Question 1
20 marksLeave Taking by Winsome Pinnock
You should spend about 30 minutes on this question.
Explore another moment in Leave Taking, not Brod's account of his nationality letter in Scene Two, where a character's loyalty to England is challenged. [20]
Model answer
A powerful challenge to loyalty comes in the row in Scene Two, after Del has come home from a night out and it has emerged that she has lost her job. What makes the moment rich is that the loyalty Del attacks is not blind patriotism but a bargain Enid believes she has made with England, and Pinnock lets Enid state her side of it before Del answers.
Enid's case comes first. "I work two jobs seven days a week", she says, so that her daughters can "dress like those children who have fathers", and she ends with the claim that people may laugh at her, but "they never laugh at you." The sentence sets the mother against the daughters: Enid has accepted humiliation herself so that her children will be spared it. Her loyalty to England is a deal. She keeps the rules, does the work and swallows the insults, and in return her daughters are meant to have a better life than hers.
Del's reply is that the bargain has failed on both sides. Her generation has not been spared: she describes managers who treat young Black people as "the lowest of the low", exactly the treatment Enid's sacrifices were meant to prevent. Nor has Enid been repaid. Del reminds her of "her works do at the hospital last Christmas", when the matron told Enid, in front of everyone, to clean up after a nurse who had been sick. Crucially, Del tells it as something the daughters saw - "We're having fun", she recalls, before the matron's order - so the humiliation Enid accepted for her children's sake was watched by those very children. Del's closing sarcasm about how much England loves her mother throws the bargain back in Enid's face.
Brod's presence gives the challenge another edge. He is the family's oldest friend, and early in the row, before England has even been mentioned, he warns that they will get nowhere by "fighting each other". The warning hangs over what follows: once Del turns from her job to England, the audience can see that whatever England has done to Enid and her daughters, the damage is now being done inside the family. Pinnock shows a challenge to loyalty to England becoming a quarrel between people who have suffered from the same thing.
Enid's response is the most surprising part of the moment. Viv tries to stop her sister, "Stop it, Del.", but Enid insists, "Let her talk. I'm listening." The two short, controlled sentences show a mother prepared to hear her bargain questioned, and she does not strike back at Del's case against England. The slap comes only when Del moves from England to her father: "No wonder Dad left you." Pinnock separates the two charges. Enid can listen to the claim that her loyalty has been wasted, but not to the claim that it cost her her husband.
By letting Enid state her bargain before Del attacks it, Pinnock makes the challenge to loyalty more than a daughter's rebellion. Del's words land because they use Enid's own experience as evidence, and because her mother, for once, listens. The moment presents loyalty to England as a price paid by one generation for the next, and asks whether the next generation thinks it was worth paying.
Explanation
A top-level answer explores one moment in which loyalty to England is challenged, such as Del's reply to Enid's list of sacrifices in Scene Two, analysing how Pinnock sets Enid's bargain against Del's evidence and stages Enid's response, with brief links to the wider play. Common errors are writing about Brod's nationality letter, which the question excludes and which earns no credit, and retelling the row without analysing how the challenge to England is presented.
Mark scheme
-
20 marks
Levels of response (20 marks). AO1 and AO2 are equally weighted (OCR, J352/01 Section A part (b)). The response is marked holistically.
Level 6 (18-20 marks): Sustained critical style in an informed personal response to both text and task.
- Coherent critical style sustained in an informed personal response to the text, showing consistently perceptive understanding (AO1)
- Textual references and quotations are precise, pertinent and skilfully interwoven (AO1)
- Detailed and well-developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Consistently effective use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
Level 5 (15-17 marks): Convincing critical style in a well-developed personal response to both text and task.
- Convincing critical style maintained in a well-developed personal response to the text, showing some insightful understanding (AO1)
- Textual references and quotations are well-selected and fully integrated (AO1)
- Thoughtful and developed analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Good use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
Level 4 (11-14 marks): Credible critical style in a detailed personal response to both text and task.
- Some critical style demonstrated in a detailed personal response to the text, showing clear understanding (AO1)
- Relevant textual references and quotations are selected to support the response (AO1)
- Some analysis of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Competent use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
Level 3 (7-10 marks), Level 2 (4-6 marks), Level 1 (1-3 marks), 0 marks: OCR's descriptors for these are given word for word in the comments, straight after the limits on the mark.Max 0 if the answer writes only about Brod's account of his nationality letter in Scene Two, the moment the question excludes (OCR: where a candidate has used only the part (a) extract, "the mark awarded should be 0"). References to that moment are ignored; only references to the rest of the play are credited.
OCR's level descriptors (continued): Level 3 (7-10 marks): A reasonably developed personal response to both text and task.
- Reasonably detailed personal response to the text showing understanding (AO1)
- Some use of relevant textual references and quotations to support the response (AO1)
- Reasonable explanation of writer's use of language, form and structure to create meanings and effects (AO2)
- Some use of relevant subject terminology (AO2)
Level 2 (4-6 marks): A straightforward personal response to both text and task.
- Begins to develop a straightforward personal response to the text showing some understanding (AO1)
- Some relevant support from the text (AO1)
- Simple comments on writer's use of language, form or structure (AO2)
- Limited use of subject terminology (AO2)
Level 1 (1-3 marks): A basic response to both text and task.
- Makes a few relevant comments about the text (AO1)
- Makes limited references to the text (AO1)
- A little awareness of language, form or structure (AO2)
- Very little use of subject terminology (AO2)
0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.Indicative content (OCR: "Please bear in mind that other content may be equally valid and should be credited."):
AO1:
- suitable moments: Del's answer to Enid's list of sacrifices, ending in the story of the hospital Christmas party (the Scene Two row); Brod telling Enid that the girls have "Caribbean souls" (Scene Two); Viv walking out of her English Literature exam (Scene Five); Enid's admission in Scene Eight that a Black woman in England goes unseen
- who challenges whom, and why: the younger generation's experience of racism set against the older generation's hope
- the effect on relationships: Enid hears the challenge out; the slap comes only at the mention of the girls' father
AO2:
- Enid's list of sacrifices and its claim ("they never laugh at you") against Del's reply ("the lowest of the low")
- Del's evidence from shared memory ("We're having fun") and her sarcasm about England's love
- short, controlled lines ("Let her talk. I'm listening.") and the slap placed after the charge about the father