence. She does not deny what Ruth says, and she explains it in one short sentence: "Something in me just gave up." The verb "gave up" suggests exhaustion rather than malice, as if Kathy has been resisting Ruth for so long that she cannot do it any more. The vague "Something in me" is typical of Kathy's narration: she describes her own failure as though it happened to her, which makes her sound both honest and evasive. Her silence becomes a second humiliation, because it leaves Tommy no reason to doubt that the friend who praised his drawings was laughing at them too.
The setting adds to the effect. A ruined churchyard is a place of old graves and endings, and in a novel about lives that end early it hints that something between the three friends is also dying. The moment ends with Kathy walking away, which leaves the damage unrepaired; it is still unrepaired when she leaves the Cottages in the next chapter.
Ishiguro has shown Tommy humiliated before. In the Juniors, after the elephant painting, there were "sneers and giggles all around him", and in Chapter 13 Ruth humiliates him in front of Chrissie and Rodney for admitting that he has never heard of deferrals. But the churchyard is different, because the humiliation is built from laughter that Kathy really shared, and Kathy's narration admits it. The pattern is only resolved in Chapter 19, when Ruth admits that she kept Kathy and Tommy apart.
Through this moment Ishiguro shows that humiliation is most powerful when it uses intimacy as its tool. The cruelty is Ruth's, but the silence is Kathy's, and the flat sentence "Something in me just gave up." captures how people can fail each other at the moment that matters most.
Explanation
A top-level answer explores one moment of humiliation outside the team-picking, such as Ruth's mockery of Tommy's animals in the churchyard in Chapter 16, and analyses how Ishiguro presents the cruelty, the victim's position and the part played by onlookers through Kathy's narration. Common errors are writing about the team-picking in Chapter 1, which the question excludes, retelling the plot of the Cottages chapters, and misreporting what happens: in the churchyard Kathy does not agree with Ruth aloud, she fails to deny what Ruth says.
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO1 and AO2 are equally weighted (OCR, J352/01 Section A part (b)). The response is marked holistically.
Level 6 (18-20 marks): Sustained critical style in an informed personal response to both text and task.
- Coherent critical style sustained in an informed personal response to the text, showing consistently perceptive understanding (AO1)
- Textual references and quotations are precise, pertinent and skilfully interwoven (AO1)
- Detailed and well-developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Consistently effective use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
Level 5 (15-17 marks): Convincing critical style in a well-developed personal response to both text and task.
- Convincing critical style maintained in a well-developed personal response to the text, showing some insightful understanding (AO1)
- Textual references and quotations are well-selected and fully integrated (AO1)
- Thoughtful and developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Good use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
Level 4 (11-14 marks): Credible critical style in a detailed personal response to both text and task.
- Some critical style demonstrated in a detailed personal response to the text, showing clear understanding (AO1)
- Relevant textual references and quotations are selected to support the response (AO1)
- Some analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Competent use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
Level 3 (7-10 marks), Level 2 (4-6 marks), Level 1 (1-3 marks), 0 marks: OCR's descriptors for these are given word for word in the comments, straight after the limits on the mark.Max 0 if the answer writes only about the team-picking in Chapter 1, the moment the question excludes (OCR: where a candidate has used only the part (a) extract, "the mark awarded should be 0"). References to that moment are ignored; only references to the rest of the novel are credited.
OCR's level descriptors (continued): Level 3 (7-10 marks): A reasonably developed personal response to both text and task.
- Reasonably detailed personal response to the text showing understanding (AO1)
- Some use of relevant textual references and quotations to support the response (AO1)
- Reasonable explanation of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Some use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
Level 2 (4-6 marks): A straightforward personal response to both text and task.
- Begins to develop a straightforward personal response to the text showing some understanding (AO1)
- Some relevant support from the text (AO1)
- Simple comments on writer's use of language, form or structure (AO2)
- Limited use of subject terminology (AO2)
Level 1 (1-3 marks): A basic response to both text and task.
- Makes a few relevant comments about the text (AO1)
- Makes limited references to the text (AO1)
- A little awareness of language, form or structure (AO2)
- Very little use of subject terminology (AO2)
0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.Indicative content (OCR: "Please bear in mind that other content may be equally valid and should be credited."):
AO1:
- suitable moments: Ruth tells Tommy in the churchyard that his animals are a joke (Chapter 16); Ruth mocks Tommy over deferrals in the cafe (Chapter 13); the teasing after the elephant (Chapter 2); the unzipping joke (Chapter 7); Kathy's outburst at Tommy's fake laughter (Chapter 9)
- who humiliates whom, who watches, and the part played by silence
- the effect on the relationships between Kathy, Ruth and Tommy
AO2:
- Kathy's narration of her own failure ("Something in me just gave up.")
- reported speech, and settings such as the ruined churchyard
- structure: patterns of humiliation and later repair (Ruth's confession, Chapter 19)