Question 1
40 marksJane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë
You should spend about 45 minutes on this question.
'Helen Burns is too good to be true.' How far do you agree with this view?
Explore at least two moments from the novel to support your ideas. [40]
4 of the 40 marks for this question are for spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of vocabulary and sentence structures (AO4).
Model answer
Helen Burns can certainly seem too good to be true. She endures a flogging without complaint, forgives those who persecute her, speaks in long, polished paragraphs of Christian wisdom and dies young in perfect faith. Yet I think Brontë works hard to stop her becoming a plaster saint: Helen has faults that she admits, feelings she hides and a faith that is her own rather than the school's. She is idealised, but she is also believable, and her goodness is presented as something the reader, like Jane, may admire without being able to share.
The case for the statement is strongest in Chapter 6. Helen fetches "a bundle of twigs" for her own punishment, presents it "with a respectful curtesy", and "Not a tear rose to Burns' eye" as she is struck. The calm verbs and the polite gesture make her seem almost unnaturally patient, while Jane's "unavailing and impotent anger" supplies the human reaction Helen lacks. When the two girls talk, Helen sounds more like a preacher than a schoolgirl: "Life appears to me too short to be spent in nursing animosity or registering wrongs." The balanced phrasing and abstract nouns give her a maturity beyond her years (Jane guesses she is "thirteen or upwards"), and her answer to Jane's wish to strike back is the Gospel itself: "Love your enemies". In Chapter 8, when Miss Scatcherd binds the word "Slattern" round her head "like a phylactery", Helen wears it "patient, unresentful", and the adjectives for her forehead, "large, mild, intelligent, and benign-looking", could describe a saint in a painting.
Brontë's treatment of her death adds to this effect. Helen dies of "consumption, not typhus" in Miss Temple's room, calmly telling Jane that she is going to God, and the narrator closes the episode with the grey marble tablet that bears the word "Resurgam", Latin for 'I shall rise again'. The single word ends her story with a certainty that no other death in the novel receives. Gaskell records that Charlotte's two eldest sisters were consumptive, and that a fever broke out at Cowan Bridge in the spring of 1825 although none of the Brontës caught it; Helen, too, dies of consumption while typhus fills the school, so even her death is closer to remembered fact than to pious invention.
However, there is strong evidence against the statement. Helen herself insists that she is far from perfect: "I am, as Miss Scatcherd said, slatternly; I seldom put, and never keep, things in order; I am careless; I forget rules". The run of short clauses sounds like honest confession rather than false modesty. She daydreams in lessons, imagining she is in Northumberland, hearing "the bubbling of a little brook" near her home, and this homesickness makes her a real child. Most tellingly, after the flogging Jane notices that "the trace of a tear glistened on her thin cheek". Helen's composure in public hides private pain, and the detail quietly shows the cost of her endurance.
Her faith is also less conventional than a stock saint's. She tells Jane, "I hold another creed: which no one ever taught me", in which Eternity is "a mighty home, not a terror and an abyss". This hopeful, private belief contrasts sharply with Mr. Brocklehurst's warnings of fire and brimstone, so Helen's goodness is not simply what Lowood teaches; it is partly a quiet departure from it.
Context suggests that Helen may be drawn from life rather than invented as an ideal. Elizabeth Gaskell, in her biography of Charlotte Brontë, wrote that Helen Burns was as exact a picture of Charlotte's eldest sister, Maria, as Charlotte's power of drawing character could make her. Maria fell ill at the Clergy Daughters' School at Cowan Bridge and died at home in 1825, aged eleven. If Gaskell is right, Helen's patience and early death may be a sister's memory rather than an invented ideal, though this is Gaskell's view rather than Charlotte's own statement.
Finally, Brontë does not present Helen as a model that Jane should simply copy. Jane admits, "I could not comprehend this doctrine of endurance" (Chapter 6), and Helen warns her that "you think too much of the love of human beings" (Chapter 8). Jane never adopts Helen's resignation: she leaves Thornfield, refuses St John and claims happiness on earth. Helen is a moral touchstone, not the novel's final answer.
Overall, I disagree with the statement. Helen is idealised in her patience and her death, and her speeches can seem too wise for her age, but Brontë gives her faults, a hidden tear and a creed of her own, and through Jane's resistance shows that her goodness, though admirable, is one way of living rather than the only true one.
Explanation
A top-level answer weighs the evidence that Helen is idealised (her patience under punishment, her sermon-like speech, her peaceful death) against the details that make her human (her confessed faults, her daydreams, the hidden tear, her own creed), analyses Brontë's methods in at least two well-chosen moments and reaches a judgement. Common errors are retelling Helen's story, writing about her death only (held to Level 3), and presenting Gaskell's view that Helen was based on Maria Brontë as a fact Charlotte stated.
Mark scheme
-
36 marks
Levels of response (36 marks). AO1 and AO2 are the equally dominant assessment objectives, with AO3 (OCR, J352/01 Section B). The response is marked holistically; AO4 is the separate SPaG point.
Level 6 (31-36 marks): Sustained critical style in an informed personal response to both text and task.
- Coherent critical style sustained in an informed personal response to the text, showing consistently perceptive understanding (AO1)
- Textual references and quotations are precise, pertinent and skilfully interwoven (AO1)
- Detailed and well-developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Consistently effective use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
- Perceptive and sensitive understanding of context and how it informs evaluation of the text (AO3)
Level 5 (25-30 marks): Convincing critical style in a well-developed personal response to both text and task.
- Convincing critical style maintained in a well-developed personal response to the text, showing some insightful understanding (AO1)
- Textual references and quotations are well-selected and fully integrated (AO1)
- Thoughtful and developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Good use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
- Convincing understanding of context which informs the response to the text (AO3)
Level 4 (19-24 marks), Level 3 (13-18 marks), Level 2 (7-12 marks), Level 1 (1-6 marks), 0 marks: OCR's descriptors for these are given word for word in the comments, straight after the limits on the mark.Max 18 if the answer refers to only one moment from the novel (OCR: "cannot move beyond Level 3"). Max 24 if it refers only briefly to a second moment (OCR: "cannot move beyond Level 4").
OCR's level descriptors (continued): Level 4 (19-24 marks): Credible critical style in a detailed personal response to both text and task.
- Some critical style demonstrated in a detailed personal response to the text, showing clear understanding (AO1)
- Relevant textual references and quotations are selected to support the response (AO1)
- Some analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Competent use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
- Clear understanding of context which informs the response to the text (AO3)
Level 3 (13-18 marks): A reasonably developed personal response to both text and task.
- Reasonably detailed personal response to the text showing understanding (AO1)
- Some use of relevant textual references and quotations to support the response (AO1)
- Reasonable explanation of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Some use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
- Some relevant comments about context inform the response to the text (AO3)
Level 2 (7-12 marks): A straightforward personal response to both text and task.
- Begins to develop a straightforward personal response to the text showing some understanding (AO1)
- Some relevant support from the text (AO1)
- Simple comments on writer's use of language, form or structure (AO2)
- Limited use of subject terminology (AO2)
- Some awareness of context, which may be implied (AO3)
Level 1 (1-6 marks): A basic response to both text and task.
- Makes a few relevant comments about the text (AO1)
- Makes limited references to the text (AO1)
- A little awareness of language, form or structure (AO2)
- Very little use of subject terminology (AO2)
- A little awareness of context implied, related to the text (AO3)
0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.Indicative content (OCR: "Please bear in mind that other content may be equally valid and should be credited."):
AO1:
- agreement: her calm under the flogging and her sermon-like speeches (Chapter 6); her patience with the "Slattern" label (Chapter 8); her peaceful death and the "Resurgam" tablet (Chapter 9)
- disagreement: the faults she confesses and her daydreams of Northumberland (Chapter 6); the private tear after the flogging; her unorthodox creed
- Jane's resistance to Helen's "doctrine of endurance" and Helen's warning about the "love of human beings" (Chapters 6 and 8)
- a personal judgement on whether Helen is idealised, believable, or both
AO2:
- balanced, abstract syntax that makes Helen sound like a preacher
- Jane's reactions as a foil ("unavailing and impotent anger")
- the list of confessed faults in short clauses; the tiny detail of the tear
- the single Latin word that closes her story
AO3:
- Gaskell's view that Helen was drawn from Charlotte's sister Maria, who fell ill at Cowan Bridge and died in 1825 (as Gaskell's view, not Charlotte's statement)
- Gaskell's record that Maria and Elizabeth were consumptive and that fever broke out at Cowan Bridge in spring 1825 -
4 marks
SPaG. AO4 (4 marks).
High performance (4 marks): In the context of the Level of Demand of the question, learners spell and punctuate with consistent accuracy, and consistently use vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve effective control of meaning.
Intermediate performance (2-3 marks): In the context of the Level of Demand of the question, learners spell and punctuate with considerable accuracy, and use a considerable range of vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve general control of meaning.
Threshold performance (1 mark): In the context of the Level of Demand of the question, learners spell and punctuate with reasonable accuracy, and use a reasonable range of vocabulary and sentence structures; any errors do not hinder meaning in the response.OCR's Marking Grid for AO4 (SPaG), J352 mark schemes June 2023-2025. AO4 is judged on the whole response: spelling, punctuation, and the range and control of vocabulary and sentence structures, in the context of the level of demand of the question. The grid starts at 1 mark: award 0 where the learner writes nothing or does not reach threshold performance. Content is credited only in the levels point.