Question 1
40 marksA Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens
You should spend about 45 minutes on this question.
'A Christmas Carol is too sentimental to be taken seriously.' How far do you agree with this view?
Explore at least two moments from the novel to support your ideas. [40]
4 of the 40 marks for this question are for spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of vocabulary and sentence structures (AO4).
Model answer
A Christmas Carol is openly sentimental: it asks its readers to weep over a disabled child, a loving poor family and a lonely old man who learns to cry. Some readers find moments such as Tiny Tim's blessing too sweet to bear. However, I disagree that this stops the novella being taken seriously, because Dickens places his sentiment beside harsh satire and disturbing images of poverty, and he uses feeling as a weapon to make comfortable readers act.
The case for the statement rests mainly on Tiny Tim. Bob reports Tim's wish that people in church would see him "because he was a cripple" and remember "who made lame beggars walk, and blind men see", a wish that makes him almost too saintly for a small boy, more a symbol of innocence than a believable child. In Stave 4 the effect is carefully orchestrated. Mrs. Cratchit's voice "only faltered once" as she says, "I have known him walk with--I have known him walk with Tiny Tim upon his shoulder, very fast indeed", and the children answer one by one, "And so have I," until "So had all." The broken repetition and the chorus of agreement work like a litany, and a reader can feel the scene being arranged for tears.
The narrator sometimes indulges feeling for its own sake. Watching Belle's daughter romp with the younger children in Stave 2, he cries, "What would I not have given to be one of them!", and imagines her hair as "a keepsake beyond price". The exclamations turn the narrator into a wistful onlooker, and the passage lingers on his emotions rather than Scrooge's. In Stave 4 Bob's grief is heightened by repetition, "My little, little child!", and the narrator ends the scene with an apostrophe, "Spirit of Tiny Tim, thy childish essence was from God!" The archaic "thy" and the direct address make the moment solemn, but a modern reader may feel that Dickens is pressing too hard on the reader's tears.
Yet the same book contains some of Dickens's most unsentimental writing. At the end of Stave 3 the Ghost reveals two children under its robe: "Yellow, meagre, ragged, scowling, wolfish". The list of five adjectives gives no comfort at all, and the antithesis "Where angels might have sat enthroned, devils lurked" shows childhood destroyed by neglect. These children are not sweet; they are frightening. A government report of February 1843 had revealed how children laboured in factories and workshops, and Dickens planned a cheap pamphlet on behalf of 'the Poor Man's Child', then changed his mind, writing that a 'Sledge hammer' would come down with far greater force if he waited. A Christmas Carol, published that December, can be read as that blow. The sentiment of the Cratchit scenes and the horror of Ignorance and Want are two halves of the same campaign.
Stave 4 is darker still and almost entirely free of sweetness. The businessmen will attend only "if a lunch is provided", and among old Joe's rags the charwoman explains why she stripped the corpse of its shirt: "If calico an't good enough for such a purpose, it isn't good enough for anything." Her coarse logic is black comedy, and it shows death without dignity or tears. Dickens is clearly capable of cold, satirical observation when he wants it.
Even Tiny Tim, the most sentimental figure, serves a hard argument. When Scrooge begs to know whether Tim will live, the Ghost answers with Scrooge's own words: "If he be like to die, he had better do it, and decrease the surplus population." The phrase echoes the economist Malthus's warning that the number of people outruns the supply of food, and by attaching it to one loved child Dickens turns an abstract theory into a death sentence. The sentiment is the point of the argument, not a distraction from it.
The ending is the most sentimental part of the book: "to Tiny Tim, who did NOT die, he was a second father". The capitals almost shout the happy news. Yet Dickens immediately undercuts his own sweetness with humour: "Some people laughed to see the alteration in him", and Scrooge "lived upon the Total Abstinence Principle", a joke about having nothing more to do with Spirits. The narrator knows that his story is a fable and invites the reader to smile at it.
Overall, I disagree with the view. A Christmas Carol is sentimental by design, and some moments, especially Tiny Tim's piety, may strike modern readers as excessive. But Dickens joins his sentiment to anger and satire, and the tears he asks for are meant to lead to action. A book that makes its readers feel for the poor man's child and then shows them Ignorance and Want is asking to be taken very seriously indeed.
Explanation
A top-level answer weighs the novella's sentimental moments (Tiny Tim, the narrator in Belle's family scene, Bob's grief, the ending) against its harsh satire and disturbing images (Ignorance and Want, old Joe's shop), analyses how language creates pathos, and links the debate to Dickens's purpose in 1843. Common errors are writing about one moment only (held to Level 3), praising or condemning sentimentality without evidence, and stating what Tiny Tim's illness was, which the novel never says.
Mark scheme
-
36 marks
Levels of response (36 marks). AO1 and AO2 are the equally dominant assessment objectives, with AO3 (OCR, J352/01 Section B). The response is marked holistically; AO4 is the separate SPaG point.
Level 6 (31-36 marks): Sustained critical style in an informed personal response to both text and task.
- Coherent critical style sustained in an informed personal response to the text, showing consistently perceptive understanding (AO1)
- Textual references and quotations are precise, pertinent and skilfully interwoven (AO1)
- Detailed and well-developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Consistently effective use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
- Perceptive and sensitive understanding of context and how it informs evaluation of the text (AO3)
Level 5 (25-30 marks): Convincing critical style in a well-developed personal response to both text and task.
- Convincing critical style maintained in a well-developed personal response to the text, showing some insightful understanding (AO1)
- Textual references and quotations are well-selected and fully integrated (AO1)
- Thoughtful and developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Good use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
- Convincing understanding of context which informs the response to the text (AO3)
Level 4 (19-24 marks), Level 3 (13-18 marks), Level 2 (7-12 marks), Level 1 (1-6 marks), 0 marks: OCR's descriptors for these are given word for word in the comments, straight after the limits on the mark.Max 18 if the answer refers to only one moment from the novel (OCR: "cannot move beyond Level 3"). Max 24 if it refers only briefly to a second moment (OCR: "cannot move beyond Level 4").
OCR's level descriptors (continued): Level 4 (19-24 marks): Credible critical style in a detailed personal response to both text and task.
- Some critical style demonstrated in a detailed personal response to the text, showing clear understanding (AO1)
- Relevant textual references and quotations are selected to support the response (AO1)
- Some analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Competent use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
- Clear understanding of context which informs the response to the text (AO3)
Level 3 (13-18 marks): A reasonably developed personal response to both text and task.
- Reasonably detailed personal response to the text showing understanding (AO1)
- Some use of relevant textual references and quotations to support the response (AO1)
- Reasonable explanation of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Some use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
- Some relevant comments about context inform the response to the text (AO3)
Level 2 (7-12 marks): A straightforward personal response to both text and task.
- Begins to develop a straightforward personal response to the text showing some understanding (AO1)
- Some relevant support from the text (AO1)
- Simple comments on writer's use of language, form or structure (AO2)
- Limited use of subject terminology (AO2)
- Some awareness of context, which may be implied (AO3)
Level 1 (1-6 marks): A basic response to both text and task.
- Makes a few relevant comments about the text (AO1)
- Makes limited references to the text (AO1)
- A little awareness of language, form or structure (AO2)
- Very little use of subject terminology (AO2)
- A little awareness of context implied, related to the text (AO3)
0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.Indicative content (OCR: "Please bear in mind that other content may be equally valid and should be credited."):
AO1:
- agreement: Tiny Tim's saintly wish in church (Stave 3); the family's chorus of memory (Stave 4); the narrator's longing in Belle's family scene (Stave 2); Bob's grief and the apostrophe to Tim's spirit (Stave 4); the ending (Stave 5)
- disagreement: Ignorance and Want (Stave 3); old Joe's shop and the businessmen's jokes (Stave 4); "surplus population" turned against Scrooge (Stave 3)
- the narrator's self-aware humour at the end
- a personal judgement on whether sentiment serves or weakens the message
AO2:
- the faltering repetition "I have known him walk with--" and the chorus "So had all."; exclamations such as "What would I not have given to be one of them!"
- the repetition "My little, little child!"; the apostrophe "Spirit of Tiny Tim"
- the list "Yellow, meagre, ragged, scowling, wolfish"; the antithesis of angels and devils
- black comedy in the charwoman's dialogue; capitals in "did NOT die"
AO3:
- the 1843 report on working children; Dickens's abandoned pamphlet for 'the Poor Man's Child' and his 'Sledge hammer' letter
- Malthus's population theory, echoed in "surplus population" -
4 marks
SPaG. AO4 (4 marks).
High performance (4 marks): In the context of the Level of Demand of the question, learners spell and punctuate with consistent accuracy, and consistently use vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve effective control of meaning.
Intermediate performance (2-3 marks): In the context of the Level of Demand of the question, learners spell and punctuate with considerable accuracy, and use a considerable range of vocabulary and sentence structures to achieve general control of meaning.
Threshold performance (1 mark): In the context of the Level of Demand of the question, learners spell and punctuate with reasonable accuracy, and use a reasonable range of vocabulary and sentence structures; any errors do not hinder meaning in the response.OCR's Marking Grid for AO4 (SPaG), J352 mark schemes June 2023-2025. AO4 is judged on the whole response: spelling, punctuation, and the range and control of vocabulary and sentence structures, in the context of the level of demand of the question. The grid starts at 1 mark: award 0 where the learner writes nothing or does not reach threshold performance. Content is credited only in the levels point.